BTW-Hill did have several years of position & coordinator experience before BYU

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 22, 2014
9:40:30am

BYUFam1

BTW-Hill did have several years of position & coordinator experience before BYU

Either way - hard to take seriously the "absolute never should have someone learning on the job" line some use for the coordinator situation but then a "sure why not" response for the HC...

And again - I get that is the way it works and am OK with it myself - but the double talk others have about it should be called out...

Report problem with this ad

BYUFam1

Bio page: BYUFam1
Joined: Jul 6, 2010
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 25,225 (246 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I love it when the Fire Bronco crowd is asked who they want to replace him and

Real G Man

10/22/14 9:07am

Uncle Rico?

AtlantaCoug

10/22/14 9:08am

I don't mind that answer

Sea Chicken

10/22/14 9:09am

I once took Army to back to back national championships scoring with only field

Garn

10/22/14 9:12am

Haha! Great post! Was your record before that better than 6-34?

CougarBuckeye-BYUI

10/22/14 9:18am

Not neccisarily true. A fan of BYU that watches all their

BlueFrog

10/22/14 9:14am

The problem is, generally speaking, is they either have unreal expectaions i.e.

Jhayes

10/22/14 11:39am

What kills me is that they complain about Bronco being a DC and they want to

John Doe

10/22/14 9:16am

Logic not allowed here.

Iman23

10/22/14 9:17am

Good, because his post didn't have any.

messi

10/22/14 9:44am

And of course that makes you right . . . of course it does or something like

COUGAR_Blue_Avenger

10/22/14 12:10pm

its because they can't imagine it being much worse. losing 4 straight non p5

10/22/14 9:19am

"... but they're positive he would just step in and do better than Bronco has."

messi

10/22/14 9:41am

And what I do love is that when a person is named...

10/22/14 9:17am

Its the old known vrs unknown debate really.

bald man

10/22/14 9:19am

And that's where I kind of stand...

10/22/14 9:23am

I'm not sold on Sitake being HC material, and I'm not sure

bald man

10/22/14 9:27am

Sitaki has been coaching the LB's at Utah since 2005...

10/22/14 9:41am

The numbers sure suggest he knows what he is doing at DC and LB.

yfootball

10/22/14 1:46pm

Since joining the PAC, his numbers have been pretty average...

10/22/14 2:01pm

Right. I guess I am just more impressed with the numbers than you. But watching

yfootball

10/22/14 3:45pm

Oh no I'm still very impressed...

10/22/14 3:51pm

Well there is a good portion that degrade current coordinators for learning

BYUFam1

10/22/14 9:22am

If Bronco was hiring a coordinator that has had...

10/22/14 9:27am

BTW-Hill did have several years of position & coordinator experience before BYU

BYUFam1

10/22/14 9:40am

Hill actually had a decent defense in 2009...

10/22/14 9:46am

I only brought him up because he gets lumped with Doman/Howell

BYUFam1

10/22/14 9:54am

Crowton was HC at LaTech for 3 years.

bald man

10/22/14 9:27am

I failed to know that; just thought he was OC - I knew Bears OC right before BYU

BYUFam1

10/22/14 9:41am

would you have picked rose to replace Cleveland? Yet they took the leap and did

Mayor of Cougartown

10/22/14 9:18am

Cleveland also tanked hard. Bronco may end up with that this year

bald man

10/22/14 9:20am

Cleveland left on his own. Somebody had to be hired.

hansel

10/22/14 9:26am

riiiigggghhhht. Left on his own, Good one.

Mayor of Cougartown

10/22/14 9:32am

I don't think I'm revealing classified information here. Pretty well-known that

hansel

10/22/14 9:41am

yes it was. He was going to be fired, that job popped up and he took it and

Mayor of Cougartown

10/22/14 9:46am

link?

hansel

10/22/14 9:47am

Think about it. If he were killing it at BYU and had a team in place to

Mayor of Cougartown

10/22/14 9:54am

That's your version. Here's Dick Harmon's

hansel

10/22/14 10:01am

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

10/22/14 11:18am

They didn't let Cleveland go, he left for for a gig in his hometown

boyblue

10/22/14 9:33am

The guy brought BYU hoops back from the absolute dead and had five

hansel

10/22/14 9:44am

agreed

boyblue

10/22/14 9:45am

disagree.

Mayor of Cougartown

10/22/14 9:47am

Here, read these

hansel

10/22/14 9:52am

ok, I'll concede...sorta... he really let himself and BYU off the hook

Mayor of Cougartown

10/22/14 10:00am

Yep, they were not going to fire him, but they didn't try to stop him from

fredgarvin

10/22/14 10:13am

So you want them to take Tom Holmoe's job then?

lawboy

10/22/14 9:28am

I love how they think these inexperienced coaches are guaranteed to do better

boyblue

10/22/14 9:31am

These people you're describing don't exist.

swingcat

10/22/14 4:47pm

It depends on your perspective, I guess.

10/22/14 9:33am

My only request from Mr. Holmoe and the Board of Trustees is that if Bronco is

Faceman

10/22/14 9:34am

It reminds me of a time when I asked this question

bigbluecougar

10/22/14 9:34am

That crowd has had a number of suggestions. Some pie in the sky

unctoothman

10/22/14 9:39am

1) I've heard tons of suggestions 2) yes, it really is not CB's job to find a HC

Non-mo Coug

10/22/14 9:56am

I love it when the Keep Bronco crowd doesn't realize he wasn't even our own

10/22/14 10:12am

He wasn't my first choice, but in retrospect, I think he was the right choice.

10/22/14 10:24am

I actually agree with you. I just think its time to move on.

10/22/14 10:28am

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

10/22/14 10:48am

Maybe a better way to say it is "conveniently ignore"

10/22/14 11:36am

If Bronco had it his way, a walkon would replace him.

Veracruz

10/22/14 12:41pm

*cough* Howell *cough*

slowhiteguy

10/22/14 12:49pm

RE: Thanks. You hit the nail on the head.

Coogar2

10/22/14 1:07pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad