As a runner and in terms of athleticism, he's as good as it gets. As a passer in his second year as a starter, he's not where he needs to be for BYU to beat top flight competition, or for him to play pro ball. He's behind the curve. I think the scheme is partially responsible.
I think we're a good team, and the teams we've played have been good, but not top 25 material, aka mediocre.