that he was just a singles and doubles hitter. .409 career slugging says a lot about him. And look, in his prime he was excellent, which is why he played in all-star games and won an MVP. I'm not arguing that he wasn't very good. There are tons of guys who aren't top-100 players who have similar non-longevity accomplishments.

And by the way, playing a lot of games at a lot of different positions on the low end of the defensive spectrum isn't something to brag about.