I am not seeing under the rule how that prevents a medical redshirt...

Oct 17, 2017
6:39:17pm

(Private) All-American

I see that rule as specifically stating you can't get that year back i.e. your redshirt year that you chose to redshirt. That year is gone from eligibility. You cannot claim a hardship for that year that you've claimed a redshirt year.

Report problem with this ad

(Private)

Bio page: (Private)
Joined: Jan 1, 1995
Last login: Jan 1, 1995
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Greg asked Lamb about Hoge.

BigYfan

10/16/17 12:28pm

Sucks for you.

SoCalCoug

10/16/17 12:28pm

While earlier he said Tanner gives us the best chance to win, Hoge's available changes the

DrBYU

10/16/17 12:37pm

Is Hoge better than the other QBs waiting in the wings & returning from mission?

ptcougr

10/16/17 1:43pm

I would take Jaren Hall in a heartbeat over Hoge

Denesheo

10/16/17 6:10pm

Hoge was in a boot on Saturday

donnerstag

10/16/17 1:04pm

Could Hoge get a medical redshirt if he misses the rest of the year?

TailgateU

10/16/17 1:42pm

Yes. It's possible

donnerstag

10/16/17 1:44pm

No it's not. He used a voluntary RS in 2016.

Kalani4Prez

10/16/17 2:15pm

Sometimes they get an extra if it's hardship, such as Keaton from USU.

TailgateU

10/16/17 2:20pm

It's actually slightly easier if there is no mission

donnerstag

10/16/17 2:22pm

Keeton hadn't used a redshirt previously.

Kalani4Prez

10/16/17 2:50pm

Signed Bryton Barr -- (link)

(Private)

10/16/17 3:17pm

Yeah, I remember Case Keenum got like 2 or 3 medical redshirt years at Houston

Game Changer

10/16/17 6:54pm

That article doesn’t contradict K4P in any way

Coop

10/16/17 7:02pm

Yes it does. It expressly talks about getting RS when you play in less than 3 ga

(Private)

10/16/17 9:21pm

Also, the fact is you can get multiple redshirts. So it directly contradicts.

(Private)

10/16/17 9:21pm

You can’t get multiple redshirts

Coop

10/17/17 5:43am

Here is the official NCAA rule on eligibility

Coop

10/17/17 7:55am

Yeah... I think under 12.8.1.7.1.1(a) and 12.8.4 there is no limitation based on

(Private)

10/17/17 3:03pm

Using a redshirt is specifically listed under the things the player can control

Coop

10/17/17 3:10pm

I am not seeing under the rule how that prevents a medical redshirt...

(Private)

10/17/17 6:39pm

There's an aspect of it that I hadn't thought of before, actually

Coop

10/18/17 11:32am

^ This is correct and what I referred to above.

Kalani4Prez

10/18/17 12:47pm

Jason White and Case Keenum both used voluntary RS years and then were granted

Game Changer

10/16/17 7:32pm

No, both were medical

Coop

10/16/17 8:18pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad