Judging recruits based on their first year? That's smart. Or on top of that, the fact that you judged a WR without considering the QB/OL. You judged a DT without considering a major injury. And you judged a random freshman who was never expected to contribute in his first year. He was already a thin LB and they moved him to TE. He was a guy who was going to just be a part of the program for a year then leave on his mission.
Yeah great choices.