There is a decent amount of 4 star lds qbs and TE. Those positions need to be

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

May 11, 2024
1:52:12pm

johnnybyu All-American

There is a decent amount of 4 star lds qbs and TE. Those positions need to be

a strength for byu.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on May 11, 2024 at 1:52:12pm

Message modified by johnnybyu on May 11, 2024 at 1:53:04pm

Report problem with this ad

johnnybyu

Bio page: johnnybyu
Joined: Jun 6, 2002
Last login: May 24, 2024
Total posts: 14,896 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A break down of what a roll of the dice it is with high school qb recruits

May 11, 1:38pm

There is a decent amount of 4 star lds qbs and TE. Those positions need to be

johnnybyu

May 11, 1:52pm

But expecting a 4 star QB to sign with BYU every year is unrealistic

Belboz

May 11, 1:56pm

Exactly. When 4-star QBs are scarce - let's be honest - they're more likely to choose a big time program.

KingDave

May 11, 2:00pm

Every year sure but we should get more than 3 in 24 years

johnnybyu

May 11, 2:03pm

Now that we’re a power school maybe. But not in the MWC or Indy

puntersarepeople

May 11, 2:10pm

No one expects to land one every year.

CaliforniaCougar22

May 11, 3:42pm

One 4 star every three years? Utah doesn't produce them at that rate, nor LDS talented QBs at that rate.

May 11, 4:56pm

There’s about 25 4/5 every year. The blue bloods will take 1 or 2

molodyets

May 11, 5:22pm

Utah is not a blue blood and they run circles around us in recruiting QBs

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 2:09am

And how many of them have turned out? The knock on Utah is they are always a decently average QB away from being a

May 12, 8:38am

Cam Rising is better than any of our QBs

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 12:18pm

And before Cam, we had two 3 star qbs get drafted while their 4 star guys

May 12, 12:38pm

Yea but our QB recruiting was decent back then and now it’s atrocious.

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 12:50pm

That's not true at all. Jaren Hall had 2 offers- from Utah and BYU.

May 12, 1:42pm

That’s only because of rating inflation

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 2:00pm

There were 3 high rated LDS or Utah QBs in the 2024 class alone

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 1:57am

Technically only 2 according to 247, which is the preferred site (Hammond & Wilson).

May 12, 8:46am

Unfortunately we did ourselves no favors in Hammond’s recruitment

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 12:24pm

I'll again say that talking about 3 stars is meaningless

krindorr

May 12, 12:35pm

Yes, that is a big distinction to make and a very fair point in 247s ranting scheme

May 12, 2:24pm

RE: Technically only 2 according to 247, which is the preferred site (Hammond

TexDaddy

May 13, 4:14pm

It is easy to point fingers, the truth of it is I have no idea what is going on behind the scenes nor the limitations

May 13, 6:40pm

Football has shown they are serious. They just paid Jay Hill a boat load of

May 13, 7:17pm

Nobody got on a plane to go develop the Hammond relationship in Texas.

TexDaddy

May 13, 4:16pm

Losing Dart sucks. We wanted him bad and he was a Utah QB. TE we’ve been doing great the last three classes if we hold

puntersarepeople

May 11, 2:09pm

Gotta throw to them more.

DiamondDog

May 11, 2:23pm

I’d like that too but the big recruits haven’t come in and developed yet

puntersarepeople

May 11, 2:45pm

Dart, Hammond, and McKee seemed like reasonable gets at one point. Fortunately

johnnybyu

May 11, 3:01pm

We were on Dart when he was a nobody and barely a 3*. The televised ESPN game

molodyets

May 11, 6:13pm

Just being LDS no longer means automatic BYU fan. Just because a family member

kaladin58

May 11, 6:59pm

Haven’t seen the 2024 numbers yet - but last year half of draft picks

molodyets

May 11, 2:00pm

Like the NFL high rating quarterbacks in college get more invested in them to

chismoso

May 11, 2:11pm

Such a great post. I wish I wasn’t already firm on my POTD or this would get it. Thanks Rise Against!!!!

May 11, 4:57pm

RE: A break down of what a roll of the dice it is with high school qb recruits

TexDaddy

May 11, 10:18pm

Do you think our staff doesn’t fly or stay in hotels to recruit?

molodyets

May 11, 10:35pm

Not for 4 star QBs. Maybe for other positions. Maybe the Defense has budget.

TexDaddy

May 13, 4:17pm

"3 star recruit" has become a meaningless designator

krindorr

May 12, 6:16am

It's too bad they stopped using 2*.

May 13, 10:16am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad