Plus there's differences in process

Dec 3, 2022
8:41:37am

krindorr Intervention Needed

So much of the game at the highest level is recruiting (as well as gameplanning and player development) and that's a contest Whittingham has never had to attempt at that level.

Maybe he'd be great at it, but odds are he'd be closer to average

Report problem with this ad

krindorr

Bio page: krindorr
Joined: Oct 5, 2020
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 18,227 (112 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Kyle W is Utah Football

Hawk Talons

12/3/22 7:50am

"holds people accountable" LOL

Gustav

12/3/22 7:51am

For football related issues, yes. Other stuff….lol

mudpupper

12/3/22 7:54am

Especially Wyoming.

Orem58thBall

12/3/22 12:21pm

RE: Kyle W is Utah Football

Samsonite

12/3/22 7:51am

I care because I want to beat them regularly and I care who we hire

Hawk Talons

12/3/22 7:52am

Honestly Utah (and somewhat TCU) are the blueprint we are wanting to follow. It makes sense to see what they do

krindorr

12/3/22 8:07am

Okay I think I came up with how we emulate them…

LumberCoug

12/3/22 4:23pm

They aren't an exact match...but we can still learn a lot from similarities

krindorr

12/3/22 4:31pm

For sure. I just think the biggest issues for BYU stem from the HC. It’s a chall

LumberCoug

12/3/22 4:45pm

Great coach, great recruiter, great program. My only beef is that he has zero

kansascougar

12/3/22 7:56am

I want to beat them and out recruit them for LDS athletes in particular

Hawk Talons

12/3/22 7:59am

Yes and absolutely need to win to make this happen, Utah

1CougFan

12/3/22 8:53am

KS knows of it, but what he's shown seems to indicate he doesn't know it.

sheza65

12/3/22 9:01am

I don't believe that BYU is their super bowl anymore, I really don't.

The Dark Knight

12/3/22 1:20pm

He was trained by Urban Meyer. That was his thing. Hate the rival.

Shore10

12/3/22 8:34am

Not just hate them, do all you can to destroy them on and

1CougFan

12/3/22 8:55am

But it gives them a psychological edge

CharlottesvilleCoug

12/3/22 9:32am

It's made the culture of the state pretty toxic now.

Shore10

12/3/22 10:18am

Nah, he was trained by Ron McBride. In McBride’s words: “I like LaVell, I don’t

Desertcoug85

12/3/22 9:20am

That’s untrue

bigjohn

12/3/22 10:19am

His actions say otherwise. Does Utah have obnoxious fans? Yep. Does Sitake act

kansascougar

12/3/22 10:25am

That’s just a rivalry strategy

bigjohn

12/3/22 12:05pm

Oh BS. BYU fans only give him a hard time in the context of the rivalry

kansascougar

12/3/22 12:07pm

This

shakarocks

12/3/22 10:28am

So why doesn't he express that respect?

The Dark Knight

12/3/22 1:18pm

He was never going to accept the BYU job. Ever. He does not respect the BYU

Desertcoug85

12/4/22 8:26am

Oh yes he was. Had Scalley not rallied he would have been at BYU

shakarocks

12/4/22 12:00pm

I don’t believe you or him. He was going to take it because Utah hadn’t offered

Desertcoug85

12/4/22 1:57pm

It's well documented

shakarocks

12/5/22 3:51am

His disdain for BYU is mostly post 2005. The family thinks they did Fred wrong

kansascougar

12/5/22 6:44am

I still insist any perceived disrespect from Bronco toward Kyle was purely

Desertcoug85

12/10/22 12:06pm

The whole world is LaBradford Smith to Kyle Whittingham.

Shore10

12/10/22 12:54pm

So lower assistant pay, assistants who might not want to come to BYU, minimal

Desertcoug85

12/5/22 1:12pm

Kyle believes BYU did his dad Fred wrong. Blood is much thicker than water.

notsofast

12/3/22 10:49am

You’re right and yet he almost

bigjohn

12/3/22 12:07pm

I love KW, but he's not great as the favorite, or when he has something to lose.

bja13

12/3/22 1:45pm

Very true. That's his whole schtick. Underdog chip on his shoulder.

Shore10

12/3/22 1:58pm

He is in the same tier as Saban, Meyer, and Sweeney.

Backcountry

12/3/22 8:07am

Wouldn't go that far, he's top 15, probably even top 10, but def not top 5

krindorr

12/3/22 8:11am

How many national championships has Kyle won (legitimately, that is)? He’s a good coach, but he’s not at that level.

Texas Hammer

12/3/22 8:14am

Hes at Utah. He turned a mid level MWC program into a P5 power. At USC Whitt

Backcountry

12/3/22 8:32am

I'd say that transformation happened under Urban but whit kept it going.

Shore10

12/3/22 8:36am

Utah was losing to Air Force and New Mexico regularly when Whitt took over.

Backcountry

12/3/22 8:37am

NM had a decent team back then. Air Force was always a hard game.

Shore10

12/3/22 8:47am

You can argue that but it's a hypothetical - Swinney, Smart, Saban, Urban etc all actually did it

krindorr

12/3/22 8:39am

Plus there's differences in process

krindorr

12/3/22 8:41am

Sure he’s built a great program, but again - how many NCs does he have? You put him at the same level of others that

Texas Hammer

12/3/22 8:58am

Oh brother. Stop with the love affair. He’s good but not elite

chitownboy

12/3/22 9:12am

Hes elite. Its not debatable

Backcountry

12/3/22 9:22am

Oh really it’s not a debate. There are only 3 or so guys that are elite

chitownboy

12/3/22 10:46am

I'd say elite. Back to back P12 championships. In the game what 4x in a row?

BYUfan92

12/3/22 10:00am

They haven’t even sniffed the playoffs yet. But yeah let’s say he’s elite.

chitownboy

12/3/22 10:48am

What does 'sniffing the playoffs entail'?

krindorr

12/3/22 12:22pm

When they officially select teams Utah has never been in the conversation.

chitownboy

12/3/22 12:39pm

Lol nice try. I didn’t say he was anywhere close to the best coach ever. SI has

BYUfan92

12/3/22 2:15pm

Correct I use hyperbole because you used it. Elite is reserved for only a

chitownboy

12/3/22 2:21pm

Top 10 percent is elite in my estimation and that’s roughly where I’d put KW

BYUfan92

12/3/22 3:00pm

Yeah your definition and mine are way different. I would count only 3-5 as elite

chitownboy

12/3/22 3:41pm

Hes at Utah, dude. Do you remember what Utah was when Kyle took over? You

Backcountry

12/4/22 8:29am

Legitimately top 10 each year. Dude you don’t know football

chitownboy

12/4/22 11:23am

How many times has Utah finished in the top 10 in the last 10 years? Yeah 0

chitownboy

12/4/22 11:38am

While I agree with the general argument...Utah finished #10 last year

krindorr

12/4/22 11:46am

Yeah. I kinda had to laugh at his assertion.

Shore10

12/4/22 11:56am

12th. Look it up if you need

chitownboy

12/4/22 12:33pm

I mean, ok. You're correct, but you think there's much of a difference?

Shore10

12/5/22 8:44am

Wrong. After bowl game they were #12. After all games are played.

chitownboy

12/4/22 12:32pm

Huh, you're right. Wikipedia has the info wrong, I'll put in an edit there

krindorr

12/5/22 6:05am

Ummm no, you need a national championship to be in the same sentence with those

zerome4sooners

12/3/22 4:07pm

Bronco or Patterson?! What the?

Texas Hammer

12/3/22 8:10am

Cut Kalani some slack, let’s let him get

Prdub83

12/3/22 8:22am

It has been seven years without the right dudes.

sheza65

12/3/22 9:06am

But does Kalani have it in him to bring in "the right dudes"?

CharlottesvilleCoug

12/3/22 9:36am

I don’t think being in the Big12 makes much difference in recruiting unless we have the right coaches recruiting.

Bonoman

12/3/22 2:12pm

My question remains: Why hasn't Kalani already learned from Kyle? How long

BYUJoJo

12/3/22 8:22am

Bingo!

1CougFan

12/3/22 8:58am

If KS learned it, then something impedes him from implementing it. I just think

sheza65

12/3/22 9:05am

BYU neuters coaches. Bronco and Kalani both came in as tough guys.

Backcountry

12/3/22 9:40am

Great observations and great post!

BYUJoJo

12/3/22 8:24am

When you hear people bad mouthing Brigham Young

JupiterJones

12/3/22 8:34am

As an active, believing member who is also a BYU fan,

troglodyte

12/3/22 10:00am

Lavell disagrees.

Les IsMore

12/3/22 2:24pm

Lavell’s legacy played out in SLC. Wish BYU got him back in the day

Honor Code

12/3/22 8:38am

Kyles competitiveness and desire to win gotta be top 10. Add to

1CougFan

12/3/22 8:49am

yet - he loses head scratchers every year. he was our coach and we would

Pobs

12/3/22 9:17am

Yeah, I bet we we hate B 2 B conference championships and Rose Bowl games.

Hawk Talons

12/3/22 10:38am

You don’t think the board would be lamenting the 3 losses? Board nature says yes

Pobs

12/5/22 12:00pm

In his first 7 years he had ONE really good season

moknowssports

12/3/22 10:53am

Kyle finished third or worse in MWC all but once.

Madam Pattirini

12/3/22 11:45am

He also benefited from P5 status vs his rival

YOHONOMOTO

12/3/22 1:26pm

Sobering isn't it?

Ute_Truther

12/3/22 3:18pm

He's a great coach who finds a way to be competitive every year. He adopted

Jasbo

12/3/22 11:51am

That’s why every time I hear from Ute fans to fire Kyle I’m like…

Coug Man in Florida

12/3/22 12:32pm

And we whiffed on him by trying to offer him way below market value.

tony

12/3/22 1:11pm

He's very good. I do question how good he'd be in a more competitive football

Gentleman Stan

12/3/22 1:23pm

I don’t understand why BYU regressed this year after stellar 2020 and 2021 seasons. Hall is awesome. Puka

TFL

12/3/22 3:48pm

Coaches not good

zerome4sooners

12/3/22 4:08pm

Defense was…

Coug Man in Florida

12/3/22 5:00pm

What is with the Utah love fest on this board?

zerome4sooners

12/3/22 4:07pm

It’s admitting they’re good, and being frustrated with how BYU committed to

Desertcoug85

12/4/22 8:37am

Yes, and BYU IMO did not take beating Utah more seriously by building a team

Posting on CougarBoard