What is the ideal coaching blueprint for a BYU football coach?

Oct 2, 2019
8:58:02am

BYU Fan All-American

I think BYU will best succeed with a system of hard work, player development, and working to help build great young men by encouraging traditional Christian values (honor code) and education.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Oct 2, 2019 at 8:58:02am

Message modified by BYU Fan on Oct 2, 2019 at 9:09:58am

Report problem with this ad

BYU Fan

Bio page: BYU Fan
Joined: Mar 7, 2002
Last login: May 22, 2024
Total posts: 24,415 (1,076 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I don't have a clue what Sitake's philosophy is in leading the team

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 7:11am

I think the only idea we do know is he loves the players. Everyone says he's a

Preppy

10/2/19 7:20am

exactly. Players are going to get him fired

SL12

10/2/19 7:31am

I have not heard nor seen that they would run through a wall for him.

coolblue

10/2/19 8:30am

This has been my biggest criticism of Sitake.

TheLoneCougar

10/2/19 7:20am

In every sense of the saying he’s “learning on the job”

Tuskaloosa Cougar

10/2/19 2:25pm

But we forget, even Bronco felt there wasn't the support needed

Coug Dude

10/3/19 7:15pm

After thinking a moment, Sitake always says he wants to be another LaVell...a

Preppy

10/2/19 7:33am

I agree. I think he wanted to be a LaVell like figure.. but I don’t think he had

cougfanz

10/2/19 7:54am

The biggest difference is Lavell hired experienced assistants.

Richbyu

10/2/19 7:59am

Reno (buddy hire with no experience), cahoon (buddy hire with

cougfanz

10/2/19 8:06am

That only works if you have an OC and DC that handle the real game at a high

Fdnman

10/2/19 8:27am

I agree with this. kalani could be a great HC if he had the correct people in

Preppy

10/2/19 8:42am

I agree. If we had a good, experienced OC and DC, it would be different.

Richbyu

10/2/19 9:10am

I'm wondering if our coaches don't get "Lavell'd" by the BoT?

Borg

10/2/19 8:35am

That may work after building a program over 20 yrs. But I think Lavell had a definite philosophy and was far more

Soupie

10/2/19 9:36am

Bronco also had a great defense, had his 24 points or less each game goal so

BYUheaven

10/2/19 7:38am

17 points a game on d, 24 on o.

molodyets

10/2/19 7:43am

yep, my bad

BYUheaven

10/2/19 7:50am

Not sure what it is right now but when he came in I don’t think he had a set

cougfanz

10/2/19 7:41am

Sounds like the softball beer league approach to running a team

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 7:42am

I think the biggest issue was kalani didn’t bring in the bad cops to his good

cougfanz

10/2/19 7:51am

I believe Sitake would have undermined "bad cops" in his program at every

LV Mike

10/2/19 8:05am

Sitaki has said Norm Chow was Edwards' bad cop when Sitaki was a player. Who is

coastcat

10/2/19 8:27am

Have fun and make memories.

yorksama

10/2/19 8:08am

Warm memories of losing in Toledo to one of the worst defenses in the country.

LV Mike

10/2/19 8:14am

It’s fairly obvious; he even announced his philosophy just prior to the Utah game.

antiyewt

10/2/19 8:13am

Something more a parent would say to his kid

Borg

10/2/19 8:38am

Ugly losses count as memories I guess

Resurgens

10/2/19 1:55pm

He has no clue either. This team has no identity.

Count Cougar

10/2/19 8:25am

^^^BINGO^^^

CougarThug

10/2/19 8:40am

Sitake’s philosophy: “If you can’t beat ‘em, praise them for an entire 15 min conference all while blaming your guys.”

JohnnyComeLately

10/2/19 8:27am

Building memories. He told us himself.

coolblue

10/2/19 8:28am

His philosophy is wining 1 big game a year, lose to our rivals and

Turd Ferguson

10/2/19 8:33am

Maybe not the philosophy. But the results are spot on. Somehow these coaches

Preppy

10/2/19 8:45am

BYU fans forget what BYU's philosophy is...

TheLost

10/2/19 8:48am

I agree with a lot of what you say,

stev

10/2/19 9:16am

So from your observations and based on what you have seen, where does Sitaki put

coastcat

10/2/19 9:22am

100% winning...

TheLost

10/2/19 9:39am

Every other P5 team in the nation goes through that type of meat grinder during

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 9:45am

Right. But...BYU isn’t P5. The depth is building. Look at Utah’s first few

Blue Mountains

10/2/19 10:10am

Nope. I don't agree. Unless I go home and re-read D&C 20 and find I missed

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 9:29am

When did EQP, Bishop and Stake President become priesthood offices?

Shihan

10/2/19 2:08pm

Ok, if you want to nit pick and quibble over language, they're all priesthood

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 2:13pm

What is the ideal coaching blueprint for a BYU football coach?

BYU Fan

10/2/19 8:58am

CB fans don't want this..

TheLost

10/2/19 9:00am

Nice strawman. Nobody on CB thinks we can magically start landing top 10

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 9:14am

Sadly, I agree with this assessment of the current state of BYU Football.

coastcat

10/2/19 9:38am

Then change the scheduling... Put Idaho State at game 5

TheLost

10/2/19 9:45am

Another strawman

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 9:46am

more denial... BYU isn't P5

TheLost

10/2/19 9:53am

We're certainly not. We're in some weird limbo land somewhere between G5 and P5

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 9:59am

4 years at BYU is like 1 in CFB...

TheLost

10/2/19 10:13am

The things you're describing are lower-order coaching decisions. They're also

BYUMizzou

10/2/19 10:32am

On defense they play conversative and scared

I'mBatman

10/2/19 9:43am

Most people just don't have a clue ...

niqmadu

10/2/19 11:43am

Well put. I often disagreed with some of the ways Bronco did things but he is

Resurgens

10/2/19 1:52pm

Disagree. Sitake's philosophy is pretty clear IMO. He's a KWhitt disciple and

jkccoug

10/2/19 2:17pm

No chance of getting the same DB's WR's and RB's that Kwhit gets regularly

mtnKat

10/2/19 3:58pm

The guys that Whitt got when he was in the MWC turned out well too though.

jkccoug

10/3/19 9:57am

Not coming to BYU because of honor code, not related to conf affiliation.

mtnKat

10/3/19 2:44pm

They talk all the time about it being a family.

Yoopercoug

10/2/19 7:28pm

"Where there is no vision the people (team) perish." Proverbs

BlueForLife

10/3/19 5:03am

What worries me more neither does Kalani

Posting on CougarBoard