So I looked up performance against "BCS" defenses - teams in BCS leagues (and Boise).
Jamaal:
Washington: 12/31, 2.6
Notre Dame: 18/43, 2.4
Wisconsin: 14/76, 5.4
Boise: 21/107, 5.1
Ga Tech: 17/86, 5.1
Utah: 13/52, 4.0
Texas: 30/182, 6.1
Virginia: 33/144, 4.4
Ga. Tech: 28/107, 3.8
Notre Dame: 14/64, 4.6
Oregon St.: 15/36, 2.4
Boise: 1/6, 6.0
WSU: 6/15, 2.5
Harvey:
Oregon St.: 24/71, 3.0
Utah: 23/116, 5.0
TCU: 23/123, 5.9
Florida State: 10/97, 9.7
Arizona: 17/71, 4.2
Utah: 15/116, 7.7
TCU: 14/53, 3.8
UCLA: 17/71, 4.2
Washington: 23/136, 5.9
UCLA: 17/16, 0.9
Utah: 23/141, 6.1
TCU: 16/64, 4.0
UCLA: 5/28, 5.6
Arizona: 15/67, 4.5
I'd give the edge to Harvey against "BCS" defenses, but both had really good games and bad games/