Capitalism always wins

Jul 11, 2019
5:54:44pm

Cougforgood Contributor

I love Cinderella teams too but holding down a true market is unfair on so many levels.

Time to watch high school football I guess.

Report problem with this ad

Cougforgood

Bio page: Cougforgood
Joined: Nov 14, 2014
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 3,843 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

This will fundamentally change college athletics, I'm not sure the Church will

ColumbusCoug

7/11/19 2:40pm

Why would the church care if BYU football players were paid for use of their likeness? They absolutely should be.

Pimpin4Paradise

7/11/19 2:41pm

I'm not the OP and these aren't necessarily my thoughts. If I had to guess where

gwalker

7/11/19 2:47pm

Yes, thank you. I should have provided more context but college athletics could

ColumbusCoug

7/11/19 2:48pm

When Ty Detmer came through there was tremendous interest in him. Who got that $

buckeyecougarguy

7/11/19 5:03pm

I think it’s funny how people who want to pay players act like the players get

Pretorian

7/11/19 6:23pm

This isn't about schools paying players.

mik3

7/11/19 6:40pm

IMO this will just remove artificial restrictions from the market and make things better.

mik3

7/11/19 2:50pm

Now on to my own thoughts, which are different. More money may well be fair. It

gwalker

7/11/19 2:53pm

Right, I was addressing the point. Understood that they were not your arguments.

mik3

7/11/19 3:05pm

I’m surprised you find any charm now.

Blue Cat

7/11/19 5:17pm

Capitalism always wins

Cougforgood

7/11/19 5:54pm

i am hoping that the NCAA says see ya to UCLA,CAL,SDSU and fresno Stanford and

travelcoug

7/11/19 4:36pm

I agree, but I don't think that's the issue. I've heard it argued that

DraperCoug22

7/11/19 4:50pm

Maybe in the short run

Cougforgood

7/11/19 5:56pm

“The world is our campus”...? Might help

ZooBlue

7/11/19 7:47pm

I guess I don't understand why this would be a problem

kjBYU

7/11/19 2:45pm

What happens when a car dealership is willing to give every single football

ColumbusCoug

7/11/19 2:47pm

I don't see an issue with players driving cars. Money already drives recruiting, that's why

mik3

7/11/19 2:52pm

I don't think it is a negative thing for student-athletes to be given cars but

ColumbusCoug

7/11/19 2:55pm

The competitive balance in college athletics is a mirage, IMO. At least when it comes

mik3

7/11/19 3:06pm

I don't get why the Church would care about this. It is irrelevant to the Church

Romex

7/11/19 2:45pm

other than that the Church has to decide whether it is willing to bankroll

AggieWeekendCougar

7/11/19 3:08pm

Think profiting from name & likeness refers to endorsements from third parties. So under this

mik3

7/11/19 3:14pm

Exactly, they would probably bring in some additional cash.

Romex

7/11/19 3:23pm

I am not convinced that being a school that Title IX wouldn't wiggle into the

AggieWeekendCougar

7/11/19 4:01pm

It seems typical that a poster with 'Aggie' in his boardname would have a hard

UberDeek

7/11/19 4:02pm

So now you resort to personal attacks to quell an opinion...and you wonder why

AggieWeekendCougar

7/11/19 4:13pm

Its called an ad hominem argument.

Pioneercoug

7/11/19 4:25pm

Oh, I'm not a BYU grad... One doesn't have to be THAT smart to know that

UberDeek

7/11/19 4:52pm

Again, this wouldn't require the school to pay anybody anything. Sponsors wouldn't

mik3

7/11/19 4:51pm

RE: other than that the Church has to decide whether it is willing to bankroll

The_Cookie_Coug

7/11/19 6:10pm

RE: I don't get why the Church would care about this. It is irrelevant to the

Rigormortise

7/11/19 10:10pm

Does state law affect the rules of a private entity?

IceBlueCoug

7/11/19 2:50pm

It certainly does IN THAT STATE. Unless it violates a constitutional right or

PJMort

7/11/19 5:15pm

This is the best path to getting NCAA football back, so I welcome it.

TCuz

7/11/19 2:53pm

Not sure how this helps anything.

bous44for49

7/11/19 2:59pm

I wonder what a Pac-12 would look like without the California schools.

svenot

7/11/19 3:03pm

Recently, the NCAA announced the creation of a working group

Everyman

7/11/19 3:25pm

Perhaps it will work in BYU's favor. If players can make a lot of money no matter what school they attend...

Crowgar

7/11/19 3:08pm

I initially thought this but how many national companies will

ColumbusCoug

7/11/19 3:10pm

You don't need national companies. NuSkin, Sigfried & Jensen, and about ten thousand emergency

mik3

7/11/19 3:15pm

No no no... Each player gets their own "company" and can recruit downlines!

ryebrye

7/12/19 7:20am

Agreed. BYU could drop major sports.

Sooner Cougar

7/11/19 3:15pm

Nope, never would happen.

Romex

7/11/19 3:24pm

I don't think they will but I definitely wouldn't say "never"

DraperCoug22

7/11/19 4:51pm

As long as it's possible to break even financially, won't change anything at BYU

Lance71

7/11/19 3:57pm

The church doesn’t restrict apostles or leaders from selling books

USMCdad

7/11/19 4:00pm

<fo>Who are these non-donors and do they all have dumb opinions?</fo>

UberDeek

7/11/19 4:00pm

I think student athletes should be paid. A modest amount set by the state/NCAA

Powerbait DPM studnt

7/11/19 4:14pm

Wouldn't it be companies paying the athletes, not the school?

mudpupper

7/11/19 4:25pm

10% of it would be going to the church for the LDS athletes so that would be a

Troy McClure

7/11/19 5:54pm

Great. Now tithing is going to be part of the Honor Code.

Betruewhiteandblue

7/11/19 5:56pm

No. Just part of the ecclesiastical endorsement if anything at all.

Troy McClure

7/11/19 6:01pm

This guy is right

hdx57

7/12/19 8:37am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad