My Account
Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 15, 2018
11:49
:49
am
stoils
All-American
Other than Tonga
I don't see anyone on your list that given hindsight would have merited any higher of a rating than 2 stars. The fact that these guys are starting is more indicative of the overall talent Kalani has brought into the program.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
stoils
Bio page
stoils
Joined
Jan 12, 2007
Last login
May 2, 2024
Total posts
10,594 (43 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
A list of some of the players that have dragged down Sitake's recruiting classes
donnerstag
11/15/18 11:25am
Not sure if Tonga is the best defensive player on the team.
LaVellIfIKnow
11/15/18 11:27am
Its probably Corbin or TakiTaki, but either way Tonga started at DT as a Fr.
ayfan
11/15/18 11:32am
Hmmmm......he'd be my pick. His stats are not huge because of the attention he
Thrill
11/15/18 11:35am
He’s also lazy
Mathew
11/15/18 12:05pm
From a talent perspective, he's the #1 player
donnerstag
11/15/18 11:36am
He's a great player, especially as only a soph, but he could be a first round
jaba166
11/16/18 1:18am
Tonga tends to take plays off and not play with a high motor
Mathew
11/15/18 12:05pm
RE: Not sure if Tonga is the best defensive player on the team.
KCougarK
11/15/18 1:13pm
It's Dayan.
Unibro
11/15/18 7:14pm
Truth is recruiting ranking is an accurate indicator of future team success
Blueto
11/15/18 11:36am
Not usually
donnerstag
11/15/18 11:38am
Actually yes. Almost always. Look at this article.
Blueto
11/15/18 11:40am
The article draws conclusions limited in scope
donnerstag
11/15/18 11:51am
They matter. Here's more data.
Blueto
11/15/18 12:12pm
That's a very poor interpretation of a badly written article
Coop
11/15/18 11:51am
Bad article
reddead
11/15/18 2:24pm
Maybe. But it doesn't change the fact that recruiting top players equates
Blueto
11/15/18 2:50pm
You should show historical 4 and 5 star recruits which have dragged BYU's actual results down
Indy Coug
11/15/18 11:38am
4 and 5 star recruits underperform on average at BYU
donnerstag
11/15/18 11:40am
Other than Tonga
stoils
11/15/18 11:49am
2 star players are generally not expected to become starters
donnerstag
11/15/18 11:55am
So we've replaced bad Bronco players with legit 2 star athletes, wahoo
stoils
11/15/18 12:12pm
We've replaced Bronco players with players with better measurables
donnerstag
11/15/18 12:19pm
And we lose a lot more. Doesn't seem to be working.
coolblue
11/15/18 1:41pm
The team is young. Have a little patience
donnerstag
11/15/18 1:41pm
We are at the "lot of patience" level now
stoils
11/16/18 7:56am
in addition, due to recent seasons, we have to look for diamonds in the rough
kapcreations
11/15/18 1:46pm
Most of our 2-deep consists of 3 and 4 star guys...Tonga is an exception
boscatar
11/15/18 1:39pm
Other than Tonga and Katoa, none of the others have been al that impressive.
UNHuskerCoug
11/15/18 12:27pm
Aleva was arguably our best playmaker on offense before getting banged up.
che flaco
11/15/18 1:01pm
Is that saying much though, comparatively speaking?
UNHuskerCoug
11/15/18 2:24pm
People will disagree, but IMO, Wilcox has become one of the best corners BYU
CMuehle
11/15/18 2:56pm
I never heard anyone complain about Tonga and Katoa. Both P12 transfers...
NacoCoug
11/15/18 1:48pm
True. The rest aren't very proven
donnerstag
11/15/18 2:00pm
Yay, starters that helped the team win 4 games last year and 5 so far this year.
cougaman
11/15/18 2:14pm
Donnerstag's posts nearly always make me feel at least a little
CMuehle
11/15/18 2:39pm
Meh... Having a couple of 2 stars play well is normal. Here are some other
Gorum the Old
11/15/18 2:41pm
Max Hall and Jamaal were both 3 star players on both rivals and 247
donnerstag
11/15/18 2:46pm
Rivals, ESPN gave Hall 2*. Check BYU's Commitment list for 2006.
Gorum the Old
11/21/18 10:06am
What fraction of BYU's 2 star recruits become starters? What fraction of their 3
colton
11/16/18 7:38am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad