Congrats to BYU. But doesn’t change my point - if I was BYU and could trade that in for a 04/08 undefeated season PLUS invite to P5 you would be foolish not to do so.
84 was a looonnnnggggg time ago. The 04/08 season were awesome and memorable, but even those have lost a bit of steam over time, and only because of time. You can’t live on past glory forever - hence why we make fun of people walking around in their highschool letterman jackets.