My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Oct 25, 2021
7:12
:24
am
chilawcoug
3rd String
<< Deleted >>
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Oct 25, 2021 at 7:12:24am
Message modified by chilawcoug on Oct 25, 2021 at 7:30:18am
Message modified by chilawcoug on Dec 23, 2022 at 12:04:21am
Report problem with this ad
chilawcoug
Bio page
chilawcoug
Joined
Mar 6, 2021
Last login
May 5, 2024
Total posts
2,525 (2 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Do we overstate the program rescuing jobs done by Bronco and Steve Cleveland?
dYrtbYkerYder
10/25/21 4:59am
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
10/25/21 5:08am
Yeah, this narrative doesn't work for me either.
dYrtbYkerYder
10/25/21 5:10am
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
10/25/21 5:12am
Bronco didn't save anything. He coached up great talent and then quit recruiting
MrClark
10/25/21 7:33am
RE: Well, it’s true. So keep living in your world. I’m sure it makes
icecougar
10/25/21 10:08am
Nonsense
HONOMO
10/25/21 7:30am
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
10/25/21 7:35am
Total fan fiction
icecougar
10/25/21 10:09am
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
10/25/21 10:31am
Totally agree. Many people wondered whether BYU football would be viable with
MDub1
10/25/21 10:17am
Hindsight is a nice thing, ain't it?
HoustonBYUCoug
10/25/21 5:08am
The powers that be were asking LaVell Edwards if he thought BYU football could
gwalker
10/25/21 5:29am
Good points. Steve Cleveland took over a program that had hit
HighHorse
10/25/21 5:40am
He also went to the dorms to beg students to attend. Steve did a great job.
TempeCoug
10/25/21 6:46am
Asking the question and it being likely are very very different things.
HONOMO
10/25/21 7:34am
Point well made.
wilsdad
10/25/21 8:15am
Just because someone else could have done the job doesn’t mean we can’t give
ColonelMustard
10/25/21 9:28am
Giving credit ≠ hero worship.
wilsdad
10/25/21 1:18pm
I don’t consider him a hero, but I’m
ColonelMustard
10/25/21 5:33pm
<< Deleted >>
All-American
10/25/21 8:28am
I know exactly the BYU speech you are talking about, thanks for reminding me
SSCoug15
10/25/21 9:13am
Great points. Look at all the programs who’ve gone to 💩 after losing a great HC
GeraldGarner
10/25/21 9:26am
Neither team needed "saving". They both had been through rocky periods and...
icecougar
10/25/21 10:19am
Bronco inherited a lot of talent, whereas Cleveland did not
donnerstag
10/25/21 6:07am
It was 2005 where Bronco was genius.
Carnac
10/25/21 6:39am
The schedule was just flat easier in 2005 than 2004
donnerstag
10/25/21 8:00am
"If's" are not worth bringing up, "If" Curtis Brown
kooogar
10/25/21 8:09am
That TCU game still makes me so mad, 16 years later...
Carnac
10/25/21 8:10am
Was so frustrating, seems like we got a bad call at the end at home also.
kooogar
10/25/21 8:22am
100%
icecougar
10/25/21 10:13am
Disagree. 2004 team learned plenty about winning as a very young team playing...
icecougar
10/25/21 9:59am
Gotta learn to win sometimes. Our guys didn't know how.
Carnac
10/25/21 10:07am
They had been learning. I do agree that they were still maturing..
icecougar
10/25/21 11:48am
I was at that UNM game.
bad84cougar
10/25/21 8:31pm
I will forever appreciate Bronco
Carnac
10/25/21 6:32am
Cleveland was amazing
(Private)
10/25/21 6:38am
Cleveland IS amazing--everything I hear about him is that
Carnac
10/25/21 6:43am
We forget how insanely difficult the schedules were in the Crowton era
krindorr
10/25/21 6:55am
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
10/25/21 7:12am
It's true but he was .500 in conference play those last few years which
kooogar
10/25/21 8:26am
Very true. Along with the fact that our QBs were constantly hurt. Lotsa bad luck
Parker Schnabel
10/25/21 5:25pm
No. Many programs with good infrastructure have crashed and never recovered.
shoganai
10/25/21 7:11am
You make it sound like we could just plug any coach and it would have rebounded.
Metallicat
10/25/21 7:16am
Any coach? Of course not. Was Bronco the only coach who could have had success?
HONOMO
10/25/21 7:44am
Nobody said “no other coaches could have done it.” But the OP makes it sound
Metallicat
10/25/21 8:44am
I gotcha. I agree with everything you said.
HONOMO
10/25/21 8:47am
FSU, Nebraska, Texas, and Tennessee have been changing coaches like crazy and it
thewaterboy
10/25/21 7:46am
It is pretty crazy he was able to hit the ground running and have only winning
HONOMO
10/25/21 7:53am
Miami
kooogar
10/25/21 8:28am
Also true
thewaterboy
10/25/21 8:48am
Gotta give credit where credit is due. Cleveland and Bronco did great work
BlooCoog
10/25/21 7:23am
No kidding. Whoever saves FSU or Nebraska is going to be praised.
(Private)
10/25/21 8:28am
Think about the parallels between Utah basketball and BYU football
krindorr
10/25/21 7:49am
Cleveland took over a 1 win team and was in the NIT by his 3rd season, NCAA by
thewaterboy
10/25/21 7:56am
Also, it was harder back then to flip teams than compared to now since the
TempeCoug
10/25/21 8:57am
And in his prime, he didn’t lose at home
stoils
10/25/21 11:21am
“Not trying to discredit either one” 😂… that is exactly what you are doing
Pretorian
10/25/21 8:25am
No. Multiple BOT members were openly asking if BYU really needed football.
All-American
10/25/21 8:28am
Sincerely, Nebraska
Johnny Vatos
10/25/21 8:50am
Nebraska kind of makes sense. Texas is the one where I'm like.... what?
HONOMO
10/25/21 9:08am
No.
nova_coug_fan
10/25/21 9:16am
They were both needed and both of them rescued programs in serious trouble
nybyblue
10/25/21 9:24am
no
ColoSpgs
10/25/21 9:31am
BOT was on the verge of cancelling the program. Bronco ran a clean
coolblue
10/25/21 10:25am
They both needed to be brought back quickly to preserve the fan base. And that's what they did. Time was of the essence.
lightmann
10/25/21 10:36am
No we don't overstate Bronco's rescue job. Just take a look at UVA's program
greatbam
10/25/21 11:34am
Went from dumpster fire to bowl eligible 5 out of 6 years
GeraldGarner
10/26/21 9:43am
Report problem with this ad
Report problem with this ad