My need is to work towards being a big boy in college football not playing New mexico or Tulane as an "equal"

Aug 19, 2019
3:45:59pm

monkeycowboy Tenured Brofessor

We didnt make a ny6 as a G5, whos to say we would? Doing so would hurt BYU in a financial sense (i know i would be less likely to get season tickets and renew my CC donations if BYU "gave up)

Report problem with this ad

monkeycowboy

Bio page: monkeycowboy
Joined: Feb 14, 2011
Last login: Apr 7, 2020
Total posts: 53,942 (28,264 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I slowly feel myself leaning towards going back to G5. I've been pro indy, but

Powerbait DPM studnt

8/19/19 2:29pm

You and I are in agreement

Brigham

8/19/19 2:34pm

last night, my wife compared BYU's season to NFL preseason. The outcome means

Powerbait DPM studnt

8/19/19 2:36pm

Not much of a fan, that wife you've got there.:) sort of.

basman

8/19/19 2:38pm

She's the most passionate BYU fan I know. She'll stay up till 2-3am watching

Powerbait DPM studnt

8/19/19 2:42pm

Good for her I guess. But maybe deal with reality, and G5 isn't it.

Turnpike Lane

8/19/19 2:49pm

I hope you're right. Because I don't see us going back to G5, but sometimes I

Powerbait DPM studnt

8/19/19 2:50pm

The only way I'd agree is.....

bluegato

8/19/19 3:04pm

Every team has 'nothing to play for' after 2 conference losses, which is about

ptcougr

8/19/19 2:39pm

Utah had 3 losses (2 conference losses) but were still in conf. championship

Powerbait DPM studnt

8/19/19 2:44pm

Yeah, but that's P5. You were making a case for G5. Hardly the same situation.

Jesse Pinkman

8/19/19 3:05pm

I'm pro-Indy, but this argument is not the one to hang your hat on. It's false.

BerkeleyCoug

8/19/19 3:11pm

Yup.

777

8/19/19 3:12pm

5-6 of our regular season games are better than any bowl game

Dangerous

8/19/19 2:44pm

It's not that simple from a competitive standpoint. All of our games are front

777

8/19/19 3:05pm

This!!! We are 2-11 in Games 3 and 4 against P5 opponents since going Indy.

BerkeleyCoug

8/19/19 3:21pm

After this year, the schedules are way more balanced.

Dangerous

8/19/19 3:31pm

Not really, we are scheduled to open 2020-2023 with either 3 or 4 straight P5s

BerkeleyCoug

8/19/19 3:40pm

Many assume we'd win more games in a G5 conference. That's not the case for now

RealSimsShadY

8/19/19 2:47pm

So youd rather give up 2 to 3 P5 games a year for a chance to play 1 at the end of the year. Keep in mind BYU never

monkeycowboy

8/19/19 2:47pm

no, I want my cake and to eat it to haha. I already stated in OP that I don't

Powerbait DPM studnt

8/19/19 2:54pm

We can still play that many P5 games

shakarocks

8/19/19 3:28pm

4+ P5 games a year? (we have 6 next year, 7 in 2021) No we couldnt.

monkeycowboy

8/19/19 3:35pm

We can play enough P5 games to fit our needs

shakarocks

8/19/19 3:38pm

My need is to work towards being a big boy in college football not playing New mexico or Tulane as an "equal"

monkeycowboy

8/19/19 3:45pm

How have we been doing working towards that?

shakarocks

8/19/19 4:01pm

Upping the money that comes into the program, spending money on coaches and facilities. Stuff that wouldnt have happened

monkeycowboy

8/19/19 4:03pm

What coaches will more money attract? We aren't getting Nick Saban

shakarocks

8/19/19 4:08pm

RE: What coaches will more money attract? We aren't getting Nick Saban

monkeycowboy

8/19/19 4:09pm

You’ve got it wrong. Every game matters

puntersarepeople

8/19/19 2:53pm

Okay, go back to G5, and when you get tired of that come back to the Cougars.

BYU I Bleed Blue

8/19/19 2:59pm

^^ didn't read entire post.

Powerbait DPM studnt

8/19/19 3:04pm

RE: I slowly feel myself leaning towards going back to G5. I've been pro indy,

OGSuperfan

8/19/19 3:01pm

You are getting thumbs down for your conclusion, however, your point about

Ash

8/19/19 3:26pm

I'm actually really interested to know the amount of these kids that truly care

RealSimsShadY

8/19/19 3:34pm

It's a factor for recruits

shakarocks

8/19/19 3:45pm

And having 6 P5s in the future doesn't?

puntersarepeople

8/19/19 3:54pm

My evidence is anecdotal

shakarocks

8/19/19 3:59pm

I bet kids would rather play storied programs, in historic stadiums, than play

RealSimsShadY

8/19/19 4:07pm

What about a first place trophy?

shakarocks

8/19/19 4:10pm

Threw 10th out there without counting, but here we go

RealSimsShadY

8/19/19 4:50pm

I'd prefer Indy if we could get a few more consistent teams on the schedule

boscatar

8/19/19 3:45pm

The problem isn't independence, it's poor performance

boscatar

8/19/19 4:29pm

Amen

Yohy

8/19/19 5:00pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad