Yep - two dropped punts is two to many

Report problem with this ad

Oct 18, 2020
7:29:54am

BYU Fan All-American

Report problem with this ad

BYU Fan

Bio page: BYU Fan
Joined: Mar 7, 2002
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 24,219 (1,062 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I think it’s time to move away from Milne as a punt returner

sidsie716

10/18/20 7:24am

Yep - two dropped punts is two to many

BYU Fan

10/18/20 7:29am

Two two* many

ChiCityCoug

10/18/20 11:10am

*two too many

ImBlueDaBaDe

10/18/20 12:10pm

You sure? That doesn’t look right

ChiCityCoug

10/18/20 12:13pm

*tutu

Blueto

10/18/20 12:17pm

Lookin like a silly CB signature of yore.

SinkingQuffa

10/18/20 12:46pm

*2 two many

Ash

10/18/20 1:55pm

Roderick fumbled 4 punts in one game

AZ Coug

10/18/20 3:50pm

I agree. Mostly because he's too valuable on offense to risk getting hurt.

Blueto

10/18/20 7:30am

With two muffs in 5 games, it isn’t worth the risk.

idcougarfan

10/18/20 7:41am

Give Davis a shot at it.

I'm Dynamite

10/18/20 8:24am

yeah

anonymous37

10/18/20 10:42am

I don't think he's doing it as some sort of favor for him. He's probably the

Harbinger

10/18/20 7:42am

And he has 3 yards in 5 games. You need sure hands!

LEDSFW

10/18/20 7:47am

What about Epps, has receiver hands and is quick. Epps & Hill are both underused

Coug76

10/18/20 7:48am

I'd think he'd be great at it, too. He's got notably big hands.

SinkingQuffa

10/18/20 9:59am

Looks like he had 10 total PRs in high school.....

mokelembembe

10/18/20 10:23am

That'd be enough for me to give him a shot in a live game.

SinkingQuffa

10/18/20 10:31am

He’s the punt returner because he has the surest hands

kapcreations

10/18/20 7:48am

He dropped the punt because of kick catch interference. Blaming him for that is like blaming a receiver for getting

YIsForBrigham

10/18/20 7:57am

The interference did not impede his ability to make the catch

bythenumbers

10/18/20 8:44am

You really think only touching interferes with your ability to catch?

Lip Gallagher

10/18/20 9:40am

It did. That’s why it’s called kick catch interference

YIsForBrigham

10/18/20 9:58am

Nonsense.

BurbankCoug

10/18/20 10:03am

To you and the other two responders

bythenumbers

10/18/20 11:55am

Milne needed to be 1 step to his right to catch the ball cleanly

StantonMac

10/18/20 12:39pm

You might be right

bythenumbers

10/18/20 12:47pm

Have you ever fielded a punt? There is a reason that was a clear cut case of kick catch interference.

JohnnyComeLately

10/18/20 10:04am

You couldn't catch a softly-tossed Nerf football with someone that close to you

reddead

10/18/20 11:51am

You're just describing the job of a punt returner

bythenumbers

10/18/20 12:01pm

No, I'm saying is that you shouldn't hold the Houston muff against him

reddead

10/18/20 12:08pm

I think you have to piece together the evidence available

bythenumbers

10/18/20 12:15pm

Exactly, there's a reason it's interference. How hard is this to understand

Lip Gallagher

10/18/20 9:36am

Katoa and Romney are the backups so apparently the coaches don't share

mokelembembe

10/18/20 8:10am

Put in Wake!

homegrown

10/18/20 8:17am

I think he’s back there because, as we’ve heard

BW84

10/18/20 8:18am

That gif in your signature is awesome.

BigEasyCougar

10/18/20 9:06am

The kid has a nice swing.

thirdgencoug

10/18/20 9:51am

To me it’s funny that the kid even has an Ortiz shirt on, while he blasts Big Papi.

BW84

10/18/20 11:41am

We should use Caleb Christensen.

DraperCoug22

10/18/20 9:12am

That's not his thing. He is pure speed returner. Needs giant lanes to shoot.

mokelembembe

10/18/20 9:33am

Then somebody else with sure hands.

DraperCoug22

10/18/20 10:42am

How is it that y’all not realize that the drop was because of the penalty

BYUAnime

10/18/20 9:44am

He very well may be our best, surest option. But he needs to be better I agree.

SinkingQuffa

10/18/20 9:53am

Is there a condom drill that he could do while trying to catch punts? That may

StutterOfTheCougar

10/18/20 10:10am

I've never heard "condom" used euphemistically before.

SinkingQuffa

10/18/20 10:27am

Yeah his first fumble wasn't great, but the second catch wasn't his fault

troymac32

10/18/20 10:01am

My main concern was just how badly he whiffed on it. Even w the interference

SinkingQuffa

10/18/20 10:04am

He actually did come up with it after all.

Fallball

10/18/20 11:17am

As I said. He does deserve credit for it. If he's gonna commit to the ball

SinkingQuffa

10/18/20 11:27am

Plus he went beast mode and recovered the fumble while surrounded by like 7 red jerseys

cheezedawg

10/18/20 5:43pm

What you fail to realize is...

canndyman

10/18/20 10:04am

Agreed, because he's our "go to" receiver. Don't risk him being injured...

CougarThug

10/18/20 10:19am

I agree. 2 muffs in 5 games exceeds acceptable standards...and

AF_Puma

10/18/20 11:08am

I’ll let Kalani know

Heath Squashwell

10/18/20 11:36am

Ika?

Posting on CougarBoard