The post that prompted this post about the change was lamenting how Rick's

Report problem with this ad

Jun 22, 2019
4:59:14pm

fattycoug All-American

The post that prompted this post about the change was lamenting how Rick's

Dropping athletics has hurt BYU athletically. So, that's the context to why this was even being brought up.

Sure, it could be argued that BYU-I should have sports but the reason this was being discussed was that "dropping sports" negatively affected BYU athletics.

I don't think it would have mattered much due to the changes in what JC football is, now, in regards to a pipeline to D1. The original post seemed to also be forgetting that the change to 4 year school would have broken that pipeline, anyway, if BYU-I had kept sports.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jun 22, 2019 at 4:59:14pm

Message modified by fattycoug on Jun 22, 2019 at 4:59:37pm

Report problem with this ad

fattycoug

Bio page: fattycoug
Joined: Sep 9, 2002
Last login: May 15, 2024
Total posts: 69,653 (11,106 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

RE: Try

Refugee Starter

6/22/19 8:59am

In relation to the original thread, people aren't realizing that the change to 4

fattycoug

6/22/19 9:05am

Exactly. I actually wrote some of that and then deleted it because it didn't seem to fit within the context

Refugee

6/22/19 9:10am

And people, IMO, are better off having BYU-I over Rick's anyway. Educationally

fattycoug

6/22/19 9:10am

Yes and no

cajuncoug

6/22/19 4:30pm

The post that prompted this post about the change was lamenting how Rick's

fattycoug

6/22/19 4:59pm

I get it. But there are numerous posts since where context clearly changed

cajuncoug

6/22/19 5:13pm

Sports are the biggest headache for a University President...

(Private)

6/22/19 9:54am

Are you willing to submit that the name of BYU-Idaho was inspired?

TheWanderer

6/22/19 10:00am

RE: Are you willing to submit that the name of BYU-Idaho was inspired?

fattycoug

6/22/19 10:03am

Absolutely. We’re seeing that playout today.

Refugee

6/22/19 10:11am

Okay. That's a fair answer.

TheWanderer

6/22/19 10:14am

In the first paragraph of the news release he linked it said. Here's the quote

6/22/19 10:51pm

The so called "Spirit of Ricks" lip service...which no one knows what means. Yep

TheWanderer

6/23/19 3:43am

How long did it take you to write that novel?

TADOW

6/22/19 10:15am

Several of us asked for detail.

TheWanderer

6/22/19 10:17am

Too long. My condolences on your ADD.

Refugee

6/22/19 10:47am

So I missed the part about why sports don't fit into the model...

bigbluecougar

6/22/19 11:22am

Sounds like cost. Most athletics programs are not self-sustaining.

scootsy

6/22/19 12:31pm

I'm a beneficiary from this development. I graduated from one of BYU-I's online

BringYourUltimate

6/22/19 11:49am

That is awesome! Love it.

Refugee

6/22/19 1:55pm

So with such a broad reach BYU-I’s football will have access to P5 talent worldwide?

Q-grr

6/22/19 12:00pm

I don’t see a Ziggy coming to play intracollegiate football at BYU-I.

Refugee

6/22/19 12:28pm

No question Pathways has helped members around the world. It has come

6/22/19 12:14pm

Not sure your second argument is on point...

fenderbender

6/22/19 3:13pm

I love BYU-I, thanks for the post!

BlueFamily

6/22/19 4:02pm

... Oops, meant for original post

BlueFamily

6/22/19 4:03pm

If you weaken entry standards, you are prone to weaken the overall rigor.

6/22/19 5:06pm

I don’t know but my guess is the rigor is region dependent.

StalwartBraveTrue

6/22/19 5:35pm

What are the difficult pre-recs to join Pathway that you are referring to?

Refugee

6/22/19 6:01pm

You convinced me.

scootsy

6/22/19 12:30pm

Thanks. Huge BYU Sports fan here. But also supportive of BYU-I and its mis

Orem58thBall

6/22/19 1:38pm

I've always understood the objective of church sponsored school is to lift the

MajorZeus

6/22/19 1:56pm

Thanks for the great post!

Blue2thebone

6/22/19 2:36pm

Seems to me a move to 4 year is a better reason

lukeskywalker

6/22/19 3:47pm

In one sense BYU-Idaho is a sort of U of Phoenix.

TheWanderer

6/22/19 4:03pm

Yeah, I read some comments in the local paper at the time

cajuncoug

6/22/19 4:23pm

I certainly don’t disagree that the transition was inspired.

BigEasyCougar

6/22/19 4:35pm

I would be devastated if BYU ever dropped athletics, and the only solace I would find is in stories like this proving

MaxxPower

6/22/19 5:35pm

Thank you for sharing this. BYU alumni have to admit

BYU Tar Heel

6/22/19 4:38pm

Wow. Thank you

MaxxPower

6/22/19 5:32pm

That was a very insightful post. Thank you so much for taking the time to write

rerunc

6/22/19 5:52pm

RE: Try

Claxton

6/22/19 6:09pm

RE: Try

MrRoboto

6/22/19 6:17pm

This is fine but I would hope after Pres Hinkley felt inspired for the change

RC Vikings

6/23/19 9:15am

Of course there was input from others. They had been burdened by it for some time.

Refugee

6/23/19 9:25am

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

6/23/19 1:45pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad