You were comparing BYU's record against a smidge of a P12 sample size with Utah's P12 record to imply BYU > Utah or at least BYU is P5 competitive on a larger scale. Point stands; winning against P5 1 to 2 times a year like a G5 or 4 times a year (which you have not done) as an indy is not on level with winning against a full P5 conference schedule.