Disagree - Independence if we can't get into a P5

Report problem with this ad

Sep 12, 2017
6:16:05pm

Pobs Starter

Report problem with this ad

Pobs

Previous username: Pobs73
Bio page: Pobs
Joined: Mar 7, 2002
Last login: May 31, 2024
Total posts: 2,264 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Independence vs. MWC

jrodute

9/12/17 2:05pm

Independence to the death before a return to the MWC. Curious-- once the Utes lose a couple games, don't you no longer

soupie

9/12/17 2:06pm

RE: Independence to the death before a return to the MWC. Curious-- once the

jrodute

9/12/17 2:15pm

Yes, I think indy is better than MWC for recruiting. Just look at the difference in teams played & TV.

soupie

9/12/17 2:17pm

Don't you think recruits would rather play on ESPN every week rather than a channel no one has including pac12 channels?

Rhino84

9/12/17 3:21pm

They impact the conference all season. When are they officially out? Lose two

Cougarfan777

9/12/17 2:15pm

BYU can act as a spoiler too. Just ask TX & Neb & Ok.

soupie

9/12/17 2:18pm

All those teams can still win their conference. As the Big 12 found out,

Cougarfan777

9/12/17 2:22pm

It's different for Utah

TFL

9/12/17 2:22pm

Same record in PAC 12 as same record as Indy is already proven to get you the

Tuskaloosa Cougar

9/12/17 4:01pm

no. mwc conf champ is about as meaningful as the portland state game.

smokymountainrain

9/12/17 2:06pm

We couldn't win it this year.

CougarinOZ

9/12/17 2:39pm

But better than BYU has done during indy plus MWC/AAC Champ can go NY6.

blackshirts

9/12/17 2:46pm

While my team is in the MWC, I think I speak for the my BYU brothers when I say

Dread Pirate Westley

9/12/17 2:09pm

BYU was in a no win situation once passed over by the PAC 10 & Big 12

BYU Fan

9/12/17 2:11pm

Don't you think this is a silly question?

Eddie

9/12/17 2:14pm

RE: Don't you think this is a silly question?

jrodute

9/12/17 2:34pm

Would if they could. Boise has no other choices. They have no other invites & aren't capable of going Indy.

soupie

9/12/17 2:38pm

I don't think many of us look at Boise and feel any envy for their situation.

ray ray

9/12/17 2:42pm

And you see no connection between Indy and the quality of our teams?

Cougarfan777

9/12/17 3:24pm

I do, but I think our recruiting versus MWC is better.

ray ray

9/12/17 3:41pm

BYU can point to it's schedule and say for a fact that a recruit can play on some of the biggest stages in the country.

Rhino84

9/12/17 3:25pm

Yes, we get to play 3-4 "brand" games a year, but then we're stuck playing a

CougLuv1

9/12/17 5:56pm

There is no reason why we couldn't assemble the same meat grinder schedule in

Junior Deputy

9/12/17 6:15pm

I just like playing for something vs. Playing for nothing.

CougarinOZ

9/12/17 9:13pm

The NCAA football landscape has changed.

Eddie

9/13/17 8:47am

Never MWC. I would prefer we convince Boise to join the AAC with us.

Junior Deputy

9/12/17 2:17pm

RE: Never MWC. I would prefer we convince Boise to join the AAC with us.

jrodute

9/12/17 2:23pm

BYU has a national fan base. The AAC is far less regional than the MWC.

Junior Deputy

9/12/17 2:29pm

Superiority complex. We were in the same conference as all those teams for

Cougarfan777

9/12/17 2:29pm

All of the sudden?

BYUFam1

9/12/17 3:43pm

Also you mentioned "we continue to lose to them"

BYUFam1

9/12/17 10:22pm

Nothing to play for argument is oversold. Any team that looses its first couple

ray ray

9/12/17 2:20pm

Many BYU fans are sick of independence...

Cougarfan777

9/12/17 2:23pm

Didn't BYU have some solid wins vs. Miss. State, Mich State and AZ?

TFL

9/12/17 2:29pm

This is crap. They are tired of losing. Apples and oranges comparisons are given and they think all of a sudden a

Rhino84

9/12/17 3:30pm

Disagree - Independence if we can't get into a P5

Pobs

9/12/17 6:16pm

MWC 100%. BYU can't get back in that conference fast enough for me.

CougarinOZ

9/12/17 2:39pm

or AAC.

blackshirts

9/12/17 2:43pm

Only if we get to bring Boise, SDSU, and AFA and get Navy and Houston in our div

boscatar

9/12/17 3:00pm

I don't think anyone is saying that these teams are more talented.

Eddie

9/12/17 2:48pm

I dont think the # is significant.

CougarinOZ

9/12/17 3:40pm

They got out because they could make much more money as an independent.

Bullrider

9/12/17 2:59pm

I think TV, $, and conference could all work out if BYU wanted back in.

CougarinOZ

9/12/17 3:46pm

Why do you assume they would even want us? The MWC was more than just

Bullrider

9/12/17 8:03pm

Maybe you're right. However I think they will work with us.

CougarinOZ

9/12/17 9:15pm

Good point. Part of what made the MWC days fun was

TFL

9/12/17 3:03pm

There have been changes, but it's all nuance.

Eddie

9/13/17 8:53am

Crazy talk. Myself and countless other fans would be done as seriuous

kotacoug

9/12/17 3:17pm

Go down fighting? When? Why can't you be in a conference and still fight?

Cougarfan777

9/12/17 3:19pm

Go down fighting to be either independent or a P5 member

kotacoug

9/12/17 3:47pm

I think your opinion is a minority opinion. Most BYU fans were fans in the MWC

CougarinOZ

9/12/17 3:53pm

Yea, it sucks in November when we have to play MWC teams.

Rhino84

9/12/17 3:55pm

Yeah, because Wyoming almost beat us in the Holiday bowl.

coldcoug

9/12/17 7:39pm

Games in November are going to suck either way with being independent or in a

kotacoug

9/12/17 4:02pm

Fresno, SJSU, UNLV, HI down the stretch would mean more if BYU were in the MWC

boscatar

9/13/17 8:35am

Lesser quality opponent is alright if the games count for something.

CougarinOZ

9/12/17 5:26pm

Nope. not a minority. I agree with him.

Pobs

9/13/17 2:30pm

Question: Do you have an issue with the targeting or targeting call? Just checking for credibility....

Refugee

9/12/17 3:13pm

RE: Question: Do you have an issue with the targeting or targeting call? Just

jrodute

9/12/17 3:27pm

Yes, on Sunia...

Refugee

9/12/17 3:33pm

<< Deleted >>

jrodute

9/12/17 3:26pm

MWC is the better short term option.

Big Time 55

9/12/17 3:31pm

See...this is what yewts hope and pray for more than for their team winning the

ol' Blue Eyes

9/12/17 3:55pm

RE: See...this is what yewts hope and pray for more than for their team winning

jrodute

9/12/17 4:07pm

I don't think the board is very split on this subject. There is a lot of

ray ray

9/12/17 5:49pm

I disagree. Utah's performance in

TFL

9/12/17 4:36pm

How many MWC championships did yewta win compared to BYU?

ol' Blue Eyes

9/12/17 4:55pm

RE: How many MWC championships did yewta win compared to BYU?

JustmeintheSLC

9/12/17 5:54pm

This years schedule is no better than a MW schedule. In a lot of ways it's worse

jackcrack7

9/12/17 4:25pm

There are many who think it's going backwards. It's not!! They are worried about

blackshirts

9/12/17 9:09pm

BYU would not schedule Utah, LSU, Wisconsin and Mississippi St. if in the MWC

boscatar

9/13/17 8:37am

Why not?

jackcrack7

9/13/17 9:24am

*Some of the OOC schedule - not the entire OOC schedule.

boscatar

9/13/17 9:39am

This year the schedule has 3 plus Utah.

jackcrack7

9/13/17 10:08am

Last year BYU had 6; next year 5. '20 has 6. '21 has 7. Can't do that w/ G5 sked

boscatar

9/13/17 10:33am

Troll much? Beyond TV exposure, better competition, and more money...

Stalwart Man

9/12/17 5:24pm

I'd move the school back to MWC so fast...ya'lls heads would spin

byuguns55

9/12/17 8:40pm

Less exposure...less money...fewer fun games...less prestige/recognition.

ol' Blue Eyes

9/12/17 9:56pm

Those are the founding lies of Independence

CougarinOZ

9/13/17 8:13am

Your first point is exactly why BYU is not in the MWC. The MWC didn't abide by an earlier agreement to allow

Rhino84

9/13/17 8:37am

AAC western expansion, that includes Boise St. and Gonzaga...

boscatar

9/13/17 8:37am

no way. pull back from the ledge.

Pobs

9/13/17 2:32pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad