Robbie was legit, Randy was a different story. Reid passed on a lot of talent

Report problem with this ad

Nov 25, 2014
7:16:23pm

Accipiter

that was superior as a result. Talent that went a lot farther.

Report problem with this ad

Accipiter

Bio page: Accipiter
Joined: Jun 30, 2010
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 10,076 (1,089 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

ROGER REID 3.0!

capo

11/25/14 9:15am

Nepotism.

BYUtka

11/25/14 9:17am

The Nepotism comment is just wrong. If you didn't like him as a coach fine but

Cougarlehi

11/25/14 9:52am

It's not that his boys weren't good enough...

mcnasty

11/25/14 10:44am

So this about him not giving an offer to Brian Santiago? That was the downfall

Cougarlehi

11/25/14 11:13am

Did I say just Santiago? He literally recruited zero point guards for several

mcnasty

11/25/14 11:38am

True. D-1 players, but having both helped kill program

cajuncoug

11/25/14 1:18pm

I have a cousin who set records at CSU playing for Stew Morrill, a Utah kid

Accipiter

11/25/14 8:32pm

His boys were great players.. seriously whats wrong with some of you?

byukarl

11/25/14 11:42am

Agree 100%

Cougarlehi

11/25/14 12:01pm

I know a couple of guys who were there at the time... drove team crazy that

relic

11/25/14 12:14pm

Yah. Its a good thing that center he recruited (Kirt Christensen)

PolarisPrime

11/25/14 6:11pm

this is correct. i know someone who played at a rival WAC school during the Reid

boss

11/25/14 6:04pm

Robbie was legit, Randy was a different story. Reid passed on a lot of talent

Accipiter

11/25/14 7:16pm

Good coach but horrible at PR. The team was tanking when they got rid of him.

93 cougar

11/25/14 9:18am

He was a pretty good coach, but . . .

BlueBuffoon

11/25/14 9:21am

Hmmm... A semi-successful BYU coach can be fired for being bad with the media,

foofcoug

11/25/14 9:26am

Here is what I don't get. Was he Semi Successful? or Successful?

capo

11/25/14 9:33am

I think he was successful, but his style of play emptied the stadium faster than

Hank Rearden

11/25/14 9:36am

Hence the comparason to Bronco. Bronco also wins, but

capo

11/25/14 9:43am

Bronco has a lower winning % than Edwards

concolor couguar

11/25/14 9:44am

RE: The nepotism thing.....

BoiseBlue

11/25/14 9:29am

Had a winning record vs Majerus

STLcoug

11/25/14 9:28am

Reid was 8-7 versus the Fat Man. 9-9 if you count '89-'90. Here is the Head to

TolerancePlease

11/25/14 11:22am

He was also 3-0 vs Majerus in the WAC tourney...

icecougar

11/25/14 7:28pm

Very good X's and O's coach. Horrible with the media. Too emotional

fulano

11/25/14 9:30am

Too emotional & not media friendly - but people also forget that there was a lot

BigD Coug

11/25/14 9:45am

completely agree

Bluforever

11/25/14 10:41am

Thanks Ryan.

PolarisPrime

11/25/14 6:14pm

He was okay and then he had a team with no talent and lost his job.

Born2Fish

11/25/14 9:54am

Poor PR, very boring style of play, was trending south fast on W/L

Bluforever

11/25/14 10:40am

Here are some contemporary reports

dratax

11/25/14 11:02am

There are obviously a lot of things that went in to it

Bill

11/25/14 11:20am

He would have been a better coach if Shawn Bradley

PacificNW

11/25/14 11:27am

Or maybe

dratax

11/25/14 11:32am

no...he left because it was the last year that rookies

PacificNW

11/25/14 11:46am

That is what I thought as well, but not everyone thought so.

dratax

11/25/14 1:34pm

Yes but....."most people,.... closely agree"

PacificNW

11/25/14 1:47pm

I oft wonder what would have happened if Carl Ingersoll were hired instead

Yakov

11/25/14 11:47am

<< Deleted >>

Harrison0Yfan

11/25/14 12:06pm

Good coach with terrible PR skills

bluegato

11/25/14 12:19pm

Roger Reid was a great X and O coach. If Reid's team was in a close game

Cougarpride

11/25/14 12:47pm

Roger Reid could have held Jimmer to a 15 pt avg.

Brigham

11/25/14 1:18pm

I don't blame him for going pro but it didn't help that Shawn Bradley left early

BYUBandfan

11/25/14 1:19pm

Coach up mediocre players...coaches down potential star players

MoveTheChains

11/25/14 2:27pm

I did my undergrad while Reid was a coach and roomed with several players

byu bcs buster

11/25/14 2:31pm

This is the correct answer

Joel Tilton

11/25/14 6:02pm

He was an excellent coach.

Mark

11/25/14 2:31pm

RE: ROGER REID was horrible for the Bball program.

Coogar2

11/25/14 3:49pm

Randy showed up at my apartment with two linemen wanting to fight me...

jakespoon

11/25/14 6:04pm

Lol. So he beat your team in the state tournament

PolarisPrime

11/25/14 6:27pm

State tournament? smoking a little too much tonight?

jakespoon

11/25/14 7:41pm

I see you just joined last year. Fyi, only the kids in the board still use the..

jakespoon

11/25/14 7:46pm

two types of people "brag" like you did in your post

PolarisPrime

11/25/14 9:10pm

Don't forget your miralax. Son. You are hilarious when high.

jakespoon

11/25/14 9:24pm

Got it. Love the "experienced" posters who dont actually....

PolarisPrime

11/25/14 10:05pm

You bet. That was fun! I can tell you more stories...

jakespoon

11/27/14 12:04pm

No one is pre-judging you

PolarisPrime

11/27/14 6:48pm

So that's your deal. Your determination to continue

jakespoon

11/27/14 7:07pm

LOL. Im sure you do.

PolarisPrime

11/27/14 7:14pm

Unlike Bronco, he prepared his teams well for beating Utah

icecougar

11/25/14 7:14pm

Reid was really good at coaching the post game

jre85

11/25/14 7:19pm

He started out wonderful-Energetic, grit, you exciting basketball

pappabear246

11/25/14 8:38pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad