RE: 2008 Fan says please please let us in the big league. 2016 Fan says it is

May 25, 2016
12:17:03pm

Thunderdome Walk-on

2008 fans and MWC fans felt MWC football should be in the club, Utes fans saying how overrated SEC is...lets keep it real, and Utah fans have turned into what they hated and deposed, welcome to the Vegas bowl

Report problem with this ad

Thunderdome

Previous username: Cougindy
Bio page: Thunderdome
Joined: Aug 13, 2013
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 595 (9 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Will Big12 expansion affect Utah

SnickSnack

5/25/16 10:03am

I don't care how it impacts Utah. I care how it impacts BYU

concolor couguar

5/25/16 10:05am

Duhh...read the article.

SnickSnack

5/25/16 10:06am

Why? The very premise has no interest to me

concolor couguar

5/25/16 10:07am

Then why are you commenting on the post? If you have no interest

erodcoug

5/25/16 10:11am

I did have a comment for the post though

concolor couguar

5/25/16 10:13am

Ok than just make real quick comments on the premise of everything you read.

SnickSnack

5/25/16 10:13am

Yep. If BYU gets in yewts lose the P5 superiority argument.

Harrison0Yfan

5/25/16 10:06am

"BYU is not a P5 opponent in any respect including the logo on the jersey"

Tokolosh

5/25/16 10:13am

Why does this sound like a Jackie Robinson argument?

SnickSnack

5/25/16 10:15am

Are you comparing us to the first black man to be allowed in MLB?

SpecialT

5/25/16 4:55pm

Except in scheduling for P5 teams.

Squeegee

5/25/16 10:18am

BYU is considered "P5" by just about everybody now...except Utah fans.

ol' Blue Eyes

5/25/16 10:18am

Playoff committee included?

Tokolosh

5/25/16 10:19am

RE: Playoff committee included?

Huge Manatee

5/25/16 10:26am

Yes.

Lance71

5/25/16 10:27am

Sure. They go undefeated, they're in; same as virtually everyone else who is P5

Twin Roots

5/25/16 10:27am

They just have to be ranked in the top 4...just like the P5 teams. Doesn't have

ol' Blue Eyes

5/25/16 10:33am

Technically sure, but realistically

Twin Roots

5/25/16 11:17am

conference affiliation is 100% irrelevant.

Dissenter

5/25/16 11:23am

Yes, a top 4 determined by the committee which was setup by the P5.

Tokolosh

5/25/16 12:07pm

In 2015, a BYU team at 12-0 would be CFP top 6 easy. Above PAC-12 champ.

StalwartBraveTrue

5/25/16 1:04pm

Top 6 is still not playoffs. Top 4 or bust, not sur BYU gets that respect.

Tokolosh

5/25/16 1:32pm

A 12-0 BYU gets into the playoff. Don't even kid

Dissenter

5/25/16 2:08pm

After all the press we've gotten about our hard schedule, we get in at 12-0.

Harrison0Yfan

5/25/16 2:12pm

Heck a 12-0 Houston would probably get in this year

Dissenter

5/25/16 2:13pm

I don't expect you to be "sur". That isn't the point.

StalwartBraveTrue

5/25/16 10:18pm

Generally speaking, when people communicate something, there is a point.

Gentleman Stan

5/25/16 2:16pm

Strange yet simple logic.

byujdmba

5/25/16 10:45am

Does it depend on your definition of "is" ?

Bgash

5/25/16 1:02pm

I've always wanted to see a 2008 Utah fan debate a 2016 Utah fan about status.

Art Director

5/25/16 10:14am

2008 Fan says please please let us in the big league. 2016 Fan says it is PACMAS

ALUF 1990

5/25/16 11:04am

2008 fan also said the system was unfair. 2016 fan has embraced the system like

Carnac el Magnifico

5/25/16 11:16am

The fans I knew in 2008 were tired of playing CSU & New Mexico and wanted to

ALUF 1990

5/25/16 11:59am

The issue to me is that

CMuehle

5/25/16 12:08pm

Yep. This exactly.

LifeLongLakerFan

5/25/16 1:23pm

This pretty much sums up Utah fan hypocrisy over the last 6 years.

StalwartBraveTrue

5/25/16 10:20pm

In some ways, it's unfortunate that Utah stuggled when they joined the P12....

SnickSnack

5/25/16 11:26am

My guess: 2004 team would have finished 2nd to USC. 2009 would have been

ALUF 1990

5/25/16 12:07pm

Cal in 04

SconnieCoug

5/25/16 2:06pm

RE: 2008 Fan says please please let us in the big league. 2016 Fan says it is

Thunderdome

5/25/16 12:17pm

The issue has less to do about Utah's P5 status and more to do with

TFL

5/25/16 2:58pm

Go look at past polls. Utah is an important game this year. Nothing more.

Lance71

5/25/16 3:38pm

this is so false

Dissenter

5/25/16 3:44pm

I know there are some that have your opinion, but you are a minority

Lance71

5/25/16 4:09pm

No, I'm not. Utah is our biggest game, bar none

Dissenter

5/25/16 4:18pm

I disagree. If we're playing well, there are many games that would be big games.

ol' Blue Eyes

5/25/16 4:32pm

That weak sched includes a home slate better than any in BYU's entire history

ALUF 1990

5/25/16 5:10pm

Yeah...get all the tougher games at home. Try playing them all over the country!

ol' Blue Eyes

5/25/16 7:04pm

OSU, WSU...can say the same thing about their schudules...

truecougster

5/25/16 7:23pm

I was addressing the ridiculous assertion by ol' Blue Eyes that Utah has a weak

ALUF 1990

5/26/16 8:49am

Yeah... thats bull

Dissenter

5/26/16 9:18am

Ok. Then explain what Bronco implied by independence being unsustainable. Does

ALUF 1990

5/26/16 11:33am

Bronco was wrong

Harrison0Yfan

5/26/16 8:08pm

This could get sideways between us in a hurry...so I'll say this

truecougster

5/26/16 11:42am

I understand what you're saying but that's part of the problem

TFL

5/26/16 12:18pm

The winning was a bonus - no doubt

truecougster

5/26/16 2:02pm

Mostly agree. I seriously doubt Whit is teaching players to hate BYU from day 1

ALUF 1990

5/26/16 2:40pm

I hate to say it but I have to...these are all valid points.

StalwartBraveTrue

5/26/16 5:24pm

Only the self worth of its fans.

mulletYno

5/25/16 10:56am

Reading that was the biggest waste of my time in the last 5 years.

Blue for Life

5/25/16 11:40am

Will benefit yewtah. Makes the rivalry game a bigger deal nationally

AZcougLawyer

5/25/16 12:31pm

But I guess that's more a benefit to the conferences than to yewtah.

AZcougLawyer

5/25/16 12:34pm

It would hurt Utah's recruiting. Utah and BYU compete for many of the same kids.

Posting on CougarBoard