I think you talent assumption is debatable

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 1, 2020
10:33:16am

AingeEraCoug Contributor

I think you talent assumption is debatable

In 2016 BYU may have had better starting talent than is expected from the 2020 team, but not as much depth as we will have in 2020.

There is a learning curve for every new head coach and BYU hasn't had a great upper class man at QB in 2017-2019. Tanner had a few shinning moments, but didn't develop into a game changer talent. I think BYU is currently in much better shape at QB now that the 3 top QBs have more experience. I believe all 3 have more upside than Mangum.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jun 1, 2020 at 10:33:16am

Message modified by AingeEraCoug on Jun 1, 2020 at 10:39:41am

Report problem with this ad

AingeEraCoug

Bio page: AingeEraCoug
Joined: Mar 25, 2001
Last login: Apr 30, 2024
Total posts: 1,247 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Kalani - Average Head Coach or Not. You all know I go with "Not"

TeeKaa

5/31/20 4:56pm

Over last 3 years KS is 15-21 vs FBS teams = 42% winning percentage. Stinketh!

Hinta

5/31/20 5:01pm

RE: Over last 3 years KS is 15-21 vs FBS teams = 42% winning percentage. Stinketh!

letthewookieewin

5/31/20 5:13pm

his record is 27-25 his first 4 years. But 4-3 combined against BIG-10 and SEC!

BYURider

5/31/20 7:52pm

That statistic makes people even more frustrated

BeardedSpock

6/1/20 12:11pm

All solid metrics and hard to argue, however.....

Pretorian

5/31/20 6:51pm

Different issue. I'm not in the camp where we stick with bad because

TeeKaa

5/31/20 8:39pm

Evidently, You don’t know what poop is.... it can be way more poopy than this.

Pretorian

6/1/20 5:09am

Could also be better than this. See: Toledo, USF, SDSU, Hawaii. All "L's".

BleedCougarBlue2

6/1/20 12:38pm

That was absolutely poopieness... kinda evened out by the Vols and USC... those

Pretorian

6/1/20 1:08pm

Fairly confident I addressed that when I wrote "or risk deeper" poop.

TeeKaa

6/1/20 1:02pm

“Deeper” implies we’re are in The poop now, which I’d disagree with....

Pretorian

6/2/20 11:38am

Shoulda hired Weber State's HC at the end of last season. Just sayin'.....

BleedCougarBlue2

5/31/20 10:15pm

You’re wrong... just say’n

Pretorian

6/1/20 5:10am

Nope. Your turn.

BleedCougarBlue2

6/1/20 12:30pm

I was just saying....

Pretorian

6/1/20 12:33pm

Jay Hill would be at the very top of my list

BYU Fan

5/31/20 11:18pm

What about Lavell? He didn’t knock any socks off at first, my point Is

Pretorian

6/1/20 5:11am

You said "get on board" with KS. "Get on board" with barely .500? Uhhh.....no.

BleedCougarBlue2

6/1/20 12:36pm

I personally found the KS first 4 years vs last 4 years most compelling.

5/31/20 7:15pm

I see BM differently. I think he got out-schemed all the time and lost games he

OldFogey

5/31/20 7:53pm

RE: I see BM differently. I think he got out-schemed all the time and lost games

5/31/20 8:17pm

As I Clearly stated in my post - it's not a Bronco love post. Just data

TeeKaa

5/31/20 8:42pm

Yes, I concur. I agree your post wasn't a BM love post. I just don't think he's

OldFogey

5/31/20 9:39pm

Bronco hate is just sour grapes at this point, dude is a very good coach

Pretorian

6/1/20 5:24am

For many here Bronco committed the unpardonable sin of succeeding after he left

BeardedSpock

6/1/20 11:53am

A fair assessment. It's just that I felt that way when he was here. Not some

OldFogey

6/1/20 2:24pm

You're an extremist on here. Nobody cares.

5/31/20 8:13pm

I think you analysis is simplistic

5/31/20 8:32pm

People look for the easiest and most shallow answers to support ideas they've

6/1/20 12:00am

Kalani's first team was his most talented.

6/1/20 9:45am

I think you talent assumption is debatable

6/1/20 10:33am

there were a number of factors that contributed to 2017, some on Kalani and...

icecougar

6/1/20 6:04pm

Factor in players, exp, etc??? That's only if your name is Phil Steele...

icecougar

6/2/20 4:28pm

Kalani will NEVER have a winning record against Utah at this point.

Gathers

5/31/20 9:50pm

The previous coach was 0-5 in his last 5 games against Utah

donnerstag

6/1/20 4:49am

neither will BYU

icecougar

6/2/20 4:24pm

Average not terrible HC. KS has a better winning percentage than Gary Andersen,

Forzaitalia

5/31/20 9:50pm

Kalani has been gifted several wins each year & still has a losing record vs FBS

BYU Fan

5/31/20 11:13pm

Amen.

TeeKaa

5/31/20 11:30pm

Wait...didn’t Twitter have a fact check label on this post?

icecougar

6/1/20 2:23am

A 7-12 P5 record is actually probably average. The 17-13 G5 record is far worse.

Gorum the Old

6/1/20 7:26am

Two things... who would you replace him with? And,

1CougFan

6/1/20 8:36am

Answer: Jay Hill, in a heartbeat.

BleedCougarBlue2

6/1/20 12:40pm

Oh yeah!!!! See the 4* dudes start lining up!!!

Pretorian

6/1/20 1:10pm

I bet KS barely wins over .500 this year, once again. Hope I'm wrong but....

BleedCougarBlue2

6/2/20 11:43am

You anti's need to stop saying you hope you're wrong.

6/2/20 12:43pm

reminds me of Bill Maher wishing we would get into a recession just so Trump....

icecougar

6/2/20 6:18pm

for starters, that's never a reason to keep the status quo...

icecougar

6/2/20 6:02pm

Another acid test: could he get another HC job if fired from BYU?

coug92

6/1/20 8:43am

Nope, he couldn't. At least not in the FBS.

BleedCougarBlue2

6/1/20 12:41pm

<< Deleted >>

icecougar

6/1/20 9:34am

Hope you stretched out properly before attempting all those gymnastics...

icecougar

6/1/20 9:36am

Byu is one of the toughest jobs in America

hereforlaughs

6/1/20 9:41am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad