Five? Guess that puts the hundreds on Cochrane Review to shame? Or the

Sep 22, 2022
10:37:37am

valleus All-American

hundreds represented by UpToDate research summaries. I can find five doctors who will say chocolate and wine are good for you or that Reiki works. That isn’t how scientific reasoning works.

Report problem with this ad

valleus

Bio page: valleus
Joined: Feb 1, 2017
Last login: May 24, 2024
Total posts: 9,495 (2,230 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Well, this is depressing...

Goliath

9/22/22 5:48am

More donuts it is.

vagabonder

9/22/22 5:50am

So if my math is right, up your donut intake by 15% just too be safe.

Spiff

9/22/22 9:26pm

That’s because most people aren’t really depressed. They’re bored.

MormonThug

9/22/22 5:58am

And IIRC, studies show that exercise is at least as effective as meds and

RevolutionDeathsquad

9/22/22 6:02am

Only for mild to moderate depression & anxiety. Most people who experience

BlooCoog

9/22/22 7:30am

I think medicine can help with acute cases to help avert crisis, but then ...

runnincoug

9/22/22 8:47am

For *mild* depression. Recommending exercise solely for the severely depressed

valleus

9/22/22 9:00am

Tom Cruise was right?

Plato

9/22/22 6:02am

Antidepressants are a misnomer. They should be called by what they do which is change the balance of..

greatbam

9/22/22 6:40am

The brain adapts to the change induced by the SSRIs reducing their effectiveness

justAnotherCoug

9/22/22 8:17am

Part of this is how we diagnose depression. We are naming symptoms not causes

The Dark Knight

9/22/22 6:51am

That’s really the only practical way to diagnose mental health conditions. They

BlooCoog

9/22/22 6:02pm

Not really. These pop news reports are not accurately describing what the

valleus

9/22/22 8:46am

You've given the correct answer.

mbs6

9/22/22 8:49am

You've vastly misrepresented the article

Goliath

9/22/22 9:08am

Five? Guess that puts the hundreds on Cochrane Review to shame? Or the

valleus

9/22/22 10:37am

And you think the article was intended to be a scholarly paper?; Interesting

Goliath

9/22/22 6:06pm

It isn't just this article. It is in the standard textbook for Abnormal Psych

The Dark Knight

9/22/22 10:34am

We've known for a long time that therapies like CBT work better...

runnincoug

9/22/22 10:57am

I would disagree with that as a blanket statement. The research shows that

valleus

9/22/22 2:55pm

that may be true about severe depression ... I'd need to look into it more.

runnincoug

9/22/22 4:41pm

<< Deleted >>

Posting on CougarBoard