We’re discussing BYU having some supposed big jump in recruiting after the Big12

Nov 18, 2021
9:02:26am

Roghai Contributor

announcement and Utah’s supposed decline... you’re aware of this, right?

So yes, discussing kids who still would’ve gone to byu had they stayed independent is irreverent here

Report problem with this ad

Roghai

Bio page: Roghai
Joined: Apr 6, 2019
Last login: Jan 6, 2022
Total posts: 804 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

MrDaBaDe had lunch with a couple Yewt athletic department guys today. They spent quite a bit of time bemoaning the hit

ImBlueDaBaDe All-American

11/17/21 6:57pm

This is an under-appreciated point of Big 12 inclusion.

stenso

11/17/21 6:59pm

I don't underappreciate it. I don't think it's possible to over appreciate it

ratherberoping

11/17/21 8:35pm

RE: MrDaBaDe had lunch with a couple Yewt athletic department guys today. They spent quite a bit of time bemoaning the

2FarGone

11/17/21 7:02pm

Not saying it didn't happen — but people at Utah see the sky as the limit — not falling

TFL

11/17/21 7:04pm

Meh, low level guys angling for $, maybe just telling him what they thought he wanted to hear.

ImBlueDaBaDe

11/17/21 7:07pm

You seem to be forgetting that BYU is the PAC South Champion already.

m0resn0w

11/17/21 7:09pm

Yep, supremacy of the pac12 south this year has already been decided, and it ain’t Utah.

valcorger

11/17/21 10:34pm

RE: Not saying it didn't happen — but people at Utah see the sky as the

panacablue

11/17/21 7:12pm

Clean sweep of the south you say?

CBaass

11/17/21 7:18pm

Yep. UCLA, USC, CU, ASU, AZ. 14+ point average MOV.

TFL

11/17/21 8:02pm

You’re conveniently leaving off your lone south defeat

WP17

11/17/21 8:34pm

Maybe you are trolling about the BYU game, but their one PAC loss

Florwood

11/17/21 8:58pm

RE: Maybe you are trolling about the BYU game, but their one PAC loss

WP17

11/17/21 9:06pm

It's more about the trend. If Utah wins the South...again...and starts off as the favorite again

TFL

11/18/21 1:49pm

"Pac-12 supremacy" =

MantisTobaggan

11/17/21 7:45pm

Lol. Yeah. Oregon and Utah have been the top 2 programs the last several years. Oregon is #3

TFL

11/17/21 8:01pm

Just a joke just a joke.

MantisTobaggan

11/17/21 9:35pm

True big game and UU has turned it around, but UO is a strawman propped up by CF

RexburgCougar

11/19/21 9:19am

And yet, you're all fighting for 2nd place in the PAC10.2 South behind BYU...

TrueBlue67

11/17/21 7:56pm

Fair enough. BYU has been awesome this year. But it's like losing to Oregon State

TFL

11/17/21 8:03pm

That also isn’t a rivalry game . . . Or are they rivals like USC???

LakeshowCougs

11/17/21 10:16pm

Kinda like the good 'ol days in the WAC/MWC... everyone thought they were BYU's

TrueBlue67

11/18/21 5:07pm

BYU guys are kidding themselves if they don't think the

TFL

11/18/21 6:16pm

And he was fired

BYU Grounds

11/18/21 6:19pm

Yeah how many times has Utah been to the Rose bowl? Doesn’t any team that wants

LakeshowCougs

11/18/21 6:58pm

How many schools have won their conference in the last 5 years?

TFL

11/18/21 7:05pm

Speaking of “clean sweep of the south…”

Metallicat

11/17/21 8:32pm

Great win for BYU. But 1 loss out of 10 games isn't a sign of doom for the program. It's just

TFL

11/17/21 8:38pm

Nah, it's 2

cougforever

11/17/21 11:18pm

Lander Barton is a Ute through and through, there was never a doubt he was going

BYU Grounds

11/17/21 8:46pm

Now try to explain away our 4* QB from SO Cal and our soon to be 4* RB from FL

Roghai

11/18/21 5:20am

<< Deleted >>

CougarBored1001

11/18/21 11:16am

He's already a 4* on Rivals

DryFlyUte

11/18/21 1:07pm

<< Deleted >>

CougarBored1001

11/18/21 5:58pm

And yet the Rivals rating is used by 247

DryFlyUte

11/18/21 6:37pm

Yep, and 24/7 hasn’t updated Glover’s rating since his Junior season. They’ll

Roghai

11/19/21 6:50am

<< Deleted >>

CougarBored1001

11/19/21 9:32am

Umm. Utah isn't having a down year in recruiting

DryFlyUte

11/19/21 10:33am

Frosh?

