My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 30, 2015
10:32
:44
am
rggee
All-American
He was pushed, but I think he would have plowed right through the guy anyway.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
rggee
New username
RGGeemer
Bio page
rggee
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Last login
Aug 29, 2021
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Kick-Catch Interference call - wasn't BYU guy blocked/pushed into USU returner?
CosmoK
11/30/15 10:31am
Yes he was. It was a missed call. Should have at least reviewed it.
Turnpike Lane
11/30/15 10:32am
Don't believe that is reviewable
mogelijk
11/30/15 10:47am
On TV it was the same idiots who did the SJSU game.
foofcoug
11/30/15 10:32am
At least they figured out the whole "Tanner" thing
fulano
11/30/15 10:35am
got hit but IMO he was going to get the penalty anyway.
MormonThug
11/30/15 10:32am
He was going to run past him to the left of him.
Turnpike Lane
11/30/15 10:34am
That's what I saw too.
Eddie
11/30/15 10:35am
I think this is plausible.
Bob Vance
11/30/15 10:35am
That's what it looked like to me, too. If Davis had been running to the
dilbert
11/30/15 10:38am
Wait - that was Davis?!?
Eddie
11/30/15 10:42am
Maybe so but it doesn't matter.
Walter Bellhaven
11/30/15 10:47am
I think the rule is "not a penalty" in that situation.
CosmoK
11/30/15 10:54am
He was pushed, but I think he would have plowed right through the guy anyway.
rggee
11/30/15 10:32am
Agreed. If any real push would've taken place, it would've only pushed him AWAY
ByuMba90
11/30/15 10:34am
he was blocked but I thought he was gonna hit him anyway. Not sure if refs
fulano
11/30/15 10:33am
Kind of how I saw it, but it also looked like he might have had a chance to race
Bob Vance
11/30/15 10:34am
Maybe so. If he had started to pull up it would have been obvious
fulano
11/30/15 10:35am
He wasn't trying to pull up. He didn't intend to pull up.
Eddie
11/30/15 10:40am
Maybe. If I'm a ref in that game I throw the flag there. Just my opinion
fulano
11/30/15 10:42am
While completely ignoring the illegal block in the back to make it happen?
Eddie
11/30/15 11:27am
he was pushed, but i think his intention was to steam roll him anyways
BlueFrog
11/30/15 10:33am
he'd still have hit him.
johnnycarson
11/30/15 10:34am
you're all wrong ^^^. This is Davis we're talking about
Beggar
11/30/15 10:36am
Davis was running out to the sidelines to get a drink, and just happen to run in
BlueFrog
11/30/15 10:37am
RE: Davis was running out to the sidelines to get a drink, and just happen to
nitroboy
11/30/15 11:33am
FWIW: The play is at about 2:02 in Cougazul's highlights:
frontrowcougar
11/30/15 10:39am
IMO, the replay makes the case for "no penalty" more than for "penalty".
CosmoK
11/30/15 11:02am
To me it looks like he is lowering his shoulder ready to pummel the guy. He did
rggee
11/30/15 11:09am
You would have a better chance at convincing me...IF...and this is a big if...
Eddie
11/30/15 11:34am
While Davis is not a physical defender, he did have a hit like your describe
dilbert
11/30/15 11:54am
After looking at the replay, I think the "lowered shoulder" is a side effect of
Spine
11/30/15 11:51am
Looking frame by frame at the replay and he starts to his right of the return
Spine
11/30/15 11:44am
Davis doesn't go into the hit like a guy who wants to nail somebody.
beebs4lyfe
11/30/15 10:49am
RE: Kick-Catch Interference call - wasn't BYU guy blocked/pushed into USU
skardem
11/30/15 11:36am
His momentum would have carried him into the defender despite the block.
SpecialT
11/30/15 12:47pm
Yes
Coug Dude
11/30/15 1:24pm
Wasn't it also a block in the back. Missed that too.
Count Cougar
11/30/15 1:34pm
Guy got pushed, in fairness Davis was at full speed and was gonna hit him early
gww687
11/30/15 3:30pm
You cant make a call based on what you think might have happened.
Count Cougar
11/30/15 3:58pm
Not exactly what I am trying to say
gww687
11/30/15 4:04pm
I think a lot of folks here are missing the fact that a field is not linear.
Eddie
11/30/15 4:09pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
