While earlier he said Tanner gives us the best chance to win, Hoge's available changes the

Oct 16, 2017
12:37:48pm

DrBYU All-American

calculation and we'll have to see. Seemed to indicate that a healthy Hoge gives us an even better chance to win. Specifically referred to how well he and the team were doing during the USU game before the injury.

Report problem with this ad

DrBYU

Bio page: DrBYU
Joined: Apr 9, 2001
Last login: May 23, 2024
Total posts: 9,357 (70 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Greg asked Lamb about Hoge.

BigYfan

10/16/17 12:28pm

Sucks for you.

SoCalCoug

10/16/17 12:28pm

While earlier he said Tanner gives us the best chance to win, Hoge's available changes the

DrBYU

10/16/17 12:37pm

Is Hoge better than the other QBs waiting in the wings & returning from mission?

ptcougr

10/16/17 1:43pm

I would take Jaren Hall in a heartbeat over Hoge

Denesheo

10/16/17 6:10pm

Hoge was in a boot on Saturday

donnerstag

10/16/17 1:04pm

Could Hoge get a medical redshirt if he misses the rest of the year?

TailgateU

10/16/17 1:42pm

Yes. It's possible

donnerstag

10/16/17 1:44pm

No it's not. He used a voluntary RS in 2016.

Kalani4Prez

10/16/17 2:15pm

Sometimes they get an extra if it's hardship, such as Keaton from USU.

TailgateU

10/16/17 2:20pm

It's actually slightly easier if there is no mission

donnerstag

10/16/17 2:22pm

Keeton hadn't used a redshirt previously.

Kalani4Prez

10/16/17 2:50pm

Signed Bryton Barr -- (link)

(Private)

10/16/17 3:17pm

Yeah, I remember Case Keenum got like 2 or 3 medical redshirt years at Houston

Game Changer

10/16/17 6:54pm

That article doesn’t contradict K4P in any way

Coop

10/16/17 7:02pm

Yes it does. It expressly talks about getting RS when you play in less than 3 ga

(Private)

10/16/17 9:21pm

Also, the fact is you can get multiple redshirts. So it directly contradicts.

(Private)

10/16/17 9:21pm

You can’t get multiple redshirts

Coop

10/17/17 5:43am

Here is the official NCAA rule on eligibility

Coop

10/17/17 7:55am

Yeah... I think under 12.8.1.7.1.1(a) and 12.8.4 there is no limitation based on

(Private)

10/17/17 3:03pm

Using a redshirt is specifically listed under the things the player can control

Coop

10/17/17 3:10pm

I am not seeing under the rule how that prevents a medical redshirt...

(Private)

10/17/17 6:39pm

There's an aspect of it that I hadn't thought of before, actually

Coop

10/18/17 11:32am

^ This is correct and what I referred to above.

Kalani4Prez

10/18/17 12:47pm

Jason White and Case Keenum both used voluntary RS years and then were granted

Game Changer

10/16/17 7:32pm

No, both were medical

Coop

10/16/17 8:18pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad