Counterfactual to #1:

Dec 8, 2021
8:39:45am

joelvandyne Truly Addicted User

This is piped in over the PA system. You can see the band in frame and they're not playing, ergo they're not necessary for this experience.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETDyuhug5ws

Report problem with this ad

joelvandyne

Bio page: joelvandyne
Joined: Jun 16, 2015
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 24,238 (10,109 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A Neuroscientific response to TADOW's "unpopular opinion" on the Marching Band

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 6:52am

You lost me when you mentioned your kid knows utah's fight song. How could you?

PrimeQuantumDeek

12/8/21 7:09am

His mom played lacrosse for the U

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 7:13am

Again… how could you?

BW84

12/8/21 7:18am

Found some pics

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 8:02am

Btw…that 2004 helmet is Quinn Gooch’s helmet lol

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 8:04am

I'm sure the young man also watched the Mickey Mouse show, so it's only a baby

StarMan

12/8/21 9:23am

My son’s experience after his mission.

Brigham

12/8/21 7:12am

My first game was BYU vs TCU 2005

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 8:28am

Dang man this is awesome. Could be a revisionist history episode.

freekarl

12/8/21 7:29am

Yeah I’m toying around with a ton of ideas right now…

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 8:33am

People like the "pep band" aspect. People don't really care about the "marching band" part.

No touching

12/8/21 7:42am

This is true.

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 7:45am

I agree with this. I loved PP’s analysis/info here. I’ve been really burned out/

Forest Green

12/8/21 10:19am

Yes, I think we are close to reaching a consensus here on the marching band

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 11:09am

The place where I've seen the crowd really care about the marching band was tOSU

HiLife

12/8/21 11:19am

this is true.

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 11:43am

For the record, I don’t hate the band

TADOW

12/8/21 8:07am

I’m actually with you in a lot of ways on this…what do you think about this?

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 8:13am

That’s great

TADOW

12/8/21 8:36am

Counterfactual to #1:

joelvandyne

12/8/21 8:39am

I think one of the developing points being made here is first and foremost

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 8:57am

5. Eliminate most/all of the marching band aspect of band performance.

Forest Green

12/8/21 10:24am

Until BYU stops playing the fight song 50 clicks under tempo, I will be upset

andrewg3

12/8/21 9:48am

Any thoughts on this post on a new mid game song?

ThomasQKelly

12/8/21 10:34am

Alright that is actually a FANTASTIC IDEA - MAKE A 1984 PLAYLIST

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 11:40am

Can't seem to find one of them

ThomasQKelly

12/15/21 2:44pm

There is a difference between what people

deljdc

12/8/21 10:45am

Is this CB’s most scholarly post ever?

NorthwestCoug

12/8/21 11:15am

Wow. Just... wow.

Ham

12/8/21 11:33am

The pep aspect of the band is great

StickyBumps

12/8/21 11:34am

If we are going to be Big 12 our band has to level up.

ditch

12/8/21 12:02pm

If we are going to go that route, I want us to go all out but be completely

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 1:40pm

This video here shows in 3+ minutes all of those emotions you mention as

Thrill

12/8/21 3:13pm

I think this is almost the exact same video I listed in item #8 on the OP

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 3:32pm

Oh wow....I didn't click on the link in your OP, but it was the first video I

Thrill

12/8/21 3:47pm

Oh absolutely dude…this video blew my mind.

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 4:46pm

Yes, I saw the video with your son. Cool moment to have saved.

Thrill

12/8/21 6:30pm

No game in the WORLD is close to the true weirdness of college football.

TheDash

12/8/21 5:26pm

More than just bands: the flag girls, cheerleaders, live eagle, jet flyover, etc

Thrill

12/8/21 6:32pm

yeah I was about to say the same thing

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 6:34pm

I just....love college football

Punk Philosopher

12/8/21 6:34pm

College football is rooted in tradition. It has tribalism, nostalgia, and pride

seacougar

12/9/21 11:27am

Can you do one of these for the flag girls?

HenderCoug

12/9/21 3:40am

Marching bands are like bagpipes. You wouldn't blast that music in your car, but

seacougar

12/9/21 11:30am

...I actually have blasted marching band in my car...

Punk Philosopher

12/9/21 11:44am

I have been known blast bagpipes on occasion, too. Started with a family reunion

seacougar

12/9/21 11:52am

I didn't see anything remotely scientific in this post, neuro or otherwise

Digital Gangsta

12/9/21 12:28pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad