My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 18, 2015
8:26
:10
am
cal
Starter
Yea, but how much experience has he had on CougarBoard where true expertise is
developed?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
cal
Bio page
cal
Joined
Sep 28, 2001
Last login
May 2, 2024
Total posts
1,201 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
The idea that a 14-year NFL QB isn't qualified to be a D-1 OC is nuts.
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 7:14am
Why?
srey
12/18/15 7:15am
Especially when stated by those who complain that he's only a HS head coach
LV Mike
12/18/15 7:16am
Why? I can't think of one successful OC who was a 14 yr NFL QB.
Blueto
12/18/15 7:17am
How about a 14-yr NFL QB who spent 2 yrs as an NFL QB coach before being HC?
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 7:26am
We could go with Elder Gifford Nielsen
HangookCoug
12/18/15 7:24am
OC because of his playing career is nuts. I would love to take the risk and
AzCoug1
12/18/15 7:27am
Some are, some aren't. Gretzky coached a bad org. but won a gold medal as coach
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 7:38am
I do not subscribe to the theory that Detmer would succeed as an OC without
srey
12/18/15 7:40am
No.... No it's really not
Hoax
12/18/15 7:37am
I'll side Lavell on this one.
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 7:39am
Link?
srey
12/18/15 7:41am
Heard Lavell say it on 1280 last week.
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 8:00am
Say what? That BYU would be nuts not to hire Detmer as the OC?
srey
12/18/15 8:01am
Ty would be a fantastic OC for BYU. Not ready for HC, but would be a great OC.
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 10:55am
I'll have to look that up. Sounds incorrect.
srey
12/18/15 11:03am
Playing and coaching are completely different skills
Left Shark Coug
12/18/15 7:44am
Son of TX HS Coaching legend, Student of game, 14 year NFL, Heisman, Successful
Saxa
12/18/15 7:52am
Still not convinced. He's a great candidate for a QB coaching position with us.
srey
12/18/15 7:55am
I'd take the risk at OC based on his body of work. That's all I'm saying
Saxa
12/18/15 7:56am
His body of work does not include any experience in college coaching.
srey
12/18/15 7:59am
I would liken it more with taking a successful president of a small business
Saxa
12/18/15 8:10am
I can agree with that. I think Ty could be great, but I am also risk averse.
srey
12/18/15 8:13am
Absolutely understand
Saxa
12/18/15 9:57am
QB coach for Ty is totally insulting.
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 8:01am
Why?
srey
12/18/15 8:02am
He's more overqualified to be QB coach than Mitt is to be President of the USA.
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 8:06am
He's overqualified for a position that is 3 steps above the highest coaching job
srey
12/18/15 8:08am
He's way overqualified to be a BYU QB coach. NFL QB coach, fine.
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 8:29am
In what ways? Please don't take this as a criticism. It is more of a critique.
srey
12/18/15 8:36am
I'm sure you know my arguments and just reach a different conclusion
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 10:25am
How many 22 year old qb coaches are there? Very very few.
srey
12/18/15 10:34am
Well they don't stay 22 for more than a year but many start very young (24, 25)
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 10:54am
Slow clap. You got me...
srey
12/18/15 10:57am
Your posts on this topic remind me of some of these.
srey
12/18/15 11:02am
To be clear, he may be a terrible OC. Who knows?
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 11:30am
Yes, you provided all the detail I should have included
VenetianCougar
12/18/15 8:02am
I agree
Helm Hammerhand
12/18/15 7:52am
Wrong. That is a good start, but a lot more is required. My guess is Ty is
Y'zFan
12/18/15 8:10am
IMO, being a 14-year NFL QB doesn't necessarily qualify one to be a D1 OC
CopperLix
12/18/15 8:10am
But can he transfer that knowledge to 18-24 year old kids at every position?
srey
12/18/15 8:16am
Let's find out
Helm Hammerhand
12/18/15 8:19am
It's an intriguing proposition, but if we are hiring Sitake I think that hiring
srey
12/18/15 8:25am
I would feel more comfortable starting him as qb coach, but I still believe he
Helm Hammerhand
12/18/15 8:47am
Equating playing experience to coaching experience is what is really nuts.
shimmy
12/18/15 8:20am
Yea, but how much experience has he had on CougarBoard where true expertise is
cal
12/18/15 8:26am
Nice avatar
srey
12/18/15 8:26am
wow I've met my doppelganger
cal
12/18/15 8:35am
coaching is different than playing. how many of the "greats" are even successful coaches?
macaroni
12/18/15 9:11am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
