I'll again say that talking about 3 stars is meaningless

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

May 12, 2024
12:35:11pm

krindorr Playmaker

I'll again say that talking about 3 stars is meaningless

A high 3 star has a lot more in common with a low 4 star than with a low 3 star. Pretty much every recruit gets 3 stars these days. But recruiting in the 84-85 range is a world of difference from recruiting in the 88-90 range....even though they're all 3 stars

Report problem with this ad

krindorr

Bio page: krindorr
Joined: Oct 5, 2020
Last login: Jun 15, 2024
Total posts: 18,214 (112 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A break down of what a roll of the dice it is with high school qb recruits

May 11, 1:38pm

There is a decent amount of 4 star lds qbs and TE. Those positions need to be

johnnybyu

May 11, 1:52pm

But expecting a 4 star QB to sign with BYU every year is unrealistic

Belboz

May 11, 1:56pm

Exactly. When 4-star QBs are scarce - let's be honest - they're more likely to choose a big time program.

KingDave

May 11, 2:00pm

Every year sure but we should get more than 3 in 24 years

johnnybyu

May 11, 2:03pm

Now that we’re a power school maybe. But not in the MWC or Indy

puntersarepeople

May 11, 2:10pm

No one expects to land one every year.

CaliforniaCougar22

May 11, 3:42pm

One 4 star every three years? Utah doesn't produce them at that rate, nor LDS talented QBs at that rate.

May 11, 4:56pm

There’s about 25 4/5 every year. The blue bloods will take 1 or 2

molodyets

May 11, 5:22pm

Utah is not a blue blood and they run circles around us in recruiting QBs

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 2:09am

And how many of them have turned out? The knock on Utah is they are always a decently average QB away from being a

May 12, 8:38am

Cam Rising is better than any of our QBs

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 12:18pm

And before Cam, we had two 3 star qbs get drafted while their 4 star guys

May 12, 12:38pm

Yea but our QB recruiting was decent back then and now it’s atrocious.

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 12:50pm

That's not true at all. Jaren Hall had 2 offers- from Utah and BYU.

May 12, 1:42pm

That’s only because of rating inflation

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 2:00pm

There were 3 high rated LDS or Utah QBs in the 2024 class alone

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 1:57am

Technically only 2 according to 247, which is the preferred site (Hammond & Wilson).

May 12, 8:46am

Unfortunately we did ourselves no favors in Hammond’s recruitment

CaliforniaCougar22

May 12, 12:24pm

I'll again say that talking about 3 stars is meaningless

krindorr

May 12, 12:35pm

Yes, that is a big distinction to make and a very fair point in 247s ranting scheme

May 12, 2:24pm

RE: Technically only 2 according to 247, which is the preferred site (Hammond

TexDaddy

May 13, 4:14pm

It is easy to point fingers, the truth of it is I have no idea what is going on behind the scenes nor the limitations

May 13, 6:40pm

Football has shown they are serious. They just paid Jay Hill a boat load of

May 13, 7:17pm

Nobody got on a plane to go develop the Hammond relationship in Texas.

TexDaddy

May 13, 4:16pm

Losing Dart sucks. We wanted him bad and he was a Utah QB. TE we’ve been doing great the last three classes if we hold

puntersarepeople

May 11, 2:09pm

Gotta throw to them more.

DiamondDog

May 11, 2:23pm

I’d like that too but the big recruits haven’t come in and developed yet

puntersarepeople

May 11, 2:45pm

Dart, Hammond, and McKee seemed like reasonable gets at one point. Fortunately

johnnybyu

May 11, 3:01pm

We were on Dart when he was a nobody and barely a 3*. The televised ESPN game

molodyets

May 11, 6:13pm

Just being LDS no longer means automatic BYU fan. Just because a family member

kaladin58

May 11, 6:59pm

Haven’t seen the 2024 numbers yet - but last year half of draft picks

molodyets

May 11, 2:00pm

Like the NFL high rating quarterbacks in college get more invested in them to

chismoso

May 11, 2:11pm

Such a great post. I wish I wasn’t already firm on my POTD or this would get it. Thanks Rise Against!!!!

May 11, 4:57pm

RE: A break down of what a roll of the dice it is with high school qb recruits

TexDaddy

May 11, 10:18pm

Do you think our staff doesn’t fly or stay in hotels to recruit?

molodyets

May 11, 10:35pm

Not for 4 star QBs. Maybe for other positions. Maybe the Defense has budget.

TexDaddy

May 13, 4:17pm

"3 star recruit" has become a meaningless designator

krindorr

May 12, 6:16am

It's too bad they stopped using 2*.

May 13, 10:16am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad