What was Chuck Carlton's speculation?

Report problem with this ad

Jan 19, 2022
11:58:59am

nephicoug All-American

Report problem with this ad

nephicoug

Bio page: nephicoug
Joined: Mar 12, 2005
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 19,237 (10 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

This shouldn't be hard on Big 12 realignment. Here it is IMO:

nephicoug All-American

1/19/22 9:55am

And yet it will probably be......

crimedog

1/19/22 9:58am

I like it, although Baylor would probably have some issues with it as it groups

Bumpus Hound

1/19/22 9:59am

Yeah, swap TCU and Iowa St between the divisions

krindorr

1/19/22 10:02am

This balances out the area of each division the most equitably but

gmj81

1/19/22 10:18am

Exactly. The idea is to split the 4 Texas schools into each division evenly

nephicoug

1/19/22 10:20am

I guess that's just not the only concern for me...

krindorr

1/19/22 10:30am

You’re still playing 3-4 teams from other division every year depending on whether there’s 8-9 conference games

nephicoug

1/19/22 10:36am

RE: I like it, although Baylor would probably have some issues with it as it

BaylorBear

1/19/22 12:14pm

How do you see rivalries playing out in the new Big 12?

SLIVER

1/19/22 12:48pm

RE: How do you see rivalries playing out in the new Big 12?

BaylorBear

1/19/22 3:09pm

I think it'll be Houston for us. Our recent games have gotten chippy.

CougtheCreator

1/19/22 3:38pm

Stick Oklahoma in the West and Texas in the East for their last 2 years

nephicoug

1/19/22 9:59am

I think there's some argument at the margins there, but that's the basic idea

krindorr

1/19/22 10:01am

What is your Pods Idea?

newbie

1/19/22 10:07am

Only starts after Texas/Oklahoma leave, but would drive attention and help the conference

krindorr

1/19/22 10:12am

Hmm. . . I think I quite like this

Bumpus Hound

1/19/22 10:26am

You'd play the other teams a ton still though - against non-pod teams 78% of years (about what we play Utah now)

krindorr

1/19/22 10:35am

I like it

newbie

1/19/22 10:37am

Ok, so how do we get them talking about this? Would be the most compelling

Cougblau

1/19/22 12:38pm

How would you decide who gets the home game in the 9th conf game of season?

Cougblau

1/19/22 12:39pm

It just rotates on a schedule

krindorr

1/19/22 12:43pm

I really like this, but I do see a potential negative for the conference

thecave

1/19/22 1:24pm

Something that isn’t logistical but would be a solution to that is changing the

Slomojoe

1/19/22 1:29pm

That's potentially an issue with any divisional setup, this might actually be better in that regard

krindorr

1/19/22 1:39pm

True. That always exists. This just magnifies that risk a bit. Good point about

thecave

1/19/22 1:44pm

Would be a ton of fun. Plus I think the risk isn't that huge - here's a hypothetical of your scenario

krindorr

1/19/22 2:08pm

I think this should be the new BIG12 logo

IceCreamButt

1/19/22 10:03am

for personal reasons - I'm hoping BYU and OK state aren't in the same division

newbie

1/19/22 10:07am

About the only logical way to do it really and have a even split of the Texas

gmj81

1/19/22 10:16am

I’d probably lose TCU and add ISU. Otherwise, all the travel is in the other

Colorado

1/19/22 10:17am

The Texas schools need to split evenly in both divisions IMO

nephicoug

1/19/22 10:22am

Then pull another school into the other division. My point is that split is

Colorado

1/19/22 10:26am

Travel in a non-factor in football. I don't think you need divisions outside of football

nephicoug

1/19/22 10:28am

Boy, B12 needs Colorado State, maybe even New Mexico and Wyoming. ....

311polo

1/19/22 10:27am

No, Boise State as a travel partner....Boise State vs Colorado State in football

coot20

1/19/22 11:01am

Remember, no smurf turf allowed, that's a rule.

Mitty

1/19/22 3:34pm

Oh yes, would love to see CU or CSU. Wyoming is a non-starter though.

Mitty

1/19/22 3:34pm

I think Utah, Colorado, and the Arizona schools will be apart of the BigXII

BYUHgrad

1/19/22 4:35pm

Can't see that happening in a way that is good for BYU and the Big 12

krindorr

1/20/22 9:03am

NM and WYO can pound sand. Co St is interesting

Sic'Em Beers

1/23/22 6:52am

Yup, I agree. OU will be in the West and Texas in the East.

runningryan

1/19/22 11:25am

Had the same thought yesterday. Seems like a no brianer as long as you can get

SLIVER

1/19/22 11:31am

Agreed. Everyone will insist on having a part of Texas for recruiting.

Hill4Heisman

1/19/22 11:51am

I wouldn’t put too much into Chuck Carlton’s speculation.

runningryan

1/19/22 11:57am

What was Chuck Carlton's speculation?

nephicoug

1/19/22 11:58am

RE: What was Chuck Carlton's speculation?

runningryan

1/19/22 5:09pm

TCU and Baylor have one of the oldest and fiercest rivalries in college football

Six Foot Seven

1/19/22 12:43pm

Some of the oldest and fiercest rivalries in the country aren't even in the same conference

nephicoug

1/19/22 1:07pm

Many of these larger p5 conferences now have a 'crossover game' outside of their

gmj81

1/19/22 1:17pm

Yep. Especially if they go to 9 conference games - the 9th will be the permanent

nephicoug

1/19/22 2:33pm

With the exception of Baylor/TCU and maybe Kansas/Iowa St those don't seem like important rivalries

krindorr

1/19/22 2:41pm

North South more evenly distributes travel

Sale

1/19/22 1:44pm

Timezones are not your friend though.

gmj81

1/19/22 2:40pm

That is a valid point. Plus it allows all teams to have access to Texas

Sale

1/19/22 3:58pm

RE: North South more evenly distributes travel

runningryan

1/19/22 5:13pm

No that makes too much sense, we can't do that

BYU Grounds

1/19/22 2:45pm

This is the only possible answer. Yes it divides TCU and Baylor, but keeps

Mitty

1/19/22 3:28pm

The Texas division is gonna be a tough one however it's done, BUT

SinkingQuffa

1/19/22 4:00pm

Yes, but Baylor & TCU stay together. As much as we want

SinkingQuffa

1/19/22 3:56pm

Go Juab!

cougarapologist

1/19/22 4:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad