My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Mar 4, 2021
8:20
:11
am
GSwarriorcoug
All-American
Defense awesome? Impossible. Was Tuiaki out sick?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
GSwarriorcoug
Previous username
(Private)
Bio page
GSwarriorcoug
Joined
Oct 25, 2006
Last login
May 19, 2024
Total posts
6,501 (215 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
It seems like most people expect Hall to be our starting QB. I’m a little
gwalker
3/3/21 8:44am
Hall should be front runner but he gets concussed easily. Romney was a superb
idacoug
3/3/21 8:47am
If he’s the starter, he’ll be running
BenTheBoss
3/3/21 8:48am
Has Hall ever had a better performance than Romney v Boise State in 2019? Maybe
gwalker
3/3/21 8:48am
They both played against the same defense against USU, and Hall had the better
DieHarder
3/3/21 8:49am
Absolutely.
Jeffacka
3/3/21 8:54am
The game plan, including situational gadget plays was a BIG part of BSU win
fulano
3/3/21 8:55am
...which was custom-tailored to Romney's strengths and ability to execute plays
icecougar
3/3/21 10:19am
Which is even more important with Romney's limited ability.
Jeffacka
3/3/21 10:26am
Or it didn’t work as well bc we had put that play on tape?
Jimmerfan32
3/3/21 1:41pm
This and the defense was awesome for 3 quarters. I like Baylor, but that was a team win.
SoBlueitHurts
3/3/21 4:54pm
Defense awesome? Impossible. Was Tuiaki out sick?
GSwarriorcoug
3/4/21 8:20am
I did say three quarters
SoBlueitHurts
3/4/21 1:20pm
So the player who got the starts reps in practice played better than the player
ldssdl
3/3/21 11:00am
Watch both games where he got concussed
idacoug
3/3/21 8:50am
He didn't look that great against USF. They were a terrible team and BYU
ldssdl
3/3/21 11:01am
You’re too worked up about a game played 2 years ago.
ZacSeljaas'Stache
3/3/21 8:51am
I didn’t say anything that disagrees with what you did. I will be happy with
gwalker
3/3/21 9:25am
I really like Romney, but I still put into perspective what he did against BSU
CaliWG
3/3/21 9:01am
Also, let's be honest, Baylor didn't look great in the games he played last year
JKLCoug
3/3/21 9:12am
I think Grimes had an amazing game against Boise state. Romney was good, but don’t see him as having executed better
mvtoro
3/3/21 10:04am
<< Deleted >>
lightmann
3/3/21 10:18am
But why though? How is Hall a better option than the other QBs?
Iron Coug
3/3/21 8:53am
Why "should" Hall be the front-runner? Romney started more games, didn't he?
BleedCougarBlue2
3/3/21 9:14am
Uh, why should he be?
Lip Gallagher
3/3/21 10:35am
Romney was a very serviceable QB, but I think most realize that his ceiling is
RH84025
3/3/21 8:48am
I can agree only if "mobility" is isolated to running/rushing ability...
BYUFam1
3/3/21 8:56am
Romney had more than twice the rushing yards and TDs In HS than Hall did. He was
dazcoug
3/3/21 10:10am
Luckily the starter will not be chosen by CB and the coaches that work with
RH84025
3/3/21 10:23am
Who do you think is the better runner - Hall or Romney? Gotta be Hall, right?
JKLCoug
3/3/21 11:04am
I've know idea going forward but Romney was a better runner by 2x statistically
dazcoug
3/3/21 2:42pm
Film is way more reliable than stats
JKLCoug
3/4/21 5:58pm
I'm wondering if you read this article
warp
3/4/21 8:46pm
I’m not saying Baylor can’t run, I’m saying Hall runs better
JKLCoug
3/5/21 5:49am
Romney suffers because he's not as skilled
braddahmike
3/3/21 8:49am
BYU needed Romney so bad 2 years ago. We needed a serviceable QB that rarely
idacoug
3/3/21 8:52am
We might need that in 2021 too, with a pretty green team and tougher schedule
fulano
3/3/21 8:58am
That's a little too general for me. What skill(s) are you talking about?
SinkingQuffa
3/3/21 1:10pm
the interesting thing about the BSU game is Romney wasn't very efficient
Littlerich
3/3/21 8:50am
Hall is great, but I don't get the obsession.
Iron Coug
3/3/21 8:51am
There is no obsession that I have seen. It’s in your head.
idacoug
3/3/21 8:52am
You're not reading the posts. Borderline obsession.
BleedCougarBlue2
3/3/21 9:17am
I feel there is more obsession with Conover
LakeshowCougs
3/3/21 8:56am
We must get on Cougarboard at different times. I see lots of "Hall should be QB1
Iron Coug
3/3/21 9:48am
<< Deleted >>
dazcoug
3/3/21 10:52am
I don’t see how that equates “obsession.”
Kavorka
3/3/21 6:36pm
You're right - I may be reading too much into the threads. That being said, post
Iron Coug
3/4/21 1:43pm
IMO, 2019 is completely irrelevant at this point.
Indy Coug
3/3/21 8:57am
Baylor’s arm strength is limited, always has been. Lots of QBs have excelled at
Corn Pop
3/3/21 8:58am
RE: Baylor’s arm strength is limited, always has been. Lots of QBs have
akbarishiwatsu
3/3/21 11:41am
Hall is the best talent in the QB room, but the competition is a true toss up
donnerstag
3/3/21 9:03am
I think you put too much stock in athleticism when defining talent
coug10278
3/3/21 9:17am
Hall also has the strongest arm of the three
donnerstag
3/3/21 9:21am
I do not see any evidence that Hall is the best talent. What are you looking at?
Iron Coug
3/3/21 9:50am
Hall has the biggest arm and the best mobility of the three
donnerstag
3/3/21 10:04am
are you SURE he Hall is the most mobile?
warp
3/3/21 2:51pm
1st half w/Jaren @ QB vs USU was the best half of BYU offensive football in '19
Forzaitalia
3/3/21 12:31pm
Hard to dispute this
JKLCoug
3/3/21 2:25pm
What does that even mean he's the best talent?
Lip Gallagher
3/3/21 10:37am
In terms of arm strength & speed, maybe.
SinkingQuffa
3/5/21 9:04am
My gut says Hall and if he gets hurt Conover if BYU keep both. Backup is Romney.
Fdnman
3/3/21 9:28am
It could easily play out that way.
dilbert
3/3/21 9:59am
Romney didn't look great playing with freshmen this year, so people think meh
Coop
3/3/21 9:33am
If we have a good pass protection OL then Romney maybe our best QB.
ParentingNotForSissy
3/3/21 10:16am
Romney is plenty athletic; he was a WR in 2018
Coop
3/3/21 10:51am
He felt less mobile and a pocket passer.He may have some mobility upside coming.
ParentingNotForSissy
3/3/21 11:33am
When he had a broken foot, or when he was in mop-up duty?
Coop
3/3/21 12:33pm
Just learning about the broken foot.
ParentingNotForSissy
3/3/21 5:16pm
I want to believe in Romney..
AltTabbins
3/3/21 10:17am
I have absolutely zero faith in Hall to stay healthy. Two concussions in two
ldssdl
3/3/21 11:05am
Sadly, I agree.
lightmann
3/3/21 11:40am
Remember all the CBers clamoring to bench Wilson last year in favor of Hall or Romney?
2FarGone
3/3/21 11:09am
Hall in the first half at Utah State in 2019 was arguably the best half of QB
Kavorka
3/3/21 12:06pm
Pretty sure Hall will be the guy if he is healty.
dodgersjazzcougs
3/3/21 12:08pm
If things are about equal with all 3 quarterbacks the starting job will go to
Bullrider
3/3/21 4:59pm
RE: If things are about equal with all 3 quarterbacks the starting job will go to
lightmann
3/3/21 7:24pm
Romney in a landslide.
Zach Morris
3/4/21 1:43am
I’m expecting Romney to be the eventual starter.
Sooner Cougar
3/4/21 7:52am
I recall the BYU offense being pretty unremarkable against Boise State
BYU Fan
3/4/21 9:12am
They got rolling in the third quarter. Good balance, but some favorable field position too.
SoBlueitHurts
3/4/21 1:21pm
I think its somewhere in between. More like Detmer to Walsh.
CaliWG
3/5/21 9:17am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad