Senior...yes. Experienced...yes. Ready to lead.......?

Aug 21, 2018
11:53:51am

icecougar All-American

....that is a big question mark imo. He didn’t look ready to lead last year and he admittedly wasn’t ready to lead in 2016 when Taysom won the starting job.

Report problem with this ad

icecougar

Bio page: icecougar
Joined: Apr 17, 2006
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 40,446 (330 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I've got a feeling about QB...and I think I am starting to change my mind

Fdnman

8/21/18 4:25am

After yesterday's practice they sure are keeping us guessing, I'll give them

Left Shark Coug

8/21/18 5:09am

Yep.

Refugee

8/21/18 7:25am

Ok. My guess - it will be Mangum. They're keeping it from AZ on purpose

stevebyu8

8/21/18 8:14am

I’m starting to lean this way after thinking all last week it had to be Wilson. It could go either way

Refugee

8/21/18 9:29am

You make an interesting point and you may very well be right. I still think

mm73

8/21/18 5:55am

I think the coaches want whoever wins the job to command the respect of the team

Junior Deputy

8/21/18 6:01am

Logic...

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 6:03am

Most seniors with experience will start over a true freshman, according to logic

Fdnman

8/21/18 6:11am

RE: Most seniors with experience will start over a true freshman, according to

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 6:26am

I got the feeling he stated Tanner would start because...drumroll...

Refugee

8/21/18 7:28am

RE: I got the feeling he stated Tanner would start because...drumroll...

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 7:59am

Relax. Regardless of what he’s done or hasn’t done, it’s been his job to lose.

Refugee

8/21/18 8:03am

RE: Relax. Regardless of what he’s done or hasn’t done, it’s

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 8:08am

It's ok...FW is one of the reasons I put the caveat in my OP. 🙂

Fdnman

8/21/18 8:11am

You thought there was a serious issue in 2013 when Taysom was healthy all year?

D.T. Survivor

8/21/18 8:19am

RE: You thought there was a serious issue in 2013 when Taysom was healthy all

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 8:27am

I can agree with all that. Just wouldn't call those years serious issues.

D.T. Survivor

8/21/18 9:19am

There was a lot of turmoil last year

shakarocks

8/21/18 8:29am

RE: There was a lot of turmoil last year

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 8:39am

If the said senior earned the job. TM has obviously not earned it yet

Cougstreak

8/21/18 7:09am

Yes, this experienced senior is competing for a job; not a confidence builder

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 7:29am

Fact

libertycoug

8/21/18 10:10am

Strong feelings on the matter for someone on the board one whole day.

ManicBlue

8/21/18 11:45pm

The alternative view

wilsdad

8/21/18 6:28am

RE: The alternative view

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 6:42am

KS is the one that started that rumor in an interview to keep the heat off him.

coolblue

8/21/18 7:03am

This is exactly what I think is going on. Plus you get a far more prepared

soupie

8/21/18 7:29am

2015: Did well - for freshmen, 2016: Taysom was QB, 2017: Offense was terrible

Benfica1

8/21/18 8:00am

Neither of those two are going to keep Arizona guessing. They

kotacoug

8/21/18 6:50am

Agreed!

Fervent Cougar

8/21/18 6:57am

OTOH, a new OC will keep Arizona guessing

CougarVeteran

8/21/18 7:18am

When is Critchlow's dad going to speak up?

WJCougar

8/21/18 7:04am

There's are several reasons not to name a starter

shakarocks

8/21/18 7:38am

RE: There's are several reasons not to name a starter

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 7:46am

shakarocks

8/21/18 7:54am

RE: No

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 8:02am

I'm saying there are a lot of reasons for not naming a QB

shakarocks

8/21/18 8:24am

RE: I'm saying there are a lot of reasons for not naming a QB

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 8:33am

I know this has been said before:

D.T. Survivor

8/21/18 7:47am

Balderdash

shakarocks

8/21/18 7:55am

I disagree. Usually a senior who has started three years would be the clear cut

D.T. Survivor

8/21/18 7:58am

Didn’t work that way last year. Try something new w/ well reasoned arguments

soupie

8/21/18 8:11am

RE: Didn’t work that way last year. Try something new w/ well reasoned

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 9:13am

Those reasons are just as much a guess as anything else

D.T. Survivor

8/21/18 9:28am

RE: Balderdash

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 8:04am

That's a possibility

shakarocks

8/21/18 8:20am

I think the coaches aren't totally sold on Mangum's leadership at this point.

mudpupper

8/21/18 8:51am

RE: I think the coaches are totally sold on Mangum's leadership at this point.

FairWeather-L.I.T.S.

8/21/18 9:01am

If it was the Freshmen, there is no harm in announcing it. Why? NO film of him

PhilPete

8/21/18 8:59am

Coaches have made a choice, they know and the team knows. It’s just about

Santos L. Halper

8/21/18 9:15am

It'll be Mangum

rggee

8/21/18 9:37am

You described exactly how things played out with Utah naming Huntley over -

Demosthenes Red

8/21/18 10:19am

Senior...yes. Experienced...yes. Ready to lead.......?

icecougar

8/21/18 11:53am

Wouldn't hold '16 against him at all.

soupie

8/21/18 11:56am

I go back further than that. During the 2016 season he confessed that...

Posting on CougarBoard