Let me rephrase: they should be in consideration.

Sep 15, 2014
11:10:46pm

VenetianCougar

I would take OK St. in that scenario. But if everyone in the Big XII had lost twice, for example, I'd prefer to see two SEC teams.

Report problem with this ad

VenetianCougar

Previous username: jj54321
New username: Mrs Featerbottom
Bio page: VenetianCougar
Joined: Oct 25, 2009
Last login: Jun 2, 2018
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What I don't get, is if the reason to go to a 4 game playoff is to make the

delbert

9/15/14 4:55pm

It should be the best 4 teams. It shouldn't matter what conference they're in.

OpusX

9/15/14 5:05pm

If you're not the best team in your conference then how can you be the best team

BYUflynn

9/15/14 5:54pm

Maybe the 2nd best team in a conference is also 2nd best in the country

OpusX

9/15/14 7:14pm

You are Auburn. You lose by 3 points on the road to Alabama.

VenetianCougar

9/15/14 10:27pm

No they shouldn't

PolarisPrime

9/15/14 10:36pm

Let me rephrase: they should be in consideration.

VenetianCougar

9/15/14 11:10pm

I never think that two teams from the same conference

PolarisPrime

9/16/14 12:32am

I agree in principle, but conferences don't play round robins anymore.

VenetianCougar

9/16/14 6:17am

Sadly, with the playoff they will feel more entitled to

PolarisPrime

9/16/14 11:04am

Very true. I like 4 better. 8 is ideal for me.

VenetianCougar

9/16/14 10:09pm

It's possible for an NFL team to win the Super Bowl without winning their

workindev

9/15/14 5:06pm

I would agree with this if college football was set up the same way as the NFL

delbert

9/15/14 5:21pm

Apples and Oranges

CougBlu

9/15/14 5:27pm

RE: Apples and Oranges

gwill

9/15/14 5:51pm

RE: Apples and Oranges

CougBlu

9/15/14 6:08pm

It should be the 5 major conf. champions plus 3 others

cocktosten

9/15/14 5:07pm

This is the right answer. if only.

delbert

9/15/14 5:12pm

This was decided upon during the negotiations between the P5s.

Everymancoug

9/15/14 5:16pm

I recognize everyone signed off on it, I am just saying I think it would

delbert

9/15/14 5:23pm

Agree. But as ecp mentions below, it' s about money and power.

Everymancoug

9/15/14 5:34pm

It's all about money and control.

ecp

9/15/14 5:21pm

I agree.

delbert

9/15/14 5:23pm

It's funny to see all the shrinking capitalists when it comes to football

OpusX

9/15/14 5:39pm

P5 functions like a cartel. Cartels and monopolies are the bane of the free

Mathlete

9/15/14 5:46pm

We invented Cartels.

OpusX

9/15/14 7:20pm

Because the 2nd best SEC team is often the 2nd best team in the country.

DoseOfReality

9/15/14 5:49pm

So when LSU and Bamma played in the BCS Championship Game

PolarisPrime

9/15/14 6:09pm

No system will be perfect but reality is that two of four could be from same

SwampCougar

9/15/14 6:18pm

I disagree. In Basketball rematches are fine because

PolarisPrime

9/15/14 6:25pm

Slightly better than the 6-3 reg season offensive juggernaut battle

SwampCougar

9/15/14 6:31pm

Also, We just need all SEC teams to have at least 2 losses which is possible

SwampCougar

9/15/14 6:32pm

True

PolarisPrime

9/15/14 6:43pm

The committee has its directive

wapiti

9/15/14 6:23pm

The top two teems in the NFL may be in the same conference

delbert

9/15/14 9:37pm

And the keyword is "think"

PolarisPrime

9/15/14 10:07pm

because they want, theoretically, the BEST teams, not conference champions.

Real Men Wear Blue

9/15/14 7:34pm

Condi Rice will keep things straight and ethical.

Rocketman

9/15/14 8:06pm

You haven't realized by now that college football is all about the SEC?

Posting on CougarBoard