My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jul 10, 2019
5:07
:48
pm
displacedute
All-American
Guidry was 2nd team last year.
I suspect he'll be at least 2nd this year.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
displacedute
Bio page
displacedute
Joined
May 30, 2005
Last login
Oct 18, 2024
Total posts
11,058 (29 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Phil Steele has Yewties ranked #8 pre-season... They're good, but not that good.
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 2:42pm
Crazy how much hype is built with 5 losses, a non-ranking, and a ring ceremony.
mulletino
7/10/19 2:44pm
Seriously, man. Any other pre-season top-10 teams lose their last two games?
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 2:49pm
Why would 2 losses to close out the season matter when the starting QB and star
BigBrotherUte
7/10/19 8:30pm
That would make a loss to BYU even more excruciating
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 8:45pm
Definitely the most experienced team in the county.
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 10:16pm
and without some major injury luck in Q3, they would have had a 6th loss to
Cougar76
7/10/19 2:49pm
We benefitted from their injury luck first. Losing their starting QB and RB helped us.
The Dude Abides
7/10/19 2:56pm
We were already down to 5th RB, 2nd string LB and both went out in Q3. Prior
Cougar76
7/10/19 3:02pm
I know. But we were playing them without their NFL RB and their starting QB.
The Dude Abides
7/10/19 3:06pm
I disagree. They were missing two key starters. We were missing lots more than
Cougar76
7/10/19 3:08pm
Ha okay. We had it way worse. Should have known better than to look at it rationally.
The Dude Abides
7/10/19 3:27pm
Correction: *”should have known better to look at it rationally.” You had an
Robbinoburrito
7/10/19 3:38pm
It's really interesting how much emphasis is placed on
TFL
7/10/19 4:20pm
I don’t know about all those details of your losses. No doubt you can point to crazy things that would have
The Dude Abides
7/10/19 4:32pm
Agreed. I didn't mean to come across like I was taking it all that seriously
TFL
7/10/19 4:42pm
Totally agree. I don’t see it crazy that they rank Utah high early. Utah has been
The Dude Abides
7/10/19 4:46pm
I root for BYU too...but have the benefit
TFL
7/10/19 4:53pm
It really is horrible when a tenured QB doesnt take you to new heights
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 5:07pm
And Tanner didn’t progress as much
TFL
7/10/19 6:26pm
*regressed
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 6:30pm
To be honest I am one of those fans that doesn’t care about Utah other than when
Robbinoburrito
7/10/19 4:48pm
I know - if BYU had scored more points, they totally would have won that game.
kos
7/10/19 7:54pm
Or if Utah has scored less, or if football ended after 3 periods like hockey, or
Robbinoburrito
7/10/19 8:06pm
QB is a big loss
Boring
7/10/19 4:43pm
Probably not. BYU has done better against Utah 1st String QBs than against ...
COACHdrn
7/10/19 5:09pm
We were on our second string QB in that game as well
sunjieming
7/10/19 11:35pm
RE: We were on our second string QB in that game as well
displacedute
7/10/19 11:44pm
freshman QB + 5/6 string RB but oh noes! - Utah lost their starters!
sunjieming
7/11/19 1:03am
Come on, man. BYU chose to replace Mangum with Wilson. They weren't forced to
kos
7/11/19 8:43am
No, not completely different. Who took first reps most of the season?
sunjieming
7/11/19 12:17pm
I’m not downplaying Utah’s injuries. I just don’t think they were uniquely bad
sunjieming
7/11/19 12:21pm
Yes, it is completely different. BYU changed their QB voluntarily because
kos
7/11/19 6:02pm
No way - BYU’s first choice was a decent Mangum but he underperformed. Wilson
sunjieming
7/11/19 6:19pm
Dude, when the "backup" is better than the starter, and continues to play when the "starter" can play...
Et Lux in Domino
7/11/19 6:52pm
Context, man. This whole discussion has been about how disadvantaged the teams
kos
7/11/19 7:13pm
I completely agree with this. We are all, of course familiar with the events of
Robbinoburrito
7/11/19 8:17pm
*Sigh*
Et Lux in Domino
7/11/19 11:18pm
It's ok. I get it.
Robbinoburrito
7/12/19 10:40am
And a new OC
JKLCoug
7/10/19 2:52pm
Redundant when discussing Utah/KWhitt.
mulletino
7/10/19 2:54pm
Phil is pretty good most of the time. I admittedly don't know much about
Jericho
7/10/19 2:44pm
They are only stacked at D. Their offense won’t be near good enough to make them
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 2:46pm
Huntley and Moss are a really good RB/QB combo.....
BoiseBlue
7/10/19 2:50pm
Their O line made Huntley and Moss do better than they are
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 3:30pm
Their offense really started clicking the second half of the season last year.
The Dude Abides
7/10/19 2:51pm
Then they brought in a *mostly* new OC. A bit of a restart. Bodes well.
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 2:52pm
The OC definitely creates some doubt. They have a lot of talent though. We’ll see.
The Dude Abides
7/10/19 2:54pm
He's brand new to their players. Which means a brand new playbook.
JKLCoug
7/10/19 2:55pm
During the streak, it hasn't apparently mattered who was their OC.
Everyman
7/10/19 4:38pm
Not underestimating him. But I'd rather them have a new OC than a tenured one.
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 4:39pm
BYU fans are weird about new OCs. Utah is still running the Spread. An inside
BigBrotherUte
7/10/19 8:19pm
Alright buddy let's see how the game goes I guess
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 10:17pm
Utah had 3 phases of playcalling last year.
jrj84105
7/10/19 11:04pm
Wait, what!
TFL
7/11/19 1:07am
Utah's OL returns 3 starters and has a top JUCO OT coming in.
displacedute
7/10/19 3:26pm
Its great he thinks they are that high
DazeofBlue
7/10/19 2:45pm
His power poll actually has them lower than that, but based upon their schedule
jreid191
7/10/19 2:48pm
Gotcha. Even so, I'd be shocked if they end up top-10 by the end of the season.
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 2:51pm
FPI and S&P suggest the following.
displacedute
7/10/19 3:25pm
I think Phil Steele is projecting 10-2 and winning Pac-12 for Utah
jreid191
7/10/19 3:41pm
If im the yewts I hate this. Sets them up for lambasting by some of their less rational fans
CLCougar
7/10/19 3:09pm
RE: If im the yewts I hate this. Sets them up for lambasting by some of their
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 3:34pm
BYU shouldn't have a 34% chance of beating the #8 team in the country. That fact
andrewg3
7/10/19 3:35pm
Did t we beat #6 Wisc last year?
Punk Philosopher
7/10/19 4:08pm
Exactly, and the odds were like 5%. I'm saying if Utah were really #8, the odds
andrewg3
7/10/19 4:35pm
60%? After 8 consecutive losses, you give BYU a 60% chance?
Et Lux in Domino
7/10/19 4:43pm
What does past performance have to do with this season's game? Wisc 2017 vs 2018
andrewg3
7/10/19 4:47pm
60% huh?
displacedute
7/10/19 4:46pm
Part of it is we're not coming off a 4-9 season
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 5:09pm
So is UTAH- expected to be better. Not coming off of a 4-9 season.
Et Lux in Domino
7/10/19 5:17pm
Utah is not expected to be better than Wisconsin was last year
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 5:24pm
I'm actually a very good reader. I'm 39, but have the reading skills of a 46-year-old. *You* didn't say anything about
Et Lux in Domino
7/10/19 5:51pm
He compared our chances of beating Wisconsin to our chances of beating Utah this
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 6:03pm
Okay. BOOM! Done...
Et Lux in Domino
7/10/19 6:15pm
LOL!!! The PAC12 is trying to claim that as a NC!!
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 6:32pm
Kinda embarrassing... Fortunately we didn't have any banners printed- 10 years after the fact.
Et Lux in Domino
7/10/19 6:42pm
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Utah lose anyone of significance on D?
Ned Schneebly
7/10/19 3:45pm
They lost a safety or two and two linebackers
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 4:05pm
Both safeties and both linebackers.
displacedute
7/10/19 5:00pm
Tareke Lewis could start at corner
DryFlyUte
7/10/19 5:17pm
Of Utah's 11 starters on D, Steele has 8 as 1st, 2nd, or 3rd Team All PAC-12.
Et Lux in Domino
7/10/19 4:55pm
Guidry was 2nd team last year.
displacedute
7/10/19 5:07pm
Bernard is overrated
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 5:09pm
We're happy to have him. 🙂
Et Lux in Domino
7/10/19 5:20pm
We're fairly stacked at LB
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 5:26pm
Your level of fence-sitting is, indeed, next-level.
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 7:25pm
I would have been happy to keep him if he could've gotten his act together.
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 7:26pm
Yes, but if he’s PAC 12 second team the PAC sucks
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 8:24pm
1. You know that there are only 12 teams in the PAC-12, right? 2. Those are 8 individual players, ranked 1, 2 or 3 team.
Et Lux in Domino
7/10/19 5:14pm
#8? Puh-leeeeeease. SMH.....
BleedCougarBlue2
7/10/19 4:58pm
Under Whitt, they’ve played well as the underdog.
D.T. Survivor
7/10/19 6:03pm
Schedule is very favorable to win a lot of games
BYU Fan
7/10/19 8:00pm
If they actually end up top-10, largely due to weakness of schedule, their bowl
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 8:05pm
Washington got beat up pretty good last year by a meh OSU
puntersarepeople
7/10/19 8:26pm
The Utes are a very good team...
tmurphey44
7/10/19 9:23pm
I never said they weren't good. They're just not the 8th best team...
DraperCoug22
7/10/19 10:17pm
I'm just saying that I think they are good and...
tmurphey44
7/10/19 10:48pm
I hope they rank them #1 before the BYU game
BYU4eVeR
7/10/19 9:52pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad