That's like making the jump from asst retail manager with a background as an incredible salesperson and giving them a VP role at corporate.

I don't doubt he can be successful, but there will be a steep learning curve, and I'm not convinced that BYU fans would be able to slog through a couple of years of mediocre offense while Detmer gets his bearings and learns on the job. College football is all about what you've done for me lately, even for superstars.