I was trying to generate a discussion with someone who knows the law. The illegal immigrant part is what had me confused because I wasn't sure if there was some kind of process to paying someone that was deported. He gave me an ETIN # to pay him at the beginning of the year...but it turns out it was for his cousin. So, in essence I wanted advice on how to proceed with someone who did crappy work, and also what I should go about doing in terms of paying him what I think he deserves considering he was deported and gave a false ETIN.

I didn't include everything in the original post so I see why people have their various opinions.