My Account
Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 17, 2020
12:33
:33
am
BYUHawk
All-American
^^^THIS. Implement a 90 second rule. If you can't confidently overturn it in 90
seconds then the call stands.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
BYUHawk
Bio page
BYUHawk
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Last login
Oct 31, 2024
Total posts
7,375 (112 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Critical officiating mistakes:
The Y's Insider
10/17/20 12:08am
RE: Critical officiating mistakes:
FT487
10/17/20 12:10am
Big 12. Holgerson cussed in the post game when brought up. Not a fan of them
thegoodmeister
10/17/20 3:01am
Didn’t get enough calls for his money?
AZcougLawyer
10/17/20 3:44am
And approximately half the game was spent with the refs huddled up trying to figure out what happened
bag
10/17/20 12:10am
So painful. I was annoyed with it when we were winning, it became almost
cougsareforreal
10/17/20 6:17am
Late hit oob was bad too.
bluecheese
10/17/20 12:10am
Meh. My biggest beef was how long they talked about every stinking penalty.
hxmCougar2000
10/17/20 12:10am
^^^THIS. Implement a 90 second rule. If you can't confidently overturn it in 90
BYUHawk
10/17/20 12:33am
One reason the NFL is more watchable. They try to fit games in 3 hr windows,
The Chelsea Dagger
10/17/20 2:05am
Glad I'm not alone. I thought these same things. BYU struggled during this time.
Benfica1
10/17/20 12:10am
Block in the back was legit on Cosper. Not Barrington.
Turnpike Lane
10/17/20 12:10am
Yes the illegal block was further upfield, not on the LOS
Dan
10/17/20 2:08am
They may call it a "block" but he hardly touched him. Literally.
BleedCougarBlue2
10/17/20 9:14am
Dude flopped. He totally sold the call.
whoneedscorners?
10/17/20 10:03am
Interfering with a opportunity tocatch a punt was a terrible call. It was muffed
BostonCougar
10/17/20 12:10am
This was a bad call in our favor.
bythenumbers
10/17/20 12:11am
Which makes it a good call. 😉
blueaussie
10/17/20 7:35am
It gave us 15 yards, but I think we recovered anyway, so it didn’t negate a TO
Trent
10/17/20 10:34am
Why? The players were within a yard (the rule).
Benfica1
10/17/20 12:11am
I don’t think so
bag
10/17/20 12:11am
The kick catch interference? How so? The guys foot was almost stepping on Milne
byusage
10/17/20 12:12am
It was one that technically was a penalty but you rarely see it called unless
bythenumbers
10/17/20 12:14am
No way- contact is not neccesary. A rule is a rule and that one wasn't even
byusage
10/17/20 12:15am
Again, I realize the rule, but you rarely see it called without contact
bythenumbers
10/17/20 12:17am
What did we get bailed out from? We recovered.
5150man
10/17/20 12:22am
I think it was called BECAUSE he muffed it. They threw it late and would not
Zooropa
10/17/20 12:27am
Totally agree with this, and you see that happen in this situation
bythenumbers
10/17/20 12:29am
I was officiating a HS game a couple weeks ago, on a long pass play in the final
goobermcmonkey
10/17/20 10:50am
Actually, you rarely see it UNLESS there is a fumble.
Benfica1
10/17/20 8:57am
It's true but you do see it called when there's obvious contact even with catch
bythenumbers
10/17/20 9:10am
ESPN announcers said bubble is 1 yd in front & shoulder pad width to the sides.
BleedCougarBlue2
10/17/20 9:17am
Look at the photo - sure looks close to me
bythenumbers
10/17/20 9:28am
Almost knocked knees.
Benfica1
10/17/20 9:31am
Yep. Good call. Luckily, if they had not called it, we (amazingly) recovered it.
BleedCougarBlue2
10/17/20 10:31am
It seemed like maybe it was called because not only was he w/i the window, but
Trent
10/17/20 10:36am
No way. Not on a fair catch. Easy call.
The Y's Insider
10/17/20 12:17am
Didn’t we recover anyways?
cougarblue
10/17/20 12:12am
Yes.
Benfica1
10/17/20 12:15am
Can you explain? It fit the rule exactly.
Lip Gallagher
10/17/20 12:13am
It seemed marginal but could have gone either way.
IceBlue
10/17/20 12:16am
i'd be pissed about that call if I were a Houston fan. But plenty of bad calls in their favor.
cruiserhead
10/17/20 12:17am
Why? It's literally the rule? And it's not a rule to be pissed about.
Lip Gallagher
10/17/20 12:23am
I didn't think it was that close when watching it. But fine, if it's the rule. My point was that if the roles were
cruiserhead
10/17/20 12:31am
Huh? I thought it was clear interference the moment I saw it. Refs and TV agreed
Forzaitalia
10/17/20 12:49am
Was it bc they were too close? That’s pretty easy to see
Pretorian
10/17/20 12:51am
That was a good call. We were lined up offsides on a key play in the 4th quarter though
cougarmikey
10/17/20 1:43am
When?
BleedCougarBlue2
10/17/20 9:19am
Nah take a lap bubba you’re wrong.
dizthewiz
10/17/20 2:40am
This is absolutely false and a bad take.
Ygrad
10/17/20 8:55am
shoulder width and arm length was violated. Not a bad call, but maybe a bad rule
DJROSS
10/17/20 10:27am
Rules have a big problem if a UH guy can hit a guy with the helmet outside of
puntersarepeople
10/17/20 12:11am
But that is rule problem not a ref problem
GSwarriorcoug
10/17/20 2:49am
It appears that way yes
puntersarepeople
10/17/20 7:44am
I bet he sees a suspension from the conference this week. Houston is dirty.
MVPlayer
10/17/20 10:28am
I think this was the right call. Key is what you define as "bad"
Tricky
10/17/20 11:24am
Deciding after to take the penalty when Oldroyd ran into the field
bluelands
10/17/20 12:13am
That was weird. Decline the call, then reverse it when the kicker enters....
Benfica1
10/17/20 12:16am
Weird, but not an officiating mistake.
RobAdams
10/17/20 12:17am
Are you sure that you can change your mind so late? Have you seen it anywhere?
ParentingNotForSissy
10/17/20 12:30am
I'll say this... if I'm the white hat, that doesn't happen. Once you decide
goobermcmonkey
10/17/20 10:56am
seems like there would be a rule against changing your mind. "oh, they are going to kick a field goal? nevermind!"
cruiserhead
10/17/20 12:17am
Delay of game or charge them with a time out..that would be what makes sense
cougarmikey
10/17/20 1:45am
It was weird he hadn't scouted enough to know that was within Oldroyd's range.
BYUHawk
10/17/20 12:36am
Agreed. You'd think after a coach makes a choice, that's it, no more choosing.
BleedCougarBlue2
10/17/20 9:21am
I don't know if I've ever seen a crew that took so long to make calls.
JuicyJam
10/17/20 12:14am
The head ref looked befuddled the whole game and looked like he was conducting
Forzaitalia
10/17/20 11:02am
The Pau'u was an incompletion. Need to maintain possession through the fall.
cougaman
10/17/20 12:20am
Yeah, at best it was borderline. You want the TD hang on to the ball all the way
bythenumbers
10/17/20 12:23am
is that true in the end zone? Haven't there been plays where the player reaches the ball across the goal line, then
cruiserhead
10/17/20 12:23am
Running into the end zone different rules than catching the ez
Florwood
10/17/20 12:27am
You can't say he didn't. Caught in the EZ, step, fall, slide for a bit, THEN
Lip Gallagher
10/17/20 12:24am
you can't say from the views that he definitely has possession as he is rolling
cougaman
10/17/20 12:30am
That should never have been confirmed
puntersarepeople
10/17/20 12:26am
Where does that end?
The Y's Insider
10/17/20 12:29am
Yep. If that had been called a TD they would’ve made that an incompletion
puntersarepeople
10/17/20 12:30am
The ball doesn’t literally pop straight up after a catch and slide due to “no
NorthernLight
10/17/20 8:08am
^^^^^^^ This is 100% correct.
BleedCougarBlue2
10/17/20 9:26am
Hi did maintain possession "through the fall". Play is dead when player hits the
BleedCougarBlue2
10/17/20 9:22am
The pass interference they called on 4th and 1 bailed out BYU.
Mozzymozzy
10/17/20 12:26am
I didn't think the Houston player deserved more than he got.
RobAdams
10/17/20 12:28am
I mean everyone was making jokes about the UTSA player named Wisdom this week.
Mozzymozzy
10/17/20 12:33am
For the headbutt I think it's more the action then the fact that he didn't
BYUHawk
10/17/20 12:39am
Disagree. Since there is no rule that says any touching of the helmets
Tricky
10/17/20 11:15am
I don't disagree. I'm not necessarily on the boat that he should have been
BYUHawk
10/17/20 12:31pm
Had the receiver caught the ball defenders helmet would have been helmet to ball
Rigormortise
10/17/20 12:45am
Glad to see someone that understands fundamental football
slatecoug
10/17/20 1:34am
And after all that, scoreboard: 43-26 is your final. 😁
TrueBlue58
10/17/20 12:49am
All correct
Pretorian
10/17/20 12:50am
Lots of missed holding calls too
machete
10/17/20 1:07am
We had some officiating breaks too
chazen
10/17/20 1:15am
Thanks for putting this in writing. It literally was about 10 minutes on that review. Refs in the 3rd quarter were horri
cougarmikey
10/17/20 1:41am
The non PI call against Wilcox in the 4th was gigantic.
Gerald-DeGroot
10/17/20 2:54am
Two straight pi’s in the end zone just before half. We ended up getting stopped
thegoodmeister
10/17/20 3:15am
It evened out. Houston PI call bad & no block-in-back call in us led to BYU TD
zerome4sooners
10/17/20 5:36am
What is great about that is there were even more errors, but BYU was able to
DJROSS
10/17/20 10:25am
Late hit call in the 4th too Allgeir was out of bounds and got hit.
Cosmo4life
10/17/20 10:28am
I think you missed the spitting incident as well.
YeahWhatever
10/17/20 11:13am
I think it’s sad - that given a GUTSY win on the road
Future_Tacos
10/17/20 12:21pm
Some of us are capable of having numerous thoughts after a game.
The Y's Insider
10/17/20 3:02pm
I don't understand how the refs get a pass just because we win.
Mitty
10/17/20 3:08pm
The missed offsides in the 3Q was bad too.
WhyaskY?
10/17/20 11:08pm
Wow didn't see that one. Total BS. Only penalty was maybe offsides on D.
Mitty
10/17/20 11:13pm
I noticed that one too.
5150man
10/17/20 11:43pm
this was a bad call red clearly wasn't watching what happened so he had to guess
cougaman
10/17/20 11:47pm
I thought this at the time as well. But, I don't know the rule well enough.
Benfica1
10/18/20 9:23am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad