OP said "seem to have found some data" on drop 8. As in, he has no idea. A post

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 8, 2022
4:06:07pm

OldFogey All-American

OP said "seem to have found some data" on drop 8. As in, he has no idea. A post

with so much speculation is not a great post - especially when he jumps to his next conclusion that "it's not hard to imagine data that would support this. It does, however, feed into rash judgments by armchair QBs. lol But go ahead...keep encouraging him.

Report problem with this ad

OldFogey

Bio page: OldFogey
Joined: Oct 1, 2018
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 3,474 (5 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

KS and misapplied "analytics"

Milton

12/8/22 2:01pm

Excellent post. Thanks.

ArcticKat

12/8/22 2:08pm

I think a major miss on 4th down analytics everywhere is factoring in momentum.

12/8/22 2:09pm

I love the 4th down calls. Just come up with better plays. Why does it have to

Iman23

12/8/22 2:17pm

and don't repeatedly call the same QB sneak when your QB is gun shy about...

icecougar

12/8/22 2:27pm

Or use a FB or not the RBs that get tackled on first contact

braddahmike

12/8/22 3:23pm

^^^^^^this. Use a FB or lead blocker at least!

12/8/22 6:23pm

Analytics just don’t work in football. It’s a lot different than baseball or BB.

Senora Featherbottom

12/8/22 2:09pm

This could be very true...11 moving parts instead of a pitcher and hitter etc

Tmoney1969

12/8/22 2:12pm

I think its overrated in basketball too. Seen way to many coaches rely on it

FT487

12/8/22 2:19pm

Quin Snyder

CameronG

12/8/22 4:00pm

Like Pope?

Wyomingite

12/8/22 8:05pm

Many coaches

FT487

12/8/22 8:21pm

I would say analytics are even overrated in basketball

CameronG

12/8/22 3:58pm

"analytics" are just "stats" so you can read into them how you want

12/8/22 2:10pm

Exactly, I hate that so many decisions now are based "on the numbers"

CameronG

12/8/22 3:55pm

There is a lot of analystics that now support going for it on short distances

I'mBatman

12/8/22 2:17pm

i'll continue my argument on 4th analytics. Be aggressive, but for Heavens sake

CougID

12/8/22 2:18pm

The Recruiting Measurables and Diamond in the rough really bothers me a lot....

Coug

12/8/22 2:36pm

All analytics based on averages should be…

coug92

12/8/22 3:00pm

Here's a simple fact about why offenses end up making mistakes:

TrueBlue67

12/8/22 3:10pm

If you don't know what the stats themselves are, or what they indicate, not sure

OldFogey

12/8/22 3:30pm

Exactly. You also need to know what they don't indicate.

cdr88

12/8/22 3:50pm

Great post. They should also run stats on allowing drives of 10 or more plays

cdr88

12/8/22 3:57pm

OP said "seem to have found some data" on drop 8. As in, he has no idea. A post

OldFogey

12/8/22 4:06pm

I think the point of the OP is that the data shouldn't be the end all be all

CameronG

12/8/22 4:23pm

I get all that. Just calling out that the OP makes a ton of assumptions

OldFogey

12/8/22 7:10pm

Very well thought out

CharlottesvilleCoug

12/8/22 4:21pm

The worst part of “analytics” is misinterpretation/misapplication.

HiLife

12/8/22 5:00pm

Same. Usually the analytics were used to justify a decision already made.

Ripliancum

12/8/22 5:30pm

One that drives me crazy is kick off returns

Jacob

12/8/22 6:09pm

Thank you - great example! Explains why we kept kicking to the USF returner

Milton

12/8/22 7:08pm

On Drop 8, it actually WOULD have worked IF we had been better in 3rd and long

12/8/22 6:20pm

They had those percentages because Drop 8 gets no pressure on the QB

CameronG

12/9/22 9:59am

I generally agree, but Drop 8 is used by almost every CFB team

12/9/22 12:05pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad