Meh... Having a couple of 2 stars play well is normal. Here are some other

Nov 15, 2018
2:41:18pm

Gorum the Old Walk-on

players who have dragged down recruiting classes: Harvey Unga, Max Hall, Cody Hoffman, Jamaal Williams. All 2* recruits.

Report problem with this ad

Gorum the Old

Bio page: Gorum the Old
Joined: Sep 6, 2007
Last login: Apr 17, 2024
Total posts: 1,199 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A list of some of the players that have dragged down Sitake's recruiting classes

donnerstag

11/15/18 11:25am

Not sure if Tonga is the best defensive player on the team.

LaVellIfIKnow

11/15/18 11:27am

Its probably Corbin or TakiTaki, but either way Tonga started at DT as a Fr.

ayfan

11/15/18 11:32am

Hmmmm......he'd be my pick. His stats are not huge because of the attention he

Thrill

11/15/18 11:35am

He’s also lazy

Mathew

11/15/18 12:05pm

From a talent perspective, he's the #1 player

donnerstag

11/15/18 11:36am

He's a great player, especially as only a soph, but he could be a first round

jaba166

11/16/18 1:18am

Tonga tends to take plays off and not play with a high motor

Mathew

11/15/18 12:05pm

RE: Not sure if Tonga is the best defensive player on the team.

KCougarK

11/15/18 1:13pm

It's Dayan.

Unibro

11/15/18 7:14pm

Truth is recruiting ranking is an accurate indicator of future team success

Blueto

11/15/18 11:36am

Not usually

donnerstag

11/15/18 11:38am

Actually yes. Almost always. Look at this article.

Blueto

11/15/18 11:40am

The article draws conclusions limited in scope

donnerstag

11/15/18 11:51am

They matter. Here's more data.

Blueto

11/15/18 12:12pm

That's a very poor interpretation of a badly written article

Coop

11/15/18 11:51am

Bad article

reddead

11/15/18 2:24pm

Maybe. But it doesn't change the fact that recruiting top players equates

Blueto

11/15/18 2:50pm

You should show historical 4 and 5 star recruits which have dragged BYU's actual results down

Indy Coug

11/15/18 11:38am

4 and 5 star recruits underperform on average at BYU

donnerstag

11/15/18 11:40am

Other than Tonga

stoils

11/15/18 11:49am

2 star players are generally not expected to become starters

donnerstag

11/15/18 11:55am

So we've replaced bad Bronco players with legit 2 star athletes, wahoo

stoils

11/15/18 12:12pm

We've replaced Bronco players with players with better measurables

donnerstag

11/15/18 12:19pm

And we lose a lot more. Doesn't seem to be working.

coolblue

11/15/18 1:41pm

The team is young. Have a little patience

donnerstag

11/15/18 1:41pm

We are at the "lot of patience" level now

stoils

11/16/18 7:56am

in addition, due to recent seasons, we have to look for diamonds in the rough

kapcreations

11/15/18 1:46pm

Most of our 2-deep consists of 3 and 4 star guys...Tonga is an exception

boscatar

11/15/18 1:39pm

Other than Tonga and Katoa, none of the others have been al that impressive.

UNHuskerCoug

11/15/18 12:27pm

Aleva was arguably our best playmaker on offense before getting banged up.

che flaco

11/15/18 1:01pm

Is that saying much though, comparatively speaking?

UNHuskerCoug

11/15/18 2:24pm

People will disagree, but IMO, Wilcox has become one of the best corners BYU

CMuehle

11/15/18 2:56pm

I never heard anyone complain about Tonga and Katoa. Both P12 transfers...

NacoCoug

11/15/18 1:48pm

True. The rest aren't very proven

donnerstag

11/15/18 2:00pm

Yay, starters that helped the team win 4 games last year and 5 so far this year.

cougaman

11/15/18 2:14pm

Donnerstag's posts nearly always make me feel at least a little

CMuehle

11/15/18 2:39pm

Meh... Having a couple of 2 stars play well is normal. Here are some other

Gorum the Old

11/15/18 2:41pm

Max Hall and Jamaal were both 3 star players on both rivals and 247

donnerstag

11/15/18 2:46pm

Rivals, ESPN gave Hall 2*. Check BYU's Commitment list for 2006.

Gorum the Old

11/21/18 10:06am

What fraction of BYU's 2 star recruits become starters? What fraction of their 3

Posting on CougarBoard