The numbers have shown the D is marginal over 4 games this year. And years prior

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 28, 2022
3:46:06pm

kotacoug Intervention Needed

The numbers have shown the D is marginal over 4 games this year. And years prior

No need for any exaggeration or manipulation.

You act like the defense gameplan for the Wyoming was great… it actually would have ranked in at #70 for defensive effectiveness. It’s games like Wyoming where we say look the D is ok… it’s not and personnel and coaching need to change.

Report problem with this ad

kotacoug

Bio page: kotacoug
Joined: Jul 20, 2002
Last login: Apr 30, 2024
Total posts: 80,539 (4,682 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Against Wyo BYU rushed 4 or 5 and sometimes 6. It didn't matter, the Wyo OL was

Hinta

9/28/22 10:04am

Speaking of ARod... can anyone explain his obsession with the short side of the field?

Coug

9/28/22 10:08am

And why was he calling a running play on 3rd and 6 in the 1st half when our

Hinta

9/28/22 10:10am

He said he called an RPO and they would go for it on 4th if they got more than 2

SUAVO

9/28/22 10:13am

Actually, he said Jaron should have taken the pass option (and had two receivers available).

kccougar

9/28/22 10:15am

That's what I was meaning when I said he should have kept it. Kept it to pass

SUAVO

9/28/22 10:45am

You guys know there is a weekly show called Coordinator's Corner where our coaches talk about things like this, right?

kccougar

9/28/22 10:14am

I'm amazed how many alleged BYU football fans have no idea about these shows

Mayor of Cougartown

9/28/22 10:26am

Do your think these shows can even come close to matching the CB Brain Trust?

King of Y

9/28/22 2:25pm

Here is the link:

King Boo

9/28/22 11:59am

He admitted to being obsessed with the run game when

Archaea

9/28/22 10:11am

He learned that from Grimes

mudpupper

9/28/22 10:31am

Who learned it from Crowton

Longhaul

9/28/22 11:42am

Right?! That should be the exception, not the rule. Something to surprise the D

canofpicante

9/28/22 12:10pm

I thought I was the only one who pondered this mystery. It is truly odd

9/28/22 5:13pm

Could be high scoring, but doesn't Arkansas has a horrible defense as well. I

SUAVO

9/28/22 10:10am

I would predict both ND and Arkansas to win but I wouldn't be

Archaea

9/28/22 10:12am

Bad pass defense, good rush defense and great at getting sacks

gohogs14

9/28/22 11:28am

They averaged 3.6 yards per rush, and that was after the awful first quarter where they averaged over 7. The D tightened

cheezedawg

9/28/22 10:11am

I feel like our D figured it out after the 1st quarter. I wonder what their yards per rush were each quarter.

HarlemCoug

9/28/22 10:13am

For second half it was over 5 yds/carry

Goliath

9/28/22 10:19am

RE: For second half it was over 5 yds/carry

cheezedawg

9/28/22 12:19pm

I copied from espn

Goliath

9/28/22 12:47pm

They just put the number of yards, you have to look at the start and end lines to figure +/-

molodyets

9/28/22 12:50pm

Yup. It will say a rush for 3 yards on 1st and 10 and then the next play is 2nd and 13.

cheezedawg

9/28/22 12:53pm

Correct. I didn't recognize that when I first looked at it.

Goliath

9/28/22 1:29pm

Not really. If that stat is true, it's only because sacks are included.

Goliath

9/28/22 10:18am

That’s not what the stats show. They rushed for 23 yards in the 2nd half or 2 yards per carry. That includes 1 sack for

cheezedawg

9/28/22 12:15pm

BYU got one sack for a loss of 7 yards.

slatecoug

9/28/22 3:04pm

Different DL against ND and Ark

HudspethEra

9/28/22 10:14am

Pili played all of the wyoming game. I think you mean Tooley

Mayor of Cougartown

9/28/22 10:27am

But Utah State could injure more of our D

CharlottesvilleCoug

9/28/22 12:13pm

Fun narrative. In truth after the first drive Wyoming run game was shut down

Blueto

9/28/22 10:15am

Only if you include sacks. So not really the full story

Goliath

9/28/22 10:20am

But including sacks is the part of the game/full story.:)

basman

9/28/22 10:22am

Absolutely agree. But a complete picture breaks down which is which

Goliath

9/28/22 10:24am

Stop with the facts. The tuiaki defenders will find any excuse to validate his

kotacoug

9/28/22 10:44am

Give me the facts on rushing yards in the 2nd half.

Bluedarts

9/28/22 2:04pm

You can't compare BYU breaking down the various groupings to generally available

NYC and Japan

9/28/22 1:09pm

Tell me you didn't watch the whole game without telling me you didn't watch the

Bluedarts

9/28/22 2:02pm

Yes. If you take out sacks, tfls, or tackles after short gains....it looks bad.

Blueto

9/28/22 10:31am

That's clever

Goliath

9/28/22 10:34am

but those are things that happened in the game so maybe don't take them all out?

Mayor of Cougartown

9/28/22 10:46am

The original post was talking about rushing attempts. Taking out sac yardage is

kotacoug

9/28/22 10:51am

yeah not sure why the college game hasn't changed like the NFL has.

Mayor of Cougartown

9/28/22 10:52am

When a person is trying every possible way to excuse poor coaching they will

kotacoug

9/28/22 10:55am

It's you whiners who constantly need to manipulate the data. After their first

Blueto

9/28/22 11:24am

He's got a point, despite the eyeroll...

Bluedarts

9/28/22 2:06pm

No manipulation needed. Cold hard facts show that the D is marginal at best. The

kotacoug

9/28/22 2:41pm

Yes because BYU knew ahead of time exactly what Wyoming was going to run on O.

slatecoug

9/28/22 3:02pm

There was 3 games to see what the 100 ranked offensive team in the country

kotacoug

9/28/22 3:03pm

Yes because teams only run the same plays they have already run that season and take the exact same approach they have..

slatecoug

9/28/22 3:59pm

You aren’t saying anything that we don’t all know. Good/great DCs show that they

kotacoug

9/28/22 4:09pm

How about... We've only lost 5 games in the last 3 years and we've been ranked in the top 25 most of the time.

HarlemCoug

9/28/22 4:17pm

If you owned some real estate in NY and part of your book wasn’t giving you the

kotacoug

9/28/22 4:52pm

None of us have the data we need to want Tuiaki gone. We might have a 1/3rd of the total data. If Tom/Kalani want him

HarlemCoug

9/28/22 5:02pm

Don’t mistake me complaining about the D as not enjoying the season. The past

kotacoug

9/28/22 5:45pm

If not for the clearly incompetent/biased officials, the BYU D would have held Wyoming to 10 points

slatecoug

9/28/22 10:58pm

See manipulation. After ONE drive it was shut down. ONE. Not a quarter and a

Blueto

9/28/22 3:04pm

1 yard is 1 too many!!!

Bluedarts

9/28/22 3:25pm

Go ask the most dominant D in the country about Kent State

BYU313

9/28/22 3:05pm

I’ve posted over and over about actual numbers like DFEI and PPD allowed which

kotacoug

9/28/22 3:54pm

Recruiting with very little support staff and an Indy label is difficult. Classes will get better going forward or

HarlemCoug

9/28/22 3:57pm

You love DFEI, except for 2019 when it had us top ten. But you need to ignore

Blueto

9/28/22 4:00pm

DFEI for 2019 was a rank of #66. Are you trying to manipulate numbers?

kotacoug

9/28/22 4:11pm

Just checked on ESPN and its actually #55

BYU313

9/29/22 6:39am

Why did we let them gain any yards at all? Sheesh! Also kinda sucks that our

Bluedarts

9/28/22 3:24pm

The numbers have shown the D is marginal over 4 games this year. And years prior

kotacoug

9/28/22 3:46pm

I have literally never claimed that. But, after a quick 10 points, the defense

Bluedarts

9/28/22 3:56pm

BYU had 1 sack for a 7 yard loss.

slatecoug

9/28/22 3:03pm

You paint a false picture

FMOCIE

9/28/22 11:27am

Did you even read the OP? He stated our run defense sucked and the only thing

Blueto

9/28/22 12:11pm

I think the run defense was ineffective for 1st half, you don’t have to paint a

FMOCIE

9/28/22 12:19pm

But you're not painting the entire picture. Their 2nd drive they also rushed 3

Blueto

9/28/22 12:28pm

Well... The 8 yard part sucks, but the rest is awesome. Love it! Hope to see

NYC and Japan

9/28/22 1:13pm

Is that a prophecy, prediction, feared outcome or something else? I assume you

basman

9/28/22 10:21am

The run defense was very good in the second half

JOPE

9/28/22 10:22am

If surrendering over 5 yds/carry is very good, then I guess

Goliath

9/28/22 10:25am

Our offense scoring forced Wyoming to do what they are horrible at. Passing…

kotacoug

9/28/22 10:46am

My unofficial count shows 10 rushes for 36 yards in the second half when

bluescholar

9/28/22 11:34am

RE: My unofficial count shows 10 rushes for 36 yards in the second half when

Goliath

9/28/22 11:41am

You have a 3, 2, and 7 that should be -3, -2, and -7, which results in 36.

bluescholar

9/28/22 11:50am

Hmmm..I just copied from the play by play

Goliath

9/28/22 11:56am

Caught red handed. Not surprised. I've been told multiple times that we were

Bluedarts

9/28/22 2:10pm

Your characterization of the run D isn't accurate.

LifeLongLakerFan

9/28/22 10:52am

i mean, that's not what happened and after the first 2 drives we stuffed the run game.

molodyets

9/28/22 11:35am

Go back and look at 3rd drive they ran it effectively

FMOCIE

9/28/22 11:43am

Did you go to a school that actually teaches math? Might want to rerun those #s.

Bluedarts

9/28/22 2:15pm

Why don’t you tell me what the DFEI ranking is for BYU? No manipulated data with

kotacoug

9/28/22 2:57pm

Losing arguments eh? Time to pivot! I'm guessing it's average though, which is

Bluedarts

9/28/22 3:29pm

Actually there are people who are claiming it is better than it is. Compared to

kotacoug

9/28/22 3:51pm

Our O has benefited greatly by elite QB play. I don't see much difference between O and D recruiting. Curious if you

HarlemCoug

9/28/22 3:59pm

I don’t but it would be interesting. You could probably argue that elite

kotacoug

9/28/22 4:47pm

LOL at the idea that recruiting kids to play defense at BYU is the same as for

Bluedarts

9/28/22 4:05pm

Why?

kotacoug

9/28/22 5:48pm

What is byu known for?

Bluedarts

9/28/22 10:04pm

Hey jerk, I've never claimed its not average...why are you so happy we're avg?

FMOCIE

9/29/22 6:55am

RE: Hey jerk, I've never claimed its not average...why are you so happy we're

Bluedarts

9/29/22 10:57am

#55 isnt bad

BYU313

9/28/22 3:33pm

DFEI #60

kotacoug

9/28/22 3:50pm

Do you even look at the stats? They only got 124 yds rushing, 3.6 carry, what

Jasbo

9/28/22 12:00pm

It's apparent after 4 games that the online is not as good as advertised

SoValleyCOUG

9/28/22 1:47pm

Now THAT's probably something worth discussing more than the usual "fire Tuiaki"

Bluedarts

9/28/22 2:19pm

Hey as soon as the D gets ranked any where close to the offense ranking let’s

kotacoug

9/28/22 2:47pm

OK, well then, staying relevant to my post, how does our run game rank?

Bluedarts

9/28/22 3:34pm

Still waiting.

Bluedarts

9/28/22 3:40pm

Well if you really want to know we rank #81 in yds per rush allowed so…

kotacoug

9/28/22 4:02pm

He asked about our rushing attack

slatecoug

9/28/22 4:03pm

I thought we were talking about defense.

kotacoug

9/28/22 4:15pm

I was talking about the run game in my post, and you said let me know when the

Bluedarts

9/28/22 4:21pm

The offense is significantly better than the defense I don’t care if our rushing

kotacoug

9/28/22 5:43pm

The BYU O is ranked #41 in Total O. The BYU D is ranked #37 in Total D.

slatecoug

9/28/22 10:59pm

Lol no one uses those analytics to evaluate Too generalized…..

kotacoug

9/29/22 8:44am

You are correct, I was on TBS back in the day. I even kept the same board name

slatecoug

9/29/22 1:49pm

RE: The offense is significantly better than the defense I don’t care if

Bluedarts

9/28/22 11:53pm

Sorry if that’s too difficult to understand…. Let me spell it out….

kotacoug

9/29/22 8:45am

BYU is #81 in rushing yards allowed/game. The BYU D is #59 rushing yards/attempt

slatecoug

9/28/22 4:09pm

#78 in rushing yards allowed per rush according to ESPN.

kotacoug

9/28/22 6:06pm

ESPN also has BYU as #34 in Total D, but the NCAA has BYU at #37 in Total D.

slatecoug

9/28/22 11:04pm

Our run game and in particular our RB's have underperformed in 2 of the 4 games this year.

slatecoug

9/28/22 4:02pm

BYU ran for 17 more yards on 10 fewer carries against Wyoming than Air Force did the week before.

slatecoug

9/28/22 2:34pm

You may be right. There was a glimmer of hope with Davis, but it also might have

Bluedarts

9/28/22 3:39pm

BYU only ran 63 plays on O for the entire game. Why would Wyoming be tired?

slatecoug

9/28/22 3:55pm

Rushing is Wyoming’s bread and butter. They’re not a terrible team and we did pretty well shutting them down later in

Rat

9/28/22 2:47pm

When Wyo scored to take the lead 10-7 with 13:03 to go in the in the second quarter Wyo had 101 rushing yards.

slatecoug

9/28/22 3:00pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad