Since 2007, BYU has 8 NCAA tourney trips. We have been overseeded once, “correct” seed 4 times, and underseeded 3 times.
Using Bracket Matrix as an objective proxy for what was the reasonable expectation for NCAA tournament seeding.
Year, BM seed, Actual seed, +/-
2015: 11, 11, 0
2014: 12, 10, +2
2012: 12, 14, -2
2011: 3, 3, 0
2010: 6, 7, -1
2009: 8, 8, 0
2008: 8, 8, 0
2007: 6, 8, -2
The notion that BYU is “always” underseeded is false.