I did not talk past him, but rather directly addressed that all three traits can exist in the same being despite natural disasters. You were the one who conflated that to a broader issue that I then addressed.

You didn't address the issue, you defined down "all-powerful" to mean really-powerful-but-not-totally.

A truly all-powerful god could still design trials and allow us agency in ways that didn't require the random mass death/displacement of thousands.