This guy perfectly lays out what it takes to get into the CFP. P5 vs G5

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 7, 2021
6:28:32pm

Schultz is back All-American

This guy perfectly lays out what it takes to get into the CFP. P5 vs G5

Here's the conspiracy, Kirk: it takes one good season for a P5 to get in, but takes at least two in a row for a G5 to get in with the first solely to be ranked high enough in the preseason the next year. I made a list of criteria to show the inequality of the committee's views. pic.twitter.com/2tq5fQ2AEH
— David Brice (@davidclaybrice) December 7, 2021

https://twitter.com/davidclaybrice/status/1468349764068646923

Report problem with this ad

Schultz is back

Bio page: Schultz is back
Joined: Jan 14, 2013
Last login: May 1, 2024
Total posts: 9,024 (824 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Is Herbstreit all right??? Glad he was able to get that off his chest… I’m sure

TempeCoug

12/7/21 6:11pm

Twitter reveals so much stupidity that I wish I wasn't aware of.

SingleStrapBackpack

12/7/21 6:12pm

He should come check out CB, and he'll hear plenty . . .

Shinshin

12/7/21 6:13pm

Well, when your employer owns all broadcasting rights, you’ve got to squash

1984coug

12/7/21 6:13pm

All the while, an independent BYU is kept out of the NY6 in favor of...

Little Mac

12/7/21 6:15pm

An independent BYU was not qualified for NY6.

coldcoug

12/7/21 6:47pm

Ummm. That's my point. ND got one. BYU was more qualified than some...and at

Little Mac

12/7/21 6:56pm

They didn’t need to elevate them Utah/Pitt at 14/15 still would have gotten in

PHXSUNS31

12/7/21 6:59pm

Yes. Exactly. You're highlighting my point. Under the current system...

Little Mac

12/7/21 7:14pm

Fair, just didn’t know if your issue was with the committee or the whole system

PHXSUNS31

12/7/21 7:17pm

Noytre Dame had a better record (11-1). Pitt and Utah were conference champs.

coldcoug

12/7/21 7:22pm

Not just realizing it. It's just being highlighted this year more starkly.

Little Mac

12/7/21 7:30pm

Such a loser.

byubyu

12/7/21 6:15pm

Tim Brando's reply:

Manti

12/7/21 6:16pm

I can only think of 2 teams G5 that had strong arguments to be in the CFP

NYC and Japan

12/7/21 9:25pm

I would think he is including the BCS years. Before the playoffs small schools

12/8/21 9:31am

BCS era there were only 2 teams selected, not 4. G5 teams rarely approach top 2

NYC and Japan

12/8/21 3:41pm

And all it took was two perfect seasons!

durandal

12/7/21 6:16pm

And luckily they had a good ND on the schedule this year.

swingcat

12/7/21 6:36pm

Just my take, but ND is not good or proven

LateToTheGame

12/7/21 7:02pm

UCF right now:

OPINIONS

12/7/21 6:16pm

Seriously though. 2 years undefeated.

letthewookieewin

12/7/21 6:17pm

Did someone remind him of the red-headed stepchild that is BYU?

idacoug

12/7/21 6:16pm

That seem uncharacteristic of the guy. Random meltdown.

Backcountry

12/7/21 6:17pm

Yeah, this feels really weird.

Music

12/7/21 6:22pm

Sheesh that was salty. Uncharacteristic of him. Chill Herbstreit. It’s a cartel.

BlooCoog

12/7/21 6:18pm

I'm not sure why all the g5s don't do it.

SCcoug

12/7/21 6:21pm

You have cracked the nut. Now we have the formula. 😉

12/7/21 8:00pm

This guy perfectly lays out what it takes to get into the CFP. P5 vs G5

Schultz is back

12/7/21 6:28pm

It is rigged. That’s how it’s built. Even after BYU gets in the B12 it will still be rigged.

12/7/21 6:29pm

Have they accepted a 12 game playoff

germ1

12/7/21 6:48pm

Yes but still debating over how to determine the auto bids.

12/7/21 6:52pm

I thought after the last meeting someone said an 8 team playoff was still in

Schultz is back

12/7/21 7:15pm

OK State would have jumped Cincinnati if they had won

12/7/21 6:33pm

100%

VACOUGFAN

12/7/21 8:34pm

Well, he’s right that the people who said it would never happen were wrong.

DieHarder

12/7/21 6:37pm

"Conspiracy" implies that things are being done in secret. All of the P5 CFP bias has been plainly in the open the

SingleStrapBackpack

12/7/21 6:50pm

It's out in the open and everyone knows it, but the CFP still pays lips service

Schultz is back

12/7/21 7:23pm

Right. I'm just commenting on the fact that it's ridiculous for Herbie to be calling people conspiracy theorists for

SingleStrapBackpack

12/7/21 7:25pm

LOL. Michigan started the season unranked and lost a game and still finished…

ChadFromCougarTown

12/7/21 6:44pm

Michigan played and beat good teams. Truth is, most G5 teams play 2-3

PHXSUNS31

12/7/21 7:05pm

Isn’t that kind of the point?

ChadFromCougarTown

12/7/21 7:07pm

I’m not exactly sure what you mean here

PHXSUNS31

12/7/21 7:18pm

Right but it’s the team not the schedule. UCF got jobbed. Cinci didn’t luckily. Emphasis on luckily.

12/7/21 7:09pm

I don’t remember the details around UCF, did they beat anyone good those years?

PHXSUNS31

12/7/21 7:16pm

The problem is that perfection doesn't guarantee jack squat. Cincinnati had to go undefeated for 2 years straight, get

SingleStrapBackpack

12/7/21 7:32pm

I don’t disagree with anything you say, just gotta hope for an expanded playoff

PHXSUNS31

12/8/21 5:27am

*perfect twice

DiamondMo

12/7/21 8:02pm

This chick nails it with her response

12/7/21 7:11pm

I like Kirk but he goes down a lot of notches for me if this is how he feels

12/7/21 7:13pm

So he is basically saying that 90% of the time the system sucks and gets it

boctabulous

12/7/21 7:15pm

How many losses does the 1st place seed have again? Sit down Herb.

AltTabbins

12/7/21 7:21pm

What a joke Herbie has become. I used to really like him

gurt

12/7/21 10:19pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad