Some good reading, regardless of where you stand on this issue:

Aug 28, 2014
9:42:35pm

ataylor

http://www.si.com/football/2013/09/25/kyle-van-noy-excerpt-system
http://www.si.com/college-football/2013/09/25/spencer-hadley-byu

Report problem with this ad

ataylor

Bio page: ataylor
Joined: Apr 20, 2009
Last login: May 16, 2020
Total posts: 33,802 (2,404 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I do not understand the relationship between HC & Athlete at BYU

YLife

8/28/14 9:08pm

I agree.

Blueto

8/28/14 9:10pm

good post

Cougarealist

8/28/14 9:11pm

I wouldn't mind a review of the HC. But I don't buy the comparison

Y'zFan

8/28/14 9:15pm

When it comes to morality issues, I agree with the comparison.

blackandblue

8/28/14 9:18pm

Non-LDS students are granted more leeway.

goldy-loak

8/28/14 9:16pm

I personally know a non lds foreign student

1984coug

8/28/14 11:01pm

Why do you feel sad for JJ? He knew the consequences of his actions and

byubyu

8/28/14 9:18pm

I soooooo wish I personally knew you

San Juan Sun

8/28/14 9:28pm

I have a feeling that if we knew everything the coaching staff knows,

ataylor

8/28/14 9:31pm

Not talking about the coaching staff, talking about CB.

San Juan Sun

8/28/14 9:36pm

Proud of the fact that Brandon was suspended? Or proud of BYU for sticking to

ataylor

8/28/14 9:41pm

What I've heard about the coaching staff confirms this.

runnincoug

8/28/14 9:36pm

I do agree with this.

Zach Morris

8/28/14 9:46pm

You guys act like he was somehow wronged by BYU. He wasn't.

byubyu

8/28/14 9:35pm

Link where I said that?

San Juan Sun

8/28/14 9:37pm

"I just wish that mercy beat out justice once in awhile."

byubyu

8/28/14 9:38pm

fail

San Juan Sun

8/28/14 9:39pm

How do you know he wasn't?

kingpin2k

8/28/14 10:45pm

Wow, and I'm sure you've never made a mistake during your entire life.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

8/28/14 9:48pm

Made plenty. Didn't have a bunch of grown men whining about the consequences.

byubyu

8/28/14 9:57pm

We're not groaning about the consequences.

TSH_Rapid_Resp_Team

8/28/14 10:03pm

Read the original post- "punishment doesn't fit the crime" "too harsh"

byubyu

8/28/14 10:09pm

Hahah love it

MtnMan

8/28/14 10:45pm

How do you know he knew the consequences of his actions?

kingpin2k

8/28/14 10:40pm

While there are elements of the honor code that could use some tweaking,

ataylor

8/28/14 9:21pm

Lets look at the facts.

PolarisPrime

8/28/14 9:40pm

Some good reading, regardless of where you stand on this issue:

ataylor

8/28/14 9:42pm

RE: Some good reading, regardless of where you stand on this issue:

Archaea

8/28/14 10:28pm

How many are saved because we didn't go easy on them?

StantonMac

8/28/14 11:11pm

I seem to hear about Bronco handling things internally, giving second chances,

Preppy

8/28/14 11:22pm

I would rather he deal with them than the HCO

Archaea

8/29/14 12:26pm

Bronco makes it sound like he has set conditions back to the team...not the HCO.

Preppy

8/31/14 9:54pm

Not sure you have a strong grasp of what it means to "show compassion"

goldy-loak

8/29/14 7:36am

or a different interpretation than you. A lot of hubris on your part, to argue

Archaea

8/29/14 12:27pm

Honor code has served us well. Take away the honor code and we're nothing.

canofpicante

8/28/14 9:59pm

Williams was not suspended the first time he got caught either.

StantonMac

8/28/14 11:14pm

We would hardly become ASU if we had temple standards. Your post is naive

HoustonCougar

8/28/14 11:25pm

You think these players were suspended because of outdated HC policies? HAHAHAHA

Preppy

8/28/14 10:25pm

"If a person can go to the temple but not be allowed into the testing center"

Harrison0Yfan

8/28/14 10:45pm

RE: "If a person can go to the temple but not be allowed into the testing

jerseyblue

8/29/14 2:58am

Differences between the temple and the HC

Harrison0Yfan

8/29/14 10:48am

I could live under a bridge,

PolarisPrime

8/31/14 10:54pm

A lot of faulty logic above

BenCahoon

8/28/14 10:55pm

What he said.

Sooner Cougar

8/29/14 12:59am

You said it yourself...

cougarmikey

8/28/14 11:37pm

boohoo, "I don't know how he'll get over it", been in the system for more than

Posting on CougarBoard