His left foot touched and propelled him out, but before he had control.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 15, 2019
7:25:41pm

ochobeeguy Playmaker

His left foot touched and propelled him out, but before he had control.

Report problem with this ad

ochobeeguy

Bio page: ochobeeguy
Joined: Oct 25, 2010
Last login: May 9, 2024
Total posts: 17,662 (9 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Just watched the 3rd down Pittman catch out of bounds review

zerigke

9/15/19 4:52pm

Too Zapruder to overturn

Indy Coug

9/15/19 4:55pm

And USC got extremely lucky on the long Pittman TD catch.

AD4

9/15/19 4:59pm

Easily could have been offensive PI.

Jeffacka

9/15/19 5:11pm

Was called for almost the exact thing later in the game.

ochobeeguy

9/15/19 7:24pm

Maybe not offensive PI - but definitely went out of bounds on his own!!!

farsurfer

9/15/19 9:54pm

I think it might have been a catch. I think it is overturned 2/10.

CosmoK

9/15/19 4:59pm

I think you are correct. It may have been a makeup call.

Backcountry

9/15/19 5:04pm

My thoughts exactly

towerman

9/15/19 5:14pm

If you just think then they got it right

9/15/19 5:06pm

It really is that simple. I don't know why this is so hard.

9/15/19 5:21pm

And that’s rules of the game. Every team deals with it...

Refugee

9/15/19 9:56pm

It doesn't matter if you think. You have to know.

9/15/19 5:20pm

That’s why I wish the refs only had 60 seconds per review

KingDave

9/15/19 5:24pm

I bet you are a high level exec at some super successful corporation or

slowhiteguy

9/15/19 5:25pm

There should be a shot clock on video reviews. If you can’t see in 30 seconds, move on

9/15/19 5:47pm

I think 4 out of 5 times

johnnybyu

9/15/19 5:22pm

Thank Chad Bunn

Beggar

9/15/19 5:42pm

Not even close to conclusive evidence that his toe touched. Easy "Call stands".

Ironhide

9/15/19 5:55pm

I think the question was control vs. timing of toe touch.

CosmoK

9/15/19 6:40pm

There is no definitive evidence of a toe touch inbounds

Captain Stubing

9/15/19 10:19pm

Watched it several times. I didn't see anything conclusive.

Dr T-bone

9/15/19 6:59pm

I don't think his touched the ground. It may hav skimmed the top of some grass, but it never touched down.

SpiffCoug

9/15/19 6:59pm

Is skimming the top of the grass enough?

kC Cougar

9/15/19 7:17pm

Probably. But w/ BYU goggles on it's not down if it only touches the top of the grass.

SpiffCoug

9/15/19 7:19pm

His left foot touched and propelled him out, but before he had control.

ochobeeguy

9/15/19 7:25pm

This is what I think. The left foot was floating not down.

kiyoshige

9/15/19 8:27pm

But you can't tell if he was still gathering the ball.

ochobeeguy

9/15/19 7:23pm

I think that gets overturned 0/10 times if the booth is doing their job.

Mojave

9/15/19 7:35pm

The point about extremely lucky is fair. Could have been called a catch and then indisputable goes the other way.

9/15/19 8:09pm

Exactly.

Refugee

9/15/19 10:28pm

Key word. "Think". Different from "for sure". That's why call stood.

Coug Dude

9/15/19 9:00pm

RE: Just watched the 3rd down Pittman catch out of bounds review

cmarrio

9/15/19 9:34pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad