Your dad sounds like a cool guy but Marines also say they're the best everything

Report problem with this ad

Jun 26, 2022
10:04:18pm

vagabonder Truly Addicted User

Report problem with this ad

vagabonder

Bio page: vagabonder
Joined: Dec 15, 2016
Last login: May 30, 2024
Total posts: 15,053 (28 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Top Gun question. Do only Navy planes and pilots fly from Aircraft Carriers? Wouldn’t logically the AF have the best

Hank Rearden All-American

6/26/22 9:54pm

Why would flying off an aircraft carrier make them less of a pilot? If anything it takes more skill.

Busting Coveys

6/26/22 9:56pm

I guess I didn’t explain that very well. It had nothing to do with skill needed, and everything to do with AF doesn’t

Hank Rearden

6/26/22 10:13pm

Why does that even matter? I’m still not following.

Busting Coveys

6/26/22 10:21pm

Since the carriers are the first line of defense their pilots see more action

novacoug1

6/26/22 9:57pm

Not true. AF can (and have) launched B-2s or B-52s and send them to the other

BleedCougarBlue2

6/29/22 10:00am

B 52s don't do a lot of dog fighting

novacoug1

6/29/22 11:04am

True, but you didn't say "dog fighting", you said "action".

BleedCougarBlue2

6/29/22 7:16pm

Marine pilots fly from carriers.

ArcticKat

6/26/22 9:57pm

Why do you think naval aviators are worse than AF pilots? Is there any reason to think that?

Clark Addison

6/26/22 9:57pm

One group is called “The Air Force”

DiamondMo

6/26/22 10:03pm

Well, the terms “Air Force” v “Navy” for starter. But ultimately my thinking is that there are a many times the number

Hank Rearden

6/26/22 10:05pm

Becoming a fighter pilot is extremely competitive in any branch. They all

califcougar

6/26/22 10:13pm

My answers to those points would be:

Clark Addison

6/26/22 10:21pm

I have no doubt that they attract top caliber talent,

MojosDojo

6/26/22 11:09pm

My dad, a retired Marine pilot, would argue the Marines have the best pilots

letthewookieewin

6/26/22 10:00pm

But Top Gun proves that incorrect.

IGotGoodGifs

6/26/22 10:01pm

The Actual Top Gun instructor consultant for the film was a Marine, Dave Berke:

NewMexiCoug

6/26/22 10:10pm

<< Deleted >>

letthewookieewin

6/26/22 10:28pm

Your dad sounds like a cool guy but Marines also say they're the best everything

vagabonder

6/26/22 10:04pm

That's because Marines are honest.

Les IsMore

6/26/22 11:22pm

I remember when Marine told me with a straight face that USMC infantry have the

vagabonder

6/27/22 6:10am

He did mention he knows very little, which doesn't imply any of them are less.

S-rizzle

6/26/22 10:01pm

Navy pilots existed before the USAF was formed.

WJCougar

6/26/22 10:01pm

Doesn't make them better...

MojosDojo

6/26/22 11:12pm

Doesn't make them worse.

WJCougar

6/27/22 7:55am

It's been a weird evolution that at times makes sense, and at others can't be

Corn Pop

6/26/22 10:04pm

The Navy does manage their own soldiers, Navy Seals

icecougar

6/26/22 11:45pm

Aren't the Marines part of the Navy?

NC CougarBear

6/27/22 9:36am

Technically, yes. But I'll tell you they sure HATE to admit that. 😉

BleedCougarBlue2

6/29/22 10:04am

All 4 branches have great pilots. One isn’t necessarily better than the other.

califcougar

6/26/22 10:05pm

Do Drone flyers belong to one of the 4 branches?

Crowgar

6/26/22 10:08pm

All branches have aerial drones

califcougar

6/26/22 10:16pm

Which branch did buster fly for?

The_Cuss

6/26/22 11:45pm

My home teaching companion in the 90s was at top gun in San Diego

zephyr

6/26/22 10:05pm

My neighbor was a Top Gun instructor at the end of the F4 era

bluelands

6/26/22 10:29pm

The Navy operated an air station in Adak, Alaska until 1997. It was a Cold War..

icecougar

6/27/22 12:09am

I'm guessing all pilots have similar training - regardless of military arm.

Eddie

6/26/22 10:07pm

Navy pilots wear brown shoes, and somehow that makes them better.

kcca

6/26/22 10:17pm

A family friend was an air force pilot in Korea and flew off the USS Hancock in

CanuckUte

6/26/22 10:21pm

Lots of good answers but some seem to think Im an idiot for asking. Let me simplify. The movie implies the VERY best

Hank Rearden

6/26/22 10:26pm

The Navy Has thousands of aircraft. It’s not hundreds vs. thousands. Not to

califcougar

6/26/22 10:47pm

The US Air Force is the largest Air Force in the world

Hotlanta

6/27/22 4:52am

RE: Lots of good answers but some seem to think Im an idiot for asking. Let me simplify. The movie implies the VERY best

zephyr

6/26/22 10:47pm

The Air Force evidently has their own school, called Weapons School

kirty

6/27/22 12:51am

Probably a moot point. Drones are the future of military air warfare.

Blueto

6/26/22 10:29pm

They'll continue to play a role,

MojosDojo

6/26/22 11:25pm

Similar question: why do 3 (or more) branches have fighter jets?

Great38

6/26/22 10:44pm

More tactical than anything.

Les IsMore

6/26/22 11:39pm

My opinion:

MojosDojo

6/26/22 11:24pm

Add my two cents to your thoughts

NavyCougar

6/27/22 7:49am

I can’t speak for all fighter pilots from the branches of the military, but i

Idacoug

6/27/22 12:21am

Yes , they fly different planes.

Mot

6/27/22 12:36am

A friend who is an AF pilot told me that navy pilots are more limited in what

Thrill

6/27/22 12:53am

I don’t think USAF pilots (I am one) are any better or worse than the USN/USMC.

pilot17

6/27/22 5:19am

35th Fighter Squadron, Itazuke AFB, Japan

Kunsi

6/27/22 7:02am

The F 35 is used by the Navy Air Force and Marines.

chazen

6/27/22 10:53am

Yes, only Navy and Marine Corps pilots fly from carriers. Everyone thinks

Mitty

6/27/22 12:08pm

Not true. "Most" pilots who operate from carriers are Navy or Marines, but not

BleedCougarBlue2

6/29/22 10:17am

I am just amazed at what any of you pilots can do. It is so cool and humbling to

Posting on CougarBoard