No, it didn't, at all.

Report problem with this ad

Jun 11, 2021
1:54:15pm

bluescholar All-American

Report problem with this ad

bluescholar

Previous username: drake
Bio page: bluescholar
Joined: Mar 21, 2009
Last login: Apr 25, 2024
Total posts: 3,874 (15 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If BYU's goal is a National Championship, the AAC and MWC isn't the way to go.

SLIVER

6/11/21 11:12am

Unfortunately, a power conference is still the only good option. I would

bluescholar

6/11/21 11:18am

Nothing BYU has done the last 10 years shows they can compete nationally

BYU Fan

6/11/21 11:22am

The only reason BYU got away with the crap schedule last year is because Covid

bluescholar

6/11/21 11:25am

The point remains that Indy isn't working

BYU Fan

6/11/21 12:12pm

Indy is working way better than G5 would be. New playoff format may change the

bluescholar

6/11/21 12:14pm

Proof Indy is working ≠ better than G5.

Iki_Balam

6/11/21 11:26pm

BYU recruiting has tanked in the last 10 years as an Independent

krindorr

6/11/21 12:38pm

You out yourself as a Ute when you make comments like this.

bluescholar

6/11/21 1:11pm

That's just factual - BYUs recruiting rank has gone WAY down in the last decade

krindorr

6/11/21 1:41pm

Team rankings are a horrible way to look at recruiting for teams outside the top

bluescholar

6/11/21 1:53pm

You keep telling me I'm wrong, but keep providing zero evidence to back that up

krindorr

6/11/21 3:33pm

As long as we have the honor code we will never recruit National

LyleLanley

6/11/21 11:23am

There is a type of national player that would choose a place like BYU..

SLIVER

6/11/21 11:39am

But it’s your son’s choice. Not yours.

LyleLanley

6/11/21 12:15pm

What better place to prepare for the NFL?

Alpi Gusto

6/11/21 12:57pm

That pitch will land us top LDS recruits, supposedly.

SLIVER

6/11/21 1:06pm

BYU doesnt stat relevant or respected in indy if we dont take an opportunity

FieroCoug

6/11/21 11:28am

If you honestly think that BYU stands a better chance of winning a NC as an Independent...

Coug

6/11/21 11:34am

Their chances of winning a title are probably actually pretty similar in

bluescholar

6/11/21 11:42am

Third...and most important of all, BYU needs to recruit a whole heck of a lot

Diablo and Doc

6/11/21 11:45am

And this isn't happening as a member of the AAC or MWC.

SLIVER

6/11/21 11:54am

You're chances of getting into the playoffs as a member of the AAC increase significantly...

Coug

6/11/21 12:21pm

So your dream season for BYU is breezing through a G5 schedule and getting

SLIVER

6/11/21 12:30pm

And your dream season is to play games that virtually mean nothing... get left out and play in the Independence Bowl?

Coug

6/11/21 12:32pm

What's your realistic dream season for BYU football?

BYU Fan

6/11/21 12:34pm

BYU's recruiting tanked when they went Independent....

krindorr

6/11/21 12:39pm

No, it didn't, at all.

bluescholar

6/11/21 1:54pm

Yes, it did. Data included

krindorr

6/11/21 2:44pm

There is so much more to recruiting than looking at team rankings. If you don't

bluescholar

6/11/21 3:10pm

If you're using draft picks as evidence, BYU produced more in MWC days...

krindorr

6/11/21 3:29pm

14 of those 22 were recruited in the 90's, so unless you're ignoring that I said

bluescholar

6/11/21 4:01pm

I do agree Kalani is better than Bronco

krindorr

6/11/21 4:19pm

Yep, which is mostly Bronco having a hard time getting non-Crowton recruits

bluescholar

6/11/21 4:54pm

I don't know that we're in total disagreement

krindorr

6/11/21 5:06pm

I am not sure how I feel about all this.

runningryan

6/11/21 12:20pm

Thank-you read Quote by a very wise man.

Beetdiggercoug

6/11/21 1:37pm

CFP leads to better recruits

BingoNY

6/11/21 1:54pm

Nice try - a literal ton of talent in the trenches

fatcracker

6/11/21 2:31pm

Hey, we need depth!

SLIVER

6/11/21 3:18pm

Let’s get real. BYU is not winning a national championship. Getting the “6th”

GeorgeAlbertsgoatie

6/11/21 3:27pm

So nice that we can just join a P5 whenever we want!

rainorsnow

6/11/21 8:57pm

We want exposure and fan access; the expanded AAC gets us that...not the MWC

Doogal McCougar

6/12/21 3:43pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad