He has 1 big win to put his cap on, Wisconsin, in a season he still lost to Boise, Utah, and USU.
He is 1-9 Vs rivals, he will likely lose to Boise and USU again going 1-11 against rivals.
He has given BYU its worst season in 50-60 years.
He has some of the worst losses in BYU history (ECU, Umass)
He has shown no reason to believe BYU can consistently win under him.
What he is building is a mediocre G5 program. I'm convinced you could give Kalani 10 seasons in the MWC of today and he wouldn't win it once.