Backcountry

11/17/21 9:13pm

serious question: why do you think landing Barton was a huge feat? isn't he

yahtzee

11/17/21 10:10pm

Because he is a fantastic player. Joining a terrific class

TFL

11/17/21 10:15pm

I get that he's a fantastic player, but is it a 'huge feat' if he's yours to

yahtzee

11/17/21 10:27pm

Well, think about the reverse situation. What if they didn’t? The reason he committed

TFL

11/17/21 10:40pm

maybe i'm not following you. are you suggesting it wouldn't be a big loss if

yahtzee

11/17/21 11:03pm

What you’re missing is the response to OPs typical CB sky is falling at Utah

TFL

11/17/21 11:15pm

I already stated I wasn't disputing utah is recruiting well.

yahtzee

11/17/21 11:28pm

I hear what you are saying, but do you have a Ryan Smith?

Loafer

11/18/21 12:09am

<< Deleted >>

CougarBored1001

11/18/21 1:09am

Okay. Well, from what you can gather in Utah recruiting. What makes you think the program is headed to decline?

TFL

11/18/21 1:50pm

I think most here saw the bad start and say the whole program is in decline.

SoBlueitHurts

11/19/21 7:22am

That's an authentic take

TFL

11/19/21 3:58pm

Honest question here. Do you see Whittingham retiring in the next 5 years and..

BYU Grounds

11/19/21 4:16pm

It depends

TFL

11/19/21 6:01pm

How is Run26 doing these days?

BIG XII Coug

11/17/21 7:05pm

RE: How is Run26 doing these days?

John Doe

11/17/21 8:13pm

We need to focus on beating our conference rivals in recruiting not some school

Blueto

11/17/21 7:07pm

The sudden uptick in BYU recruiting has been a bit surprising to me. I certainly

Soy Celeste

11/17/21 7:12pm

Show that things being mostly equal, BYU is more desirable

boogers

11/17/21 7:16pm

The gap in recruiting hasn’t changed one bit comparing last year to this year..

Roghai

11/18/21 5:25am

Makes BYU beating Utah squarely even more embarrassing, doesn’t it?

Soupie

11/18/21 6:49am

Not at all. Even with a talent advantage, only losing one in the last ten games

Roghai

11/18/21 8:33am

Soupie

BYU Grounds

11/18/21 5:00pm

Wait and see.

boogers

11/18/21 8:49am

I don’t think it’s just a b12 thing. We also have a coach players want

Don Carlton

11/17/21 9:14pm

BYU average recruit rating for 2022: 83.20 2021: 83.86. For reference, Utah’s

Roghai

11/18/21 5:24am

Both teams are on the rise. Don’t know why people think Ut fans are feeling down

idkwhatiexpected

11/17/21 8:04pm

Lol Utah’s average recruit rating so far: 87.15. Last year: 87.27

Roghai

11/18/21 5:19am

Uh oh! Ute-fan-on-CB convention going on here

ACrop

11/18/21 6:39am

did you know that 84% of Rogaine's stats are made up on the spot?

yahtzee

11/18/21 8:29am

Here you go.

Roghai

11/18/21 8:39am

I was joking. but thanks. BTW, I didn't know Utes were 10th in the Pac12

yahtzee

11/18/21 8:55am

Only because Utah always fills out their class later than everyone else. Happens

Roghai

11/18/21 8:57am

hmmm. they ended up 5th last year. Middle of the pac of the 5th best fb conf

yahtzee

11/18/21 9:01am

Where would BYU have landed?

Roghai

11/18/21 9:03am

if we were in the Pac12? no way to know. we got into a better conference.

yahtzee

11/18/21 9:04am

Byu only finished ahead of one PAC 12 team in recruiting last year: Arizona

Roghai

11/18/21 9:08am

I know it's easy to get confused b/c BYU may win the Pac12 title

yahtzee

11/18/21 9:09am

How in the world did we beat all those Pac 12 teams? Like you said yourself

RenoCoug

11/18/21 11:15am

You’re better coached than all the PAC 12 teams you play this season besides

Roghai

11/19/21 6:52am

We were better coached early in the season

SoBlueitHurts

11/19/21 7:12am

We're not talking about history we live in there and now 26-17, its been 800 day

BYU Grounds

11/19/21 3:50pm

So that average number is subject to drop (or maybe rise) once the class is

SoBlueitHurts

11/18/21 10:05am

Yep, but the sample is large enough that we know Utah isn’t having this big made

Roghai

11/18/21 10:12am

My source: 24/7 sports’s composite rating which averages the ratings of all the

Roghai

11/18/21 8:35am

WOW man, your comments are mistimed at best.

Zoobieman

11/18/21 9:48am

This sounds very much like the things MrDaBaDe heard at lunch.

ImBlueDaBaDe

11/18/21 9:59am

No, it sounds like what you’re saying is made up. BYU hasn’t been beating Utah

Roghai

11/18/21 10:10am

Hahahahaha you’re clueless. Do you really want me to come back to this when Utah

Roghai

11/18/21 10:00am

Come back to this thread? No. But discuss Utah's success when it happens

Zoobieman

11/18/21 11:10am

Doesn’t account for 1/2 the team entering the transfer portal.

Romex

11/18/21 6:50am

What are you even talking about? I’m clearly talking football

Roghai

11/18/21 8:37am

Take it either way, Football or Basketball. Or are you referring to players just

Romex

11/18/21 8:57am

That’s not happening in football more than normal

Roghai

11/18/21 9:04am

RE: That’s not happening in football more than normal

Romex

11/18/21 5:09pm

Okay. Whatever you say, #2.

Megamind

11/18/21 8:39am

You aren't taking into account people that have committed to BYU since the BIG12

YaHerdWithPerd

11/18/21 8:46am

Lol how much do you want to bet? I follow recruiting pretty closely and am

Roghai

11/18/21 8:55am

Who’s that? They honestly don’t have much room to recruit with all the frosh

idkwhatiexpected

11/18/21 2:04pm

BYU will hopefully get a boost from big 12 affiliation, I don’t see how U has

idkwhatiexpected

11/18/21 2:03pm

Our only 2 commits since the announcement average .895. Not to mention a .97

YaHerdWithPerd

11/18/21 8:50am

Lol those guys were going to byu either way

Roghai

11/18/21 8:56am

ah, so we just discount the guys like Barton who were "going to utah either way"

yahtzee

11/18/21 8:58am

We’re discussing BYU having some supposed big jump in recruiting after the Big12

Roghai

11/18/21 9:02am

I don't think it's irreverent at all. It's just sports, not religion dude.

yahtzee

11/18/21 9:05am

Moa was literally committed to Utah. What about Collin Chandler who was a lock

YaHerdWithPerd

11/18/21 11:07am

Moa decommited from Utah because of a disagreement on position he would play

DryFlyUte

11/18/21 4:44pm

Lol don’t bring up a guy like Moa when you clearly don’t know the backstory

Roghai

11/19/21 6:56am

You can't stop there. Tell us all what the backstory is please.

Wingnut

11/19/21 6:57am

ESPN 700 talked about Moa's decommitment from Utah

DryFlyUte

11/19/21 9:18am

Good for them.

Thrill

11/18/21 9:11am

Utah's class is ranked in the 80s nationally. . .BYU in the 70s. . .

MyTwoCents

11/18/21 9:14am

That’s because it weighs the total number of commits. BYU has filled out their

Roghai

11/18/21 9:22am

Again, 90% of our class was signed before we got into the BIG 12. we don't know

YaHerdWithPerd

11/18/21 11:11am

Do they weigh the Ute commits before or after they visit the west concourse?

yahtzee

11/18/21 2:39pm

-DELETED-

Zoobieman

11/18/21 9:27am

it'll take time before changes are seen in these metrics

Hill4Heisman

11/18/21 12:07pm

BYU having success and rising, sure. Doesn't mean Utah is 'declining'.

seacougar

11/18/21 12:38pm

Wait, we got Rising?

ImBlueDaBaDe

11/18/21 12:42pm

He was a non committable offer. The Utes have even better QB for next year 4.3

Posting on CougarBoard