RE: You should totally turn this into a poll.

Report problem with this ad

Apr 21, 2021
9:01:00pm

yahtzee Truly Addicted User

Report problem with this ad

yahtzee

Previous username: yahtzee26
Bio page: yahtzee
Joined: Nov 22, 2004
Last login: May 20, 2024
Total posts: 28,229 (3,616 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

One football game to save the world. Who's your QB?

Social Distance

4/21/21 8:54pm

RN post-Weber State. Nuf said.

mulletino

4/21/21 8:54pm

<< Deleted >>

yahtzee

4/21/21 8:56pm

Max Hall

cambo

4/21/21 8:55pm

There was a lot of CB rage over his lack of arm strenth.

mulletino

4/21/21 8:56pm

Yep..A lot of CBers don't enunciate the letter 'g'

yahtzee

4/21/21 8:59pm

I'm speaking to my people thus spelled phonetically.

mulletino

4/21/21 9:00pm

It was more his putting a game on the line maxing out his arm

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 9:10pm

Stremf

Gunga Galunga

4/21/21 10:09pm

Jackson Brown

TADOW

4/21/21 8:55pm

His one start was too memorable. I'm still trying to forget it!

SafetyFirst

4/22/21 11:42am

Beau Hoge

Grammar Police

4/21/21 8:56pm

Jacob Conover

Magathis

4/21/21 8:56pm

Half of these responses:

yahtzee

4/21/21 8:56pm

Christian Stewart

SJS

4/21/21 8:57pm

Best BYU QB between Hall and Wilson

Backcountry

4/21/21 9:24pm

Um, Taysom?

JKLCoug

4/21/21 9:31pm

He said QB, not gladiator.

Y05

4/21/21 9:33pm

The Thorterback

Backcountry

4/22/21 3:22am

This was the right response. Ha!

SinkingQuffa

4/22/21 5:44am

It's a great day to be a T-wolf!

BYUtka

4/21/21 10:06pm

Can we pick the year we're pulling them from? Or just overall career?

DeekLyfter

4/21/21 8:57pm

pick the year

Social Distance

4/21/21 8:58pm

Who are we playing in this football game?

DeekLyfter

4/21/21 8:59pm

The college football version of the Monstars

Social Distance

4/21/21 9:00pm

Well then, Taysom Hill from 2014, pre-broken leg.

DeekLyfter

4/21/21 9:10pm

I think post broken leg he is stronger.

Pangare

4/22/21 6:58am

Koy

rivercitycoug

4/21/21 8:57pm

Austin Kafentzis running the monster package all game.

DieHarder

4/21/21 8:57pm

At the very least run it several plays in a row on fourth down. They’ll never expect we’ll run it again and again...

Pistol Shrimp

4/21/21 9:28pm

If only there were a way to list the QBs and then have people vote on their pick

yahtzee

4/21/21 8:58pm

You should totally turn this into a poll.

Social Distance

4/21/21 9:00pm

RE: You should totally turn this into a poll.

yahtzee

4/21/21 9:01pm

The spirit of Jack Tuttle

Magathis

4/21/21 9:00pm

Taysom: the healthy Taysom that can leap tall buildings

AF Cougar

4/21/21 9:06pm

Healthy Sr. Taysom or Beck followed razor close by Hall and then Wilson

RUNBYU1

4/21/21 9:49pm

This^ As they actually were through the year, 2006 Beck. But maybe the “what if” version of Taysom.

mvtoro

4/22/21 1:17am

Probably right. I still think I might take Nebraska Taysom.

RUNBYU1

4/22/21 3:13pm

100% healthy Taysom hill

Tuskaloosa Cougar

4/22/21 7:22am

Riley Nelson

Ash

4/21/21 9:09pm

RE: One football game to save the world. Who's your QB?

kcca

4/21/21 9:13pm

I've narrowed it to two. Going to flip a coin to decide between

Y05

4/21/21 9:13pm

<< Deleted >>

DeekLyfter

4/21/21 9:14pm

Taysom, Hall, Beck, Wilson, Stewart...

BYU Fan

4/21/21 9:14pm

Zach. Hands-down.

SinkingQuffa

4/21/21 9:18pm

Sir Maximus. The guy was just a winner.

Backcountry

4/21/21 9:23pm

RE: Sir Maximus. The guy was just a winner.

Pangare

4/22/21 7:02am

...except for when he lost. I love Max, but he didn't exactly win the "big" ones

The Dark Knight

4/22/21 7:56am

Max hall

cougfanz

4/21/21 9:35pm

Hall

bluelands

4/21/21 9:38pm

Taysom Hill. With those stakes he gets the job done. The man is a warrior.

stenso

4/21/21 9:46pm

Taysom if we are playing Texas

BigYfan

4/21/21 9:57pm

Full healthy Taysom

Rat

4/21/21 10:04pm

Hall

climps

4/21/21 10:22pm

Jesus Christ

All-American

4/21/21 10:37pm

RE: Jesus Christ

SinkingQuffa

4/22/21 2:39am

Max would be way down the list

kimdaddy35

4/21/21 10:55pm

The question wasn’t “who is the best QB since 2001?”

Social Distance

4/21/21 11:44pm

Max Hall was bad in 3 games against Utah

kimdaddy35

4/22/21 1:09am

Yet he was still .500 against TCU/Utah in 6 games.

mulletino

4/22/21 1:15am

His team was .500. His individual performances were poor in most of his biggest games even at his peak.

mvtoro

4/22/21 1:20am

Against really athletic teams that BYU, as a program, is 0-11 against since 2009.

mulletino

4/22/21 1:53am

Sure. But are we talking team performance or QB performance? When we lost with Hall in those games it was often BECAUSE

mvtoro

4/22/21 2:07am

Unfortunately his 1-2 TCU record gets a lot worse when you look at the stats

SinkingQuffa

4/22/21 2:27am

And you are wrong. Is he the only QB to beat Utah twice since Detmer?

Backcountry

4/22/21 7:11am

Oklahoma and Utah 2007 and 2009 were defensive victories.

The Dark Knight

4/22/21 8:02am

RE: Max would be way down the list

Backcountry

4/22/21 7:09am

Post Superbowl MVP, Jets' Zach Wilson

7FootRussian

4/21/21 11:40pm

One game: healthy Taysom Hill; One play: Christian Stewart

BYUBandfan

4/22/21 12:33am

One play? Hail Magnum.

Y05

4/22/21 1:57am

You're right. Give me Tanner Mangum for the win!

BYUBandfan

4/22/21 9:45am

Taysom is a great option if you want passes to hit the dirt.

Backcountry

4/22/21 7:12am

<< Deleted >>

BrighamJung

4/22/21 6:37am

RE: One football game to save the world. Who's your QB?

mattpatt

4/22/21 7:35am

Senior John Beck is the easy answer, IMO.

The Dark Knight

4/22/21 7:58am

This is the truth, Hall over Beck is a joke. Hall had Collie, Pitta, and Unga

Diablo and Doc

4/22/21 12:22pm

McMahon--No Question.

lbmango

4/22/21 10:27am

I don’t know. 2001 McMahon had some physical issues that might limit him and concussions had taken their toll...

Posting on CougarBoard