My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 30, 2015
10:33
:55
am
BlueFrog
All-American
he was pushed, but i think his intention was to steam roll him anyways
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
BlueFrog
Bio page
BlueFrog
Joined
Sep 5, 2010
Last login
Feb 17, 2021
Total posts
102,537 (26,273 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Kick-Catch Interference call - wasn't BYU guy blocked/pushed into USU returner?
CosmoK
11/30/15 10:31am
Yes he was. It was a missed call. Should have at least reviewed it.
Turnpike Lane
11/30/15 10:32am
Don't believe that is reviewable
mogelijk
11/30/15 10:47am
On TV it was the same idiots who did the SJSU game.
foofcoug
11/30/15 10:32am
At least they figured out the whole "Tanner" thing
fulano
11/30/15 10:35am
got hit but IMO he was going to get the penalty anyway.
MormonThug
11/30/15 10:32am
He was going to run past him to the left of him.
Turnpike Lane
11/30/15 10:34am
That's what I saw too.
Eddie
11/30/15 10:35am
I think this is plausible.
Bob Vance
11/30/15 10:35am
That's what it looked like to me, too. If Davis had been running to the
dilbert
11/30/15 10:38am
Wait - that was Davis?!?
Eddie
11/30/15 10:42am
Maybe so but it doesn't matter.
Walter Bellhaven
11/30/15 10:47am
I think the rule is "not a penalty" in that situation.
CosmoK
11/30/15 10:54am
He was pushed, but I think he would have plowed right through the guy anyway.
rggee
11/30/15 10:32am
Agreed. If any real push would've taken place, it would've only pushed him AWAY
ByuMba90
11/30/15 10:34am
he was blocked but I thought he was gonna hit him anyway. Not sure if refs
fulano
11/30/15 10:33am
Kind of how I saw it, but it also looked like he might have had a chance to race
Bob Vance
11/30/15 10:34am
Maybe so. If he had started to pull up it would have been obvious
fulano
11/30/15 10:35am
He wasn't trying to pull up. He didn't intend to pull up.
Eddie
11/30/15 10:40am
Maybe. If I'm a ref in that game I throw the flag there. Just my opinion
fulano
11/30/15 10:42am
While completely ignoring the illegal block in the back to make it happen?
Eddie
11/30/15 11:27am
he was pushed, but i think his intention was to steam roll him anyways
BlueFrog
11/30/15 10:33am
he'd still have hit him.
johnnycarson
11/30/15 10:34am
you're all wrong ^^^. This is Davis we're talking about
Beggar
11/30/15 10:36am
Davis was running out to the sidelines to get a drink, and just happen to run in
BlueFrog
11/30/15 10:37am
RE: Davis was running out to the sidelines to get a drink, and just happen to
nitroboy
11/30/15 11:33am
FWIW: The play is at about 2:02 in Cougazul's highlights:
frontrowcougar
11/30/15 10:39am
IMO, the replay makes the case for "no penalty" more than for "penalty".
CosmoK
11/30/15 11:02am
To me it looks like he is lowering his shoulder ready to pummel the guy. He did
rggee
11/30/15 11:09am
You would have a better chance at convincing me...IF...and this is a big if...
Eddie
11/30/15 11:34am
While Davis is not a physical defender, he did have a hit like your describe
dilbert
11/30/15 11:54am
After looking at the replay, I think the "lowered shoulder" is a side effect of
Spine
11/30/15 11:51am
Looking frame by frame at the replay and he starts to his right of the return
Spine
11/30/15 11:44am
Davis doesn't go into the hit like a guy who wants to nail somebody.
beebs4lyfe
11/30/15 10:49am
RE: Kick-Catch Interference call - wasn't BYU guy blocked/pushed into USU
skardem
11/30/15 11:36am
His momentum would have carried him into the defender despite the block.
SpecialT
11/30/15 12:47pm
Yes
Coug Dude
11/30/15 1:24pm
Wasn't it also a block in the back. Missed that too.
Count Cougar
11/30/15 1:34pm
Guy got pushed, in fairness Davis was at full speed and was gonna hit him early
gww687
11/30/15 3:30pm
You cant make a call based on what you think might have happened.
Count Cougar
11/30/15 3:58pm
Not exactly what I am trying to say
gww687
11/30/15 4:04pm
I think a lot of folks here are missing the fact that a field is not linear.
Eddie
11/30/15 4:09pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
