Not even close. 2001, 2006, 2008, 2009 would have run them off the field

Jan 19, 2021
3:04:21pm

reddead All-American

It was definitely BYU's best record since 1996, and a great season for stats. But the team struggled against too many teams for me to think of them as a powerhouse.

Report problem with this ad

reddead

Bio page: reddead
Joined: Nov 16, 2009
Last login: Mar 27, 2023
Total posts: 5,151 (9 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

Fargo

1/19/21 10:52am

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

2FarGone

1/19/21 10:53am

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

Sea Chicken

1/19/21 10:53am

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

Turnpike Lane

1/19/21 10:54am

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

braddahmike

1/19/21 10:57am

No need to roast. Your post history does the talking.

Lip Gallagher

1/19/21 10:59am

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

Yiowa

1/19/21 11:02am

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

WallaX2

1/19/21 11:04am

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

HuskerFan2

1/19/21 11:05am

Accurate

Yiowa

1/19/21 11:05am

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

m0resn0w

1/19/21 11:56am

Boom! Roasted!

'92Coug

1/19/21 8:30pm

Kalani's a better fit for BYU. He also has staying power and Grimes doesn't.

BlueFever

1/19/21 11:08am

I love Coach Grimes, but

CopperLix

1/19/21 11:10am

Yeah, but would Grimes have hired Grimes?

SouthernCoug

1/19/21 11:24am

More important, does he keep Tuiaki?

Z-Ute

1/19/21 12:15pm

Yep, roasted. Poor take. But I like your bold style. You're going places, kid

OldFogey

1/19/21 11:37am

At least you are consistent.

Benfica1

1/19/21 11:41am

Here's a Thought Fargo

Royalblueglasses

1/19/21 11:58am

What will you say if BYU goes 6-6 this coming year?

Fargo

1/19/21 12:39pm

A lot of Sitaki love going 11-1

Z-Ute

1/19/21 12:53pm

RE: What will you say if BYU goes 6-6 this coming year?

Royalblueglasses

1/19/21 3:02pm

<< Deleted >>

BYUlv

1/19/21 12:07pm

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

Kavorka

1/19/21 12:19pm

So are other coaches...so what? Are any of them coming here?

Refugee

1/19/21 12:45pm

I think someone like Grimes should be considered as HC. BYU needs to get away

Fargo

1/19/21 3:24pm

Killing the program? Wrong year to take that stance IMHO...

Refugee

1/19/21 7:05pm

This is like saying

southprovocougar

1/20/21 9:44am

Not to roast you, but I don't know. Grimes wants to run an SEC type

oldrugger

1/19/21 12:51pm

I just think BYU will miss his level of professionalism and certainly what he

Fargo

1/19/21 3:08pm

I completely agree with you there.

oldrugger

1/19/21 4:29pm

I think the word that you are looking for is 'ran', not 'runs'.

southprovocougar

1/20/21 9:51am

That's massive speculation. Where'd you come up with all of that?

Lip Gallagher

1/19/21 3:14pm

Frankly, you're stating something as fact that is merely your speculation.

Katewot

1/19/21 1:24pm

Frankly you're stating something as fact that is merely your opinion.

CougarThug

1/19/21 1:39pm

He's correct. It is a fact (not opinion) that Fargo's claim is just speculation.

Benfica1

1/19/21 1:51pm

Of course it is just my opinion. I would think that is obvious.

Fargo

1/19/21 3:09pm

I just don't get this. Why do people dislike Kalani so much? I think both are

Cougar TD

1/19/21 1:32pm

Because holding aside two anomalous seasons, he's painfully bad

reddead

1/19/21 1:45pm

Well, yes. If you discredit his good seasons and only look at the bad ones, he

Cougar TD

1/19/21 1:55pm

Sure. And if you put stock in 2020, you'll be disappointed every other season

reddead

1/19/21 2:43pm

There are always people that find a rain drop on a sunny day. You found it!

OldFogey

1/19/21 2:43pm

Of course you'll be disappointed, it was the best BYU team since '96.

bluescholar

1/19/21 2:45pm

Not even close. 2001, 2006, 2008, 2009 would have run them off the field

reddead

1/19/21 3:04pm

So what is painfully bad? What kind of record next year? I want to know what

Cougar TD

1/19/21 2:53pm

BYU will win 7 in 2021. We'll see about 2022 (schedule is incomplete)

reddead

1/19/21 3:06pm

I see a 4-7 2021 season. New QB, new OC

coastcat

1/19/21 5:56pm

Yeah, it could get bad

reddead

1/19/21 6:11pm

By good season do you mean this past season because let's be honest, BYU played

Fargo

1/19/21 3:14pm

He's had five seasons and you ignore two of them? And you seem to forget

bluescholar

1/19/21 2:27pm

It took special talent to go 4-9 in 2017, I'll tell you that

reddead

1/19/21 2:48pm

Again, you seem to completely ignore advanced metrics, which take into account

bluescholar

1/19/21 2:56pm

Oh yeah. By all means, enjoy the advanced metric top-10 ranking

reddead

1/19/21 3:02pm

I'm with you. The schedule was cupcake from top to bottom. Even BSU sucked.

Fargo

1/19/21 3:17pm

Yep, advanced metrics are wrong and your very scientific "top-10 teams don't

bluescholar

1/19/21 3:28pm

Lol noting that UTSA went 7-5 doesn’t make the final score any better

reddead

1/19/21 9:42pm

Nah, top 10 teams have plenty of bad games against decent competition.

bluescholar

1/20/21 11:52am

This coming season will be very telling. We will see what happens. I will

Fargo

1/19/21 3:16pm

2021 will be telling just like 2020 was telling, 2019 was telling, etc. BYU

bluescholar

1/19/21 3:34pm

Some CBers are just weird.

Benfica1

1/19/21 1:55pm

I don't hate him at all. I think at this point he is average at best as a head

Fargo

1/19/21 3:11pm

First things first: you are board newbie

Elvis

1/19/21 1:36pm

Actually each of the amounts you said he was down by were negative, so

Schultz is back

1/19/21 1:48pm

Completely agree with you and is really all I'm pointing out with my added

Fargo

1/19/21 3:21pm

How quickly CB has forgotten Sitake's extension after Idaho State

reddead

1/19/21 1:36pm

I take it you're not into advanced metrics?

bluescholar

1/19/21 2:33pm

Well at least one person agrees with me. I think everyone else will be agreeing

Fargo

1/19/21 3:22pm

Same here. This is one area where I'd love to be very, very wrong

reddead

1/19/21 6:12pm

Offensive Coordinator is a different skill set than head coach.

BlueBeliever

1/19/21 1:37pm

I would’ve fired Sitake after seeing two plays:

bbd24

1/19/21 2:41pm

painful learning experiences

BYU Grounds

1/19/21 4:20pm

IMO, Grimes is an elite OL coach a very good OC, but I'm not sure about a HC.

Emmett Fitz-Hume

1/19/21 4:26pm

RE: IMO, Grimes is an elite OL coach a very good OC, but I'm not sure about a

Lip Gallagher

1/19/21 4:28pm

Grimes is great at instilling discipline. He's great at managing/delegating (as this year as OC showed when he handed

unctoothman

1/19/21 4:54pm

The timing of these posts is hilarious

cougargollum

1/19/21 7:28pm

RE: I'm probably going to get roasted for saying this but here goes.

IceBlue

1/19/21 8:21pm

Your freezing cold takes are laughable to anyone familiar with the program.

Coug-de-Lyon

1/19/21 9:07pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